[PDF] The Slogan Back to the Quran and the Sunna:

View - Download The Slogan Back to the Quran and the Sunna:

Previous PDF

Next PDF

TheSlogan"BacktotheQur'anandtheSunna":

AComparative Studyofthe Responsesof

ijasanandNurcholishMadjid

Athesissubmittedto

theFaeultyofGraduateStudiesandReseareh inpartialfulfillmentoftherequirementsof thedegreeofDoetorofPhilosophy by

YudianWahyudi

TheInstituteofIslamieStudies

MeGillUniversity,Montreal,Canada

(2002) 1+1

NationalLibrary

ofCanada

Acquisitionsand

BibliographieServices

395WellingtonStreet

OttawaONK1AON4

canada

Bibliothèquenationale

duCanada

Acquisitionset

servicesbibliographiques

395,rueWellington

OttawaONK1A

ON4 canada

YourfileVoileréférenoe

OurfileNoIJeréfét8noe

Theauthorbasgrantedanon

exclusivelicenceallowing the

NationalLibraryofCanadato

reproduce,loan,distributeorsell copiesofthisthesisinmicroform, paperorelectronicformats.

Theauthorretainsownershipofthe

copyrightinthisthesis.Neitherthe thesisnorsubstantialextracts fromit maybeprintedorotherwise reproducedwithout theauthor's pemnSSIOn.

L'auteuraaccordéunelicencenon

exclusivepermettant

àla

Bibliothèquenationale

duCanadade reproduire,prêter,distribuer ou vendredescopiesdecettethèsesous la formedemicrofiche/film,de reproductionsurpapierousurformat

électronique.

L'auteurconservelapropriété

du droitd'auteurquiprotègecettethèse. Ni lathèsenidesextraitssubstantiels decelle-cinedoiventêtreimprimés ouautrementreproduitssansson autorisation.

0-612-78794-X

Canada

To:

MyMother,who,thoughnevertaughttoread,

compareseverything ii

Author

Title

Abstract

:YudianWahyudi Study oftheResponsesofijasanal

Jabir1andNurcholishMadjid

Department:InstituteofIslamicStudies,

McGillUniversity

Degree:DoctorofPhilosophy

ijasan

NurcholishMadjid(Indonesia,

b.1939)totheslogan"BacktotheQur'anand astheideal inthelightof factorsthathaveledtothedecline ofIslaminthemodemagewillbe comparedfromtheperspective ofthefirstandseconddimensionsofhis heritages,respectively,forthereform ofIslam.Itis,however,inthecontextof thethirddimension practice totheQur' iii traditional. IV

Auteur

Titre

Department

Diplôme

Résumé

:YudianWahyudi :Leslogandu"retourauCoranet

àlaSunna":Uneétude

Muq.ammad

etdeNurcholishMadjid :DoctoratèsPhilosophie

Cettethèsecomparelesréponses

d'ijasan(néenEgypte1935), ijanafi,mieuxconnue sousle titreHéritageetModernité facteursexpliquantledéclindel'Islamde l'èremoderne,serontdonc ijanafiqui etoccidentaux troisièmedimensionduprojetde v VI

TableofContents

Dedication,

ii

Abstract,iii

Table ofContents,vi

System

ofTransliteration,viii

Acknowledgements,ix

Introduction,1

Chapter

theIdealSolutiontotheDecline ofIslaminthe

ModemAge:AHistoricalIntroduction,14

ChapterII:

ijasanand

NurcholishMadjid:GeneralSimilaritiesand

Differences,114

ChapterIII:TheHermeneutics

oftheRetumtotheQur'an andtheSunna,207

Conclusion,295

Bibliography,309

Appendix:AList

ofEnglish-ArabicTerms,353 VIl

SystemofTransliteration

Arabie

"Nur "NahdlatulUlama"ratherthan "NahqataI-'Ulama'."ThesameaIsoappliesto oftheiroldornew onward)are example beeomesulama. Vlll

Acknowledgements

K.H.AbdurrahmanWahid(formerPresident

oftheRepublicofIndonesia)for introducing Minal 'Aqfda havealsomyundyinggratitudeforshowingsuch tremendouspatienceand understandingwithrespecttothenature ofmyproject.Theircritical asweIlMr.Steve thestudy

JoannaGacek)forproviding

mewithafullscholarshiptodomyPh.D. continuemystudiesatMcGillUniversity.K.H.

AR.Fakhruddin(former

IX ofmywife'sRA. thesis. 1 (DirectorGeneral fortheCandidates recentgraduates universities.2

1wouldalsothankProf.

ijasanforpersonallyhelpingmeto ofDr.lam'a's ofAhmadAzhar

Basyir'sThought],"inYudianWahyudi,ed.,

TheQur'a-nandPhilosophical

Reflections

2Nineteengraduates

Universitytocelebrateitstenthanniversary. SeeYudianWahyudi,Akh.

MinhajiandArnimlRadi,eds.,

TheDynamicsofIslamicCivilization:Satu

DasawarsaProgramPembibitan

(1988-1998)[ADecadeoftheProgram x presentation,Dr. of booksonboth ofthepublictransport thatweweretaking!

Dr.'Ali

preliminaryquestionsconceming ijanafi'sreformprojectandgavemea number oftheretumtothe

Qur'an.

kindlyinvited metodeliver"ACritieal EvaluationoftheBaekwardnessof

1wouldalsoliketothankhereMr.Edward

A.Silooy,wholentmehis

colossalsupportduringmyterms aspresidentoftheIndonesianStudents Xl

PengalamanBelajar

IslamdiKanada,

3

McGillUniversity,Montreal,Kanada,4

andIslamandDevelopment:ASocio-

ReligiousPoliticalResponse.

5

Hisbenevolencealsomadeitpossibleforthe

TheQur'a-nand

PhilosophicalReflection,

6

KyaiHajiAbdulWahidHasyim,7andAn

8

Kanada

PERMIKA-TitianllahiPress,1997).

ItwaslaunchedatMcGillUniversityon

May

2,1997.

Institute

GuidetoStudyingattheInstitute

ofIslarnicStudies,McGillUniversity,

LembagaPenterjemah

McGillUniversityonNovember10,1997.

5SeeSriMulyati, UjangTholibandIftitahJafar,eds.,Islam&

&PenulisMuslim

Indonesia,1997).

ItwaslaunchedatMcGillonDecember10,1997.

UniversityonJune22,1998.

TwentiethCentury

ofthebook,seeR. xii formedparts neverheretoforepublished.Thusmypaperon "ijasanConceptofal-

September

Sunna'

,"readatthe34 th

AnnualMeetingoftheMiddleEastStudies

AssociationheldinOrlando,Florida,from17-19November,2000, formsa part

2001bythe

University

MohammedArkounandEdward

W.Said,constitutesaverysmallpartofmy

AssociationBulletinvol.

33no.l(Summer1999):86.

ItwaslaunchedinTorontoon30November1999.

xiii (nowforrningaverysmallpart ofmyChapter1);"EgyptianResponsestothe sametime1hadto th on17-20November,2001(nowforrningaportion ofChapterII).

As1approachtheend

oftheseacknowledgements,1wouldlikealsoto

A.Malik

Madani(ofthe

Shad'aFaculty,theSunanKalijaga IAIN,where1teach

SudarkamMertosono,Munir

A.Muin,Mujiburrahman,LabibahZain,

MustafidDahlan(Cairo)and

[Thu]SandraThibaudeau,tonameonlyafew,for ofthelibrary xiv neededduringmystudies. to

Al-Asmin:A

PocketDictionary

dedicatedtohimthat1finishedcompilingin

1991duringmyfirstsemesterat

theInstitute.Perhapswiththecompletion ofthisthesis1willbeabletofulfill thistask.

Lastbutnotleast,

returnstoIndonesia,"whilemywife -whoasDr.Federspielconstantly

Montreal.Inclosingletmesaythat,despite

aIltheassistanceandsuggestions that1havereceivedinthecourse ofwritingthisdissertation,1alonebear responsibilityforany ofitsshortcomings.

Montreal,March

1,2002

Y.W. xv

Introduction

'ilmal-fiqh essence sidesofthedebate thuspuritan,idealist,andfundamentalist intheirstrictefforttoadaptrealityto

Scripture.The

ofmakinghistory.Theyareforthisreason moreliberalandrealistintheir willingnesstoexploreothersources ofScripture.Thedivineguaranteeofthis everlastingdialecticiscalled tajdfd,whichisoftencoupledwith 2 processoftajdfdisviewed asacentenarycycle,basedontheProphet people religionforit."J

Theslogan"Back

ofrevelationinthisdialectic.

Thiswasthecaseinsuchclassicconflicts

ofauthorityasthoseofthe

Kharijitesversus'Aliibn

AbltheAbbasidrevolutionarymovement

againsttheUmayyads,and risetosorne idealIslam,while 2 John

Islah,"inJohn

Oxford:OxfordUniversityPress,1983),32.

J

Thought:AStudy

diss.,McGillUniversity,1996),2. 3 4 becomingmoreandmorea"conqueredideology" bytheeveoftheeighteenth century(coming ofIslaminthemodernera.

Theslogan,

fromtheyoke slogancanbeseeninthewritings ofMuslimintellectualsfromeverycorner andNurcholishMadjid. salaj[("puritan"and "fundamentalist")truth ofthesloganinatajdfd(modernandeven contemporary)way.Theproject,for

Mal).mudAniinal-'Alim,indicates

4JohnL.Esposito,IslamandPoUties,3

rd edition(NewYork:Syracuse

UniversityPress,1991),37.

K.S.Lambton,BernardLewis,eds.,

TheCambridgeHistoryofIslam

4 'ulama'evenaccusedhim ofunbeliefin1997forhisformulations,while

IbrahIm

8

Likewise,

"AI-Turathwa 'ArabI"(Criticism ("fundamentalism") 10 (themodem pioneer

DarFikriyya,1997),Il.

FazlurRahmanwa

I-JasaninAl).mad'Abdal-I-Jafimed.,

Jadalal-Ana-wa

al-Sittln(Cairo:Madbufi1997),107-113.

L'Harmattan,1993),

131.
quotesdbs_dbs14.pdfusesText_20

[PDF] your bac maroc

[PDF] your bac maroc شاهيد لحسن

[PDF] your bac maroc ????? ????

[PDF] your bac svt

[PDF] your family or mine (2015) nancy berggren

[PDF] your turn page 127 2as

[PDF] yourbac maroc

[PDF] youssoupha bac francais

[PDF] youtube 2016 nouvelle star

[PDF] youtube action movies full movies english 2014

[PDF] youtube alain soral juillet 2016

[PDF] youtube algebra

[PDF] youtube bac algerie 2013

[PDF] youtube bac histoire geographie

[PDF] youtube bac libre adab