concept selection report
|
Concept Generation & Concept Selection
Concept Generation & Concept Selection Report 2 Submitted towards partial fulfillment of the requirements for Mechanical Engineering Design – Fall 2012 Department of Mechanical Engineering Northern Arizona University Flagstaff AZ 86011 |
|
CONCEPT SCREENING AND SELECTION
I Use your need criteria as a way to select a manageable set of preliminary concepts following brainstorming II Summarize your research in the areas of intellectual property regulation business model/payment and prototyping/testing to screen your preliminary concepts III |
|
Concept Selection
Concept Selection: The final design of the project was selected using analytical tools such as House of Quality Pugh Chart and Analytical Hierarchy Process (AHP) The five medium-fidelity and three high-fidelity concepts developed during concept generation were initially considered and assessed using concept selection tools |
Are concept selection tools useful in engineering design?
The evaluation of the utility of concept selection tools in the engineering design process is important because these tools were developed as a means to aid decision makers in the fuzzy-front end of the design process—a stage of design that is rife with ambiguities and uncertainties [ 20 ].
Does concept selection bias the design process?
This means that the judgments students make on which ideas to consider and thus put into the concept selection tool can bias the decision making very early on in the design process.
Wrong Ways to Do Screening
Gut feelBoss says, “Do it this way”Single customer decidesOne team member is strong champion linkedin.com
Better Ways to screen Concept
Multi-votingEach team member votes for several concepts. The concept with the most votes is selected.Pros and consThe team lists the strengths and weaknesses of each concepts. The group then selects the best concept based on group opinion. linkedin.com
Preferred Concept Selection Process
Decision MatricesStart with a Product Design SpecificationExamine ALL concepts at the same timeCan be weighted or un-weighted linkedin.com
Benefits of A Structured Concept Selection Method
A customer-focused productA competitive designBetter product-process coordinationReduced time to product introduction linkedin.com
Two Stages of Concept Selection
Concept screening 1. Reduce the many product concept ideas generated to a relative few that will get additional refinement and analysis Concept scoring 1. Use objective methods to select to your consensus final concept selection linkedin.com
Concept Screening
Prepare the selection/screening matrix 1. Selection criteria must relate to key customer needs Rate the concepts 1. + = “better than” 2. 0 = “same as” 3. − = “worse than” Rank the concepts 1. As objectively as possible using the concept rating Combine and improve the concepts 1. Is there a generally good concept that is downgraded by one feature? 2
Commons Pitfalls in Concept Selection
Not doing itRunning with the first ideaForgetting the customerSelection chart criteria don't correspond to PDS linkedin.com
Concept Selection process Concept screening and Concept scoring Product design and development
Concept Select Decision Matrix Pugh Matrix
Overview of Project Selection Concepts / Methods / Techniques
|
Requirements for the planning of and consent to UKCS Field
concept the Field Operator should provide a. Concept Select report to the OGA that summarises the information and requirements which led. |
|
COMPARISON OF FOUR EXISTING CONCEPT SELECTION
Concept selection is an activity in the product design process where alternative concepts are compared and a decision is made to select the alternative(s) |
|
Acorn CCS Project: D24 Concept Options Report
8 nov. 2019 D11 Onshore Site Selection Report. 28/02/2020 D21 Financing Plan. D25 Concept Select Report. 08/05/2020 D03 CO2 Capture Plant Design. |
|
Northern Lights Project Concept report RE-PM673-00001
The Concept Study report (“DG2 report”) was the primary deliverable at The following criteria were used throughout the concept selection process to ... |
|
Concept Selection for Hydrocarbon Field Development Planning
and concept selection purposes the project cost approxi- [9] Instituto Mexicano del Petróleo “Internal Report on Con- cept Selection |
|
Concept Selection - Applying Pugh Matrices in the Subsea
of the concept selection process it is a powerful tool. It forces reasoning to be based on explicit criteria and FMC managers review the study report. |
|
EVOKE: A VALUE-DRIVEN CONCEPT SELECTION METHOD FOR
EVOKE: A Value-driven Concept Selection Method for Early System Design. 12. J Syst Sci Syst Eng mainly because of its reported transparency in. |
|
Dolphyn Hydrogen - phase 1 final report
9 oct. 2019 Dolphyn Hydrogen. Phase 1 - Final Report. Comprising: Phase 1a – Concept Select. Phase 1b – FEED for 2MW Scale Prototype. Public Report. |
|
CONCEPT SELECTION IN THE AUTOMOTIVE INDUSTRY WITH
Concept selection has been a living topic in engineering design for many years see [King and. Sivaloganathan 1999] for some examples. Selecting the right |
|
Concept Selection using Matrix Analysis - Business Growth Hub
Concept Selection using Matrix Analysis. You would use this approach as part of the design process to select the best concepts that meet the Product Design |
|
Concept Selection - MIT App Inventor
The Pugh concept selection method does not aim to select the best concept, but to develop the best concept Most of the time, there is not one superior concept |
|
Syde361 Concept Selection
Concept Selection Process • Prepare Example: Concept Screening CONCEPT Source of Information:Consumer Reports magazine, 1/94 and 2/94 issues |
|
Concept Selection - Applying Pugh Matrices in the Subsea
value Concept Selection and evaluation matrices [5,6,7,8] successful the concept selection and Pugh matrix were FMC managers review the study report |
|
1 Concept Selection for Deep Water Field Development Planning
26 jan 2016 · What should you expect after this lecture: • You will be familiar with concept selection process for deep water offshore oil and gas fields • This |
|
Concept Selection for Hydrocarbon Field Development Planning
and concept selection purposes the project cost approxi- mation are Cost Class 5 [9] Instituto Mexicano del Petróleo, “Internal Report on Con- cept Selection |
|
On Solution Concept Evaluation/Selection in Inventive Design - CORE
Consequently, the evaluation and selection process can be implemented with accuracy In this paper, we will report on current progress made on our ongoing |
|
Design Evaluation Methods - ME 2110
Identify the criteria for comparison 2 Select the alternatives to be compared • Alternatives are developed during concept generation • All concepts should be |
|
Decision Making Process, Field Development Concept Selection
3 mar 2013 · concept selection related to the upstream oil and gas industry DMP can be No of “bottlenecks” / no of direct reports Facilitates / enables |
