How to attack problems - New York University




Loading...







Courvoisier's Law Revisited - World Health Organization

famously known as the Courvoisier's law, Courvoisier syndrome, or Courvoisier's sign or Courvoisier-Terrier's sign (koor-vwah-zee-aye), has been subjected to changes in wording, phrasing and grammar from time to time, and these changes have redefined the definition originally put forward by the “safe surgeon”, and it is now

The Clinical Picture - Cleveland Clinic Journal of Medicine

The Courvoisier sign A 60-year-old woman has had jaundice, dark-colored urine, and light-colored stools for the past several days She has no his-tory of jaundice or gallstone disease With the exception of a palpable gallblad-der, the physical examination of the abdomen is unremarkable Computed tomography of

How to attack problems - New York University

1 Courvoisier v Raymond 1 different from assault and battery in that mistake can be a defense in self-defense 1 even accidental harming of third-person is not actionable unless D realizes or should have realized that the act creates an unreasonable risk of causing such harm 2 This is different from Roman Law 2 necessary elements

Obstructive Jaundice - DocDroid

Exception to Courvoisier's law (in 20 of cases) a) Calcular obstructive jaundice with palpable G B : 1 Metabolic stone with a healthy distensible G B 2 Stone in C B D & another stone in cystic duct ~ mucocele 3 A stone of Hartmann's pouch obstructing both cystic duct and C B D (Mirrizi syndrome)

How to attack problems - New York University 66753_10Torts_Epstein_Fall_2009.pdf  9<EFG 7BCE88@CG<BA  F86BA7 78G8E@<A8<AG8AG<BA4?BEA8:?<:8A68  "AG8AG<BA4?A4?LF<F  +8FG4G8@8AG  <AG8A7F6BAF8DH8A68  >ABJF<GJ<??B66HE  CFG8<A  7<7K46G<AG8AG<BAGB@4>86BAG46G  J4FG;8E84FFH@CG<BAB9G;8E<F>  7<7G;87898A74AGBI8EE<784FFH@CG<BA

 7898AF8F6BAF8AG A868FF<GL F8?97898AF8<AF4A<GL<F

HFH4??LABG47898AF8  66<78AGF '8:?<:8A68A4?LF<F  CE<@4946<864F8  7HGL

 <AFGE4A:8E64F8F G;8E8<F47HGLGBE84FBA45?864E8

 @B7<9<87  5L6BAGE46G54<?@8AG  CE8@<F8F?<45<?<GL7HGLGBGE8FC4FF8E 8G6   FC86<4?E8?4G<BAF;<C  5E846;  9BHEJ4LFGBF;BJA8:?<:8A68  6HFGB@-#!BBC8E+?<>8FG;<F  A8:?<:8A68C8EF8FG4GHG8 8FC ?<68AF<A:  6BFG58A89<G64?6B9E<F>6B@8FHCJ;8A LBHJ4AGGBF;BJG;4G7<7AGG4>88ABH:; CE864HG<BA  64AB664F<BA4??L6?4F;J<G;6HFGB@  <9<G7B8F 6<G8G;4G-#!BBC8E?<A84 J;B?864??<A:@4L?4:58;<A7  +8F<CF4  64HF4G<BA  64HF8<A946G5HG9BE64HF8  CEBK<@4G864HF8?<@<GBA64HF8<A946G  7<E86GA8FFG8FGLBH?BB>4GG;8<A=HEL4A7 JBE>LBHEJ4L546>F88<94ALG;<A:F8I8E87 6;4<AB964HF4G<BA  46GFB9G;<E7C4EG<8F 9E84><F;8I8AGF '(-A4GHE4?G;<A:F?<>8:E4I<GL  )B?8@<F64F8  9BE8F8845<?<GLG8FG?<45<?<GL?<@<G87GB 6BAF8DH8A68FG;89BE8F8845<?<GLB9J;<6; @478F46G<BAFA8:?<:8AG<AG;89<EFGC?468 4A7 C8EFBAFJ<G;<AG;4G9BE8F8845?8MBA8 B974A:8E  J4:BA@BHA7  FC86<4?64F8F  8@BG<BA4?7<FGE8FFHF8G;8F8FC86<4?64F8F ABG9BE8F8845?8BEJ;4G8I8E  74@4:8F  J4FK;HEG  <AFGE<6G?<45<?<GL 7HGL7HGLABGGB;HEG4ALBA8  5E846;<9LBH;HEG4ALBA8 LBHI85E846;87

"AG8AG<BA4??L"A9?<6G87!4E@G;8)E<@446<84F84A7898AF8F

 -E8FC4FFGB%4A7 )8EFBA 4A7;4GG8?F  4A4?LF<F9BHEC4EG  J4F46GIB?<G<BA4?<AG8AG<BA4?  <7)4FFH@8E<F>

 8I8A<9L8F G;8E8@4LFG<??58GBEG<9<AG8A787GB64HF8

;4E@  <FG;8E8FB@87898AF8A868FF<GL F8?9 7898AF8  /BF5HE:I )HGA8LC8EFBA  4GG8E8L<F4A<AG8AG<BA4? HA6BAF8AG87 GBGBH6;<A:

 4@4:8F4E84??<A=HE<8FE8FH?G<A:9EB@JEBA:9H?46G

 8::F;8??F>H??EH?8<AG8AGGB;4E@<FABGA868FF4EL BA?L

<AG8AGGBGE8FC4FFLBHG4>8G;8I<6G<@4FLBH9<A7;<@

 @<FG4>84A7HA9BE8F8845<?<GL4E8HFH4??LABG7898AF8F

 BH:;8EGLI ,G8CC?4A7

 4??HA4HG;BE<M878AGELBAGB4ABG;8EF?4A7<FGE8FC4FF

 <AG8AGGB8AG8E?4A7<FJ;4G@4GG8EF ABG<AG8AGGB7B

74@4:8GB?4A7

 <AG4A:<5?88AGEL@4L58GE8FC4FF 5HG@HFGF;BJ74@4:8GB

?4A78?86GEB@4:A8G<6J4I8F 8G6   "AG8?I !4@<7<;4GG8?F

 8?86GEBA<66B@@HA<64G<BAF7BABG6BAFG<GHG8GE8FC4FFHA?8FF

G;8L74@4:8BE<@C4<EG;89HA6G<BA<A:B94ABG;8EFCEBC8EGL

 <A=HA6G<I8E8?<89BA?LJ;8E8G;8E8<FG;E84GB9<EE8C4E45?8

;4E@  ;<:;?<>8?<;BB7B9<@@<A8AG <EE8C4E45?8;4E@  64AABG58478DH4G8?L6B@C8AF4G875L74@4:8F  BAI8EF<BA  )B::<I ,6BGG

 6BAI8EF<BAHAJ4AG87<AG8E98E8A685LJ<G;G;8CEBC8EGLB9

)9EB@J;<6;<A=HELGB)E8FH?GF

 A8<G;8E<AG8AGGB6B@@<GJEBA:9H?46GABE>ABJ?87:8B9GEH8

BJA8EF;<CB9CEBC8EGL<FE8DH<E87

 <G<FE8DH<E87G;4G;4I8<AG8AGGB8K8E6<F87B@<A<BABE

6BAGEB?BI8EG;8CEBC8EGL

 ,B@8BI8E?4CJ<G;GE8FC4FFGB6;4GG8?F BAI8EF<BA4?BA89BE

4:4<AFGJ;8A;47G4>8ACEBC8EGL9EB@ J;B;47

CE8I<BHF?LG4>8A<G9EB@CBFF8FF<BAB9FGB?8ACEBC8EGL

54F<64??L (A?LGE8FC4FFJBH?7?<8J;8AG;87898A74AG;47

G4>8ACBFF8FF<BAB9G;8C?4<AG<99NF:BB7FJ<G;BHG6?4<@<A:

BJA8EF;<CB9G;8@  &BBE8I +8:8AGFB9.A<I8EF<GLB94?<9BEA<4  BJA8EF;<C<AG8E8FG<F8FF8AG<4?

 6BAI8EF<BA64AABG8K<FG<A4F<GH4G<BAJ;8E8)JBH?7;4I8

G;EBJA4J4L4ALJ4LF  898AF8FGB"AG8AG<BA4?-BEGF  BAF8AFH4?898AF8F  &B;EI 0<??<4@F

 (C8E4G<BAFJ;<6;4E8ABG6BAF8AG87GB4E854GG8EL

BC8E4G<BAFJ;<6;4E86BAF8AG87GB4E8ABG BE<:<A4??L I8ELFGE<6G?L4CC?<87  &B78EACBF<G<BA<F?8FFFGE<A:8AG  HFH4??L G;<F<F6BAGE46G874EBHA7 G;8E8<F4A8@8E:8A6L8K68CG<BA 4A74 DH4F< 8@8E:8A6L8K68CG<BA9BE<FFH8FJ;<6; 6B@8HC7HE<A:FHE:8EL  C4G<8AGFFG<??;4I84E<:;GGBE89HF84AL GE84G@8AG

 @BE87<99<6H?GJ<G;FH5FG<GHG876BAF8AG@<ABEF 8G6 

 FH56BAF8AG9BE@<ABEF <A6B@C8G8AGF  FH56BAF8AG64A58@BE87<99<6H?GJ;8A GE84G@8AG<F9BEG;858A89<GB94ABG;8EK 6;BBF8FGB;4I8LHA78E:B4ABC8E4G<BA9BE G;858A89<GB9M  "AF4A<GL  &6 H<E8I ?@L

 <AF4A8C8BC?84E8?<45?8BEG;8<EGBEGFJ8J4AGGB

6E84G8<A68AG<I8F9BE6BAGEB??<A:G;8<E58;4I<BE  <A68AG<I8BA<AF4A8C8EFBA  <A68AG<I8BA64E8G4>8EFG;8L7BAGJ4AG G;8<EC4L6;86>GB7<F4CC84E  <A4F8AF8 ?BFF;4FGB585BEA5LBA8B9GJB <AAB68AGC8BC?8 4A7G;HFF;BH?794??BAG;8 C8EFBAJ;B6E84G87<G

 G;8E8<F<AG8AG<BA5864HF8<AF4A8C8EFBA<AG8A787GB

FGE<>8  ,8?9 898AF8  BHEIB<F<8EI +4L@BA7

 7<998E8AG9EB@4FF4H?G4A754GG8EL<AG;4G@<FG4>8

64A5847898AF8<AF8?9 7898AF8  8I8A466<78AG4?;4E@<A:B9G;<E7 C8EFBA<F ABG46G<BA45?8HA?8FFE84?<M8FBEF;BH?7 ;4I8E84?<M87G;4GG;846G6E84G8F4A HAE84FBA45?8E<F>B964HF<A:FH6;;4E@  -;<F<F7<998E8AG9EB@+B@4A%4J  A868FF4EL8?8@8AGF  F<GH4G<BA<FFB<@@87<4G8G;4GGE47<G<BA4? E8@87<8FFH6;4F<A=HA6G<BABECB?<6846G<BA 4E8ABG4ABCG<BA  46G<BA@HFG58E8FCBA7<A:GB4ABA:B<A: E<F>  46G<BA@HFG58CEBCBEG<BA4G8GBG;8E<F>

 'B?<45<?<GL9BE7898AF8<9G;8E84FBA45?8@4AJBH?7

58?<8I8G;4G;<F?<98J4F<A74A:8E  898AF8B9)EBC8EGL  <E7I !B?5EBB>  &4LABG64G6;4@4A5L@84AFJ;<6;@4L@4<@

;<@BE8A74A:8E;<F?<98>8L;8E8<FG;4GG;8E8J4F

<AG8AG<BAGB64G6;4A7;4E@ ABGCE8I8AG  '868FF<GL

 G;<F7898AF84CC?<8FJ;8A1<F7E<I8AGBGE8FC4FF7H8GB4A

46GB9 B7 G;8JEBA:9H?46GB94G;<E7C4EGL 8G6

 )?BB9I )HGA4@

 46G<BAFB9F8EI4AG4E8 ?8:4??L G;846G<BAFB9G;8

@4FG8EI<64E<BHF?<45<?<GL  A868FF<GLC8E@<GFGE8FC4FF BJA8EB9?4A7@4LABGCE8I8AGGE8FC4FFBHGB9 A868FF<GL 5HGA887ABG4FF<FG 8<G;8E  /<A68AGI %4>8E<8-E4AFCBEG4G<BA B  4?G;BH:;GE8FC4FF7H8GBA868FF<GL<F4??BJ87 7898A74AG@HFGFG<??6B@C8AF4G8C?4<AG<999BEG;8 74@4:87BA87H8GBG;88AGEL  CH5?<6A868FF<GL

 78FGEH6G<BABEF8<MHE8B9CE<I4G8CEBC8EGL5LCH5?<6

F8EI4AGF@4L58B> 5HG6B@C8AF4G<BA<FFG<?? A868FF4EL

 G;87<99<6H?GL<FG;4GG;85HE78A<F6BA68AGE4G87 5HG

G;858A89<GF4E87<FGE<5HG874@BA:@4ALBG;8EF  FB J8:<I8B99<6<4?<@@HA<GL 5HGHFH4??L7BAG

FC86<9<64??LFHE6;4E:8G;BF858A89<G87 4F9<A7<A:BHG

J;BG;8L4E864A587<99<6H?G

 ,GE<6G%<45<?<GL4A7'8:?<:8A68!<FGBE<64A7A4?LG<6BHA74G<BAF

 BE@4G<I84F8F  -;8G;BEAF64F8  4E:H45?L8FG45?<F;8FFGE<6G?<45<?<GL  %<GG?8GBA@HFG6B@C8AF4G8G;BF8LBH<A=HE8

 ;B>894??<A:J4FABG?4J9H? G;8E89BE8G4><A:4J4LJ4FABG

?4J9H?  -<G;864F8

 8K4@C?8B9C8EI8EF8<A68AG<I8F6E84G875LCH5?<6A868FF<GL

64F8F4A74FL@@8GE<64?<A68AG<I8F  084I8EI 04E7

 898A74AG6B@@<GG87ABA8:?<:8A68ABG<AG8AG<BA4?FBAB

54GG8EL  -;8BE@FB96G<BA  -E8FC4FF4A74F8

 GE8FC4FF;4E@64HF875LF<E86G4A7<@@87<4G8

4CC?<64G<BAB99BE684:4<AFG)FC8EFBA

 64F8<A7<E86G;4E@F ABG<AIB?I<A:7<E86GHF8B99BE68

 ,6BGGI ,;8C;8E7

 78@BAFGE4G8F7<99<6H?GL<AF8C4E4G<A:GE8FC4FF4A7

64F8

 ,GE<6G%<45<?<GL4A7'8:?<:8A68<AG;8%4FG!4?9BEG;8'<A8G88AG;8AGHEL

 EBJAI $8A74??

 <97898A74AGJ4F8K8E6<F<A:7H864E8 ;8J4FABG?<45?89BE

FGE<><A:

 GE4AF<G<BA4J4L9EB@FGE<6G?<45<?<GLGBA8:?<:8A68FG4A74E7<A

G;8.,  ?8G6;8EI +L?4A7F8G6 

 FGE<6G?<45<?<GLFG4A74E79BEFJ;B@4<AG4<A74A:8EBHF

G;<A:FBAG;8<ECEBC8EGLJ;8AG;BF8G;<A:F8F64C8  G<8FGB45ABE@4??L74A:8EBHF46G<I<G<8F  EBJAI B??<AF

 )E<A6<C?8FB9+L?4A7FF;BH?7ABG588KG8A787F;BH?7584

A8:?<:8A68FG4A74E7  )BJ8??I 4??

 FGE<6G?<45<?<GL8I8AG;BH:;GE4<AJ4F9B??BJ<A:F498GLFG4GHG8F

 ,GE<6G%<45<?<GL4A7'8:?<:8A68<A&B78EA-<@8F  ,GBA8I B?GBA

 F@4??CBFF<5<?<GLB9<A=HEL 5HGFG<??9BE8F8845?8

B?GBAI ,GBA8

 64E89H?@4A@HFGG4>8E84FBA45?864E8GB4IB<7<A=HE<8F

5864HF8<G6BH?758E84FBA45?L9BE8F88A G;8J8E8HA78E4

7HGLGBCE8I8AG

 G;8E8J4FABG;<A:G;4G464E89H?@4AJBH?7;4I87BA8

7<998E8AG?L<AG;<F64F8 FBAB?<45<?<GLG;8E<F>J4FI8EL

F@4??  !4@@BAGE88I #8AA8E

 7B6GE<A8B9FGE<6G?<45<?<GL7B8FABG4CC?LGB7E<I8EF

 G;8E8J4FABE84FBAGB4AG<6<C4G8F8<MHE8 <??A8FF FBABG

A8:?<:8AG  -;8'8:?<:8A68"FFH8  -;8+84FBA45?8)8EFBA  /4H:;4AI &8A?BI8

 FH5=86G<I8I B5=86G<I8FG4A74E79BEE84FBA45?8A8FF

 B5=86G<I8FG4A74E7<F58GG8EJ;4GE84FBA45?8@4AB9

BE7<A4ELCEH78A68JBH?7;4I87BA8  +B58EGFI +<A:

 4??47H?GF4E8GE84G878DH4??LHA78EA8:?<:8A68FG4A74E7

 <A9<E@<G<8F7BAGE8?<8I84C8EFBAB9A8:?<:8A68

 8K68CG<BAJ;8A;4E@87C4EGL4FFH@8FG;8E<F>G846;<A:

><7GB7E<I8  4A<8?FI I4AF

 @<ABEF@HFG8K8E6<F8F4@8FG4A74E7B958;4I<BE4F47H?GF

J;8A8A:4:87<A47H?G46G<I<G<8F

 FGE4A:8E64F8F8I8ELBA8;4FGB?<I8HCGBG;8FG4A74E7B9

G;8E84FBA45?8C8EFBAG;4G8I8ELBA88?F858?<8I8FG;8@GB

58  E8HA<:I @8E<64A4@<?L"AFHE4A68B  <AF4A<GL64A5847898AF8GBA8:?<:8A68 5HGG;8 6<E6H@FG4A68F4E8A4EEBJ

 89986GB9<AF4A<GL@F49986G45<?<GLGBHA78EFG4A77HGL

GB7E<I864EJ<G;BE7<A4EL64E8  G;8E8@HFG584A45F8A68B9ABG<68G;4G<AF4A<GL JBH?7B66HE  4?6H?HFB9+<F>  ?LG;I <E@<A:;4@04G8E0BE>F

 ABGA8:?<:8AG<A54F<A:6BAFGEH6G<BABACE8I<BHF;<FGBEL

 6>8EGI %BA:"F?4A7++

 J;8A8KCBFHE8GBE<F><FBEG;8CHECBF8B9F4I<A:4?<98 <G<F

ABGA8:?<:8AGHA?8FFE4F;BEE86>?8FF  -8EEL '8:?<:8A68  ,84IL '8:?<:8A68  (F5BEA8I &BAG:B@8EL

 ?<45<?<GL<FCE8@<F87BA454?4A6<A:B9FB6<4?E<F>

 8I8A<968EG4<A6BA7H6G@4L9BE8F8845?LE8FH?G<A;4E@ G;8

E<F>@4L58=HFG<9<875LG;86<E6HFG4A68F  BB?8LI )H5?<6,8EI<68B

 E84FBA45?84?G8EA4G<I8FG4A74E7ABGE8DH<E87GBG4>84

CE864HG<BAJ;<6;J<??6E84G84A8J74A:8E9BEFB@8BA88?F8

 .,I 4EB??-BJ<A:B

 %84EA87!4A79BE@H?4"9G;8CEB545<?<GL5864??87)G;8

<A=HEL %4A7G;85HE78A ?<45<?<GL78C8A7FBAJ;8G;8E

<F?8FFG;4A%@H?G<C?<875L)< 8 J;8E8<F?8FFG;4A)% 

9BE@H?46E<G<6<M874F7<99<6H?GGB4CC?L C4EG<4??L5864HF8

8?8@8AGF4E87<99<6H?GGBDH4AG<9L  HFGB@

 HFGB@7B8FABG9<GJ8??J<G;64?6H?HFB9E<F>G;8<784<FG;4G<9

58;4I<BE7B8FAG78I<4G89EB@G;86HFGB@4EL?8I8?B964E8 G;<F<F

CE<@4946<88I<78A68B9E84FBA45?864E8  -<GHFI E479BE7

 B@@BACE46G<68B945HF<A8FF6BAGEB?F=HEBEFF;BH?7ABG

F8GG;BF8FG4A74E7FE84FBA45?LF498@84AFF498466BE7<A:

GBG;8HF4:8F ;45<GF 4A7BE7<A4ELE<F>FB9G;85HF<A8FF

 &4L;8JI ,H??<I4A&<A<A:B

 8I8A<94:EBFF?46>B964E8<FHA<I8EF4?6HFGB@ J87BAG

4??BJ<GGB6BAGEB?  64F8:4<A87?<GG?89B??BJ<A:  -;8-#!BBC8E

 8I8A<946HFGB@<F9B??BJ87 G;8E8@4L58A8:?<:8A68

J;B?864??<A:@4L?4:58;<A7<AG;847BCG<BAB9A8JF498GL

78I<68F  J;8AG;<F<FG;864F8 6BHEGF;BH?77E<I86HFGB@  +G;<FEH?<A:BC8AFHC8I8EL6HFGB@GB6BHEG 4A4?LF<F

6HFGB@F;BH?76E84G84FGEBA:CE8FH@CG<BA<A94IBEB9

7898A74AG  &87<64?&4?CE46G<68  %4@4I BEE4F  GB8FG45?<F;@87<64?@4?CE46G<6864F8 @HFGF;BJ G;4GG;854F<6ABE@FB9>ABJ?87:84A7@87<64?64E8

J8E8ABG9B??BJ87 4A7G;4GG;<F94<?HE864HF87G;8

<A=HELFH998E87

 J;8AG;8E8<FABF<A:?86HFGB@:BI8EA<A:G;8<FFH8

G;8CE46G<G<BA8E@HFG9B??BJ4F6;BB?B9G;BH:;G G;BH:;<G64A584ALB9G;8@4=BEBA8F

 <G<FABGA8:?<:8AGGBC<6>46BHEF8B9GE84G@8AGG;4G

8KCBFGGHEAFBHGGB58G;8JEBA:BA8 HA?8FF7B6 F;BH?7;4I8>ABJA<GJ4FG;8JEBA:BA88K4AG8  F?<:;GI4E<4G<BAF<A64E84E84??BJ879BE?8FF

FBC;<FG<64G87;BFC<G4?F4A76?<A<6F 5HG?4E:8E8:<BA4?

7<FC4E<G<8F4E8ABGC8E@<GG877<998E8A68F<A E8FBHE68F4E8HA4IB<745?8 5HG7<998E8A68F<A CE46G<68F4E8ABGC8E@<GG87

 <AG8EAF E8F<78AGF4E8;8?7GBG;8F4@8FG4A74E74F

9H??7B6GBEFFGE4A:8ECE<A6<C?8  4AG8E5HELI ,C8A68

 E<:;GB9C4G<8AGGB7<E86GG;8<E64E8<F54F<F9BE7HGL

GB7<F6?BF84??E<F>FCBG8AG<4??L49986G<A:786<F<BA

@HFG587<F6?BF87  8K68CG<BAF  J;8AC4G<8AG<FHA6BAF6<BHF  J;8A7<F6?BFHE8CBF8FFH6;4:E84GG;E84GGB C4G<8AGJ8?94E84FGB586B@8HA984F<5?8  <ABE78E9BE?<45<?<GL G;8E8@HFG58464HF4? E8?4G<BAF;<C58GJ88AG;894<?HE8GB7<F6?BF84A7 74@4:8GB) G;86BHEGF4E8E8F<FG4AGGB78@4A7FGBE8DH<E8

7B6GBEFGB7<F6?BF89H??E4A:8B9CBFF<5?8GE84G@8AG

4?G8EA4G<I8F<A6B@C?8K64F8F  ,G4GHG8F4A7+8:H?4G<BAF  (F5BEAI &6&4FG8EF

 <G<F<@@4G8E<4?J;8G;8EG;87HGL<FBA8<@CBF875L6B@@BA

?4JBE5L4FG4GHG8 "A8<G;8E64F8G;894<?HE8GBC8E9BE@G;8

7HGL6BAFG<GHG8FA8:?<:8A68  <A=HEL@HFG58B9G;8><A7J;<6;G;8FG4GHG8J4F 78F<:A87GBCE8I8AG

 9BE9878E4?E8?<897H8GB5E846;B99878E4?FG4GHG8J<G;AB

8KC?<6<GCE<I4G8E<:;GB946G<BA G;8E8<F49BHEC4EGG8FG

 )BA8B96?4FF9BEJ;BF858A89<GG;8FG4GHG8J4F 8A46G87

 <FG;8E84AL?8:<F?4G<I8<AG8AGBA8J4LBEG;8BG;8E

 CE<I4G8E<:;GB946G<BA<F6BAF<FG8AGJ<G;G;8 HA78E?L<A:CHECBF8B9G;8?8:<F?4G<I8F6;8@8

 <FG;84E84BA8GE47<G<BA4??L;4A7?875LFG4G8?4J <A

4A4E84B96BA68EACE<@4E<?LGBG;8FG4G8F  +7F86   +FGF86   8I<78A68B78  &4EG<AI !8EMB:

 /<B?4G<BAB9FG4GHG8J4F7<E86GA8:?<:8A68 5HGG;8E8FG<??

@HFG58464HF4??<A>58GJ88AG;8I<B?4G<BA4A7G;8<A=HEL

 EBJAI ,;LA8

 9BE4FG4GHG8GB588I<78A68B9A8:?<:8A68 <G@HFG58

FB@8G;<A:G;8FG4GHG8J4F78F<:A87GBCEBG86G4:4<AFG

 4E84FB97<F4:E88@8AG

 FB@86BHEGF;4I8EH?87G;4G?84I<A:BA8F64E8HA?B6>87 <9

<GFH5F8DH8AG?L:8GFFGB?8A4A7<FHF87GB<A=HE8FB@8G;<E7

C4EGL <FA8:?<:8A68BG;8E6BHEGF;4I8EH?87G;8BG;8EJ4L

 @BFG6BHEGF;B?7G;4G54EG8A78EF4E8?<45?8BEF8EI<A:5BBM8

GB6HFGB@8EFJ;BG;8A:BBAGB7E<I87EHA> G;BH:;G;<F<F

E8=86G875LFB@86BHEGF4A7BI8EEH?875LFG4G8?4J<AFB@8

4E84F  #H7:84A7#HEL  !B?@8F -;8B@@BA%4J  4?G<@BE84A7(;<B++I  BB7@4A

 J;8A4G4GE46>4A7F<:;G?<A89BEGE4<A<F5?B6>87 :8GG<A:BHG

B9LBHE64EGB6;86><FE84FBA45?8  )B>BE4I 0454F;++

 :8GG<A:BHGB9LBHE6;4EGB6;86>9BE4GE4<A<FHA6B@@BA

CEB545?L9HG<?8 4A7CBFF<5?L74A:8EBHF

 BB7@4A6E84G874EH?8B9?4JJ;8E8G;8E8F;BH?7ABG;4I8

588ABA8<GF;BH?7;4I8588A4946GDH8FG<BA9BEG;8=HEL

 )EBB9B9'8:?<:8A68  )EB5?8@F  +8F"CF4  E84??L G;<F<F45BHG5HE78AF;<9G<A:  +8F"CF45HE78AGB  64AF;<9G<G546>  LEA8I B47?8

454EE8?EB??<A:BHGB94J4E8;BHF86BH?7AG;4CC8A

J<G;BHGA8:?<:8A68  7HGLB978G8E@<A<A:J;BF854EE8?<G<F J;BJ4F 64HF8 E8FGFBA7898A74AG5864HF8;8J4F<AG;8 58FGCBF<G<BAGB>ABJ

 <9G;8E84E8946GF<A6BAF<FG8AGJ<G;A8:?<:8A68 G;8A

<G<FHCGBG;8GBCEBI8G;8@

 ;BG8?64F8F<ABA8 E8F<CF44CC?<8F 5HGABGG;8BG;8E

 <ABA864F8 G;8;BG8?>A8J45BHG;BB?<:4A<F@;47

E84FBAGB8KC86GG;4GG;8E8JBH?758;BB?<:4A<F@

 <AG;8BG;8E64F8 G;8;BG8?7<7AG>ABJ45BHGG;8

C4EGLG;8L;47ABE84FBAGB8KC86G  FB +8F"CF47B8FAG4CC?L<AG;8?4GG8E5864HF8

G;8E8<FABE84FBA9BEG;8;BG8?GB>ABJ4A7G;HFAB

A8:?<:8A68  B?@8A4E8F/<I4FI ,HA??<4A68"AFHE4A68B  G;E88C4EGG8FG  466<78AG@HFG58B9G;8><A7J;<6;7B8FABG B66HEJ<G;BHGA8:?<:8A68  64HF85L4A4:8A6LJ<G;<AG;88K6?HF<I8 6BAGEB?B9G;87898A74AG  ABG7H8GB4ALIB?HAG4EL46G<BABAG;8C4EG B9G;8C?4<AG<99  -;8E84E8FB@8<AFG4A68FB9E8FCBAF<5<?<GLJ;<6; 64AABG58C4FF87BAGB4ABG;8EC4EGL  254EE4I ,C4A:4E7

 @H?G<C?87898A74AGF7B8FABGCE86?H784CC?<64G<BAB9

E8F<CF4  E8F<CF4<F<@CBEG4AGGBBI8E6B@86BAFC<E46LB9 F<?8A68  )?4<AG<99FBA7H6G  BAGE<5HGBEL'8:?<:8A68

 8FG45?<F;87J;8A);4FABGG4>8AE84FBA45?864E8 4A74F4E8FH?G

;4FFH998E87<A=HEL54EF4ALE86BI8EL4G4??J;8AFH668FF9H?

 5HE78AB9CEBB9<FBAGBCEBI8)FA8:?<:8A68  4F<6B6GE<A8  HGG8E9<8?7I BEE8FG8E

 <9LBH;<G4AB5FGEH6G<BALBHE84FBA45?L6BH?7;4I8

4IB<787 LBHE46G<BA<F5?B6>87  88@FI ;<64:B +B6>"F?4A7)8BE<4++

 46GB9ABG6;86><A:J;8G;8E64EFJ8E8FGBCC87J4F

ABG6BAGE<5HGBELA8:?<:8A68  ;86BH?78KC86GG;8@GBC8E9BE@G;8<E7HG<8F  ;8J4F78C8A7<A:BABG;8E8@C?BL88F  ,6;J4EGM -BEG%4J4A7G;86BAB@L  L8E@4AI .,%<A8FB

 C?4<AG<99FA8:?<:8AG46G<BAF4E8CEBK<@4G864HF8BA?L

<9G;8L4E84FH5FG4AG<4?946GBE<A5E<A:<A:45BHGG;8

;4E@  <9)7B8FABG@B7<9LG;8<E58;4I<BEGBCEBG86G G;8@F8?I8F4F4E84FBA45?8C8EFBAJBH?7 G;8L@4L 586BAGA8:  FB@86BHEGF;4I8E89HF87GB<@CBF86BAGE<5HGBEL A8:?<:8A68J;8E8)<FCEBG86G875L4FG4GHG8

46G<BAF7BA8HA78E<EE8F<FG<5?8<@CH?F87BABGF8I8E

64HF4?6BAA86G<BA 4A74E8G;HFABG6BAGA8:7<GGB

G4A:

 A868FF<GL<F47898AF8<96BAGA8:<F7BA8<A4A

8@8E:8A6L J<G;BHGG<@8GBG;<A> FB?BA:4FK46GF

?<>84E84FBA45?LCEH78AGC8EFBAJBH?7

 %8+BL<5E8B I ;<64:B &<?J4H>88 ,G )4H?+L

 BAGEBI8EF<4?64F8B99?4K64G6;<A:9<E8A8KGGB E4<?EB47?4KJ4F 988G4J4L 6BHEG9BHA7G;8E8 J4FAB6BAGE<5HGBELA8:?<:8A685864HF8<GJ4FBA )NFCEBC8EGL4A7ABA887GB:H4E7BJACEBC8EGL 4:4<AFG46G<BAFB9  FFH@CG<BAB9+<F>

 4F>FJ;8G;8E);4F78?<58E4G8?L4A7IB?HAG4E<?L8A6BHAG8E874

>ABJAE<F>6E84G875LFA8:?<:8A684A7 <9FB <G<G;B?7FG;4GF;8

F;BH?7ABG5845?8GBE86BI8E9BEG;86BAF8DH8AG;4E@

 %4@FBAI @8E<64AK84A7-BB?B  ABGDH<GG<A:<F4A4FFH@CG<BAB9E<F>

 4FFH@CG<BAB9E<F><A<A7HFGE<4?466<78AG45B?<F;875LF4GHG8

<A  &HEC;LI ,G88C?86;4F8@HF8@8AGB

 C?4<AG<99>A8J;8J4F:8GG<A:BAGB4E<78BA8J;BG4>8F

C4EG<AFCBEG4668CGFG;874A:8EF<A;8E8AG<A<G

 @BE8@B78EA4FFH@CG<BAB9E<F>;4F4A<A6E84F877HGLGB

J4EA  GJBGLC8F

 CE<@4EL4FFH@CG<BAB9E<F>J;8E8 5LI<EGH8B9G;8A4GHE8

B9G;846G<I<GL4A7G;8C4EG<8FE8?4G<BAF;<CGBG;846G<I<GL

G;87898A74AGBJ8FAB?8:4?7HGLGBCEBG86GG;8C?4<AG<99

9EB@G;8C4EG<6H?4EE<F>B9;4E@G;4G64HF87G;8<A=HEL

 F86BA74EL4FFH@CG<BAB9E<F>J;8E8G;87898A74AG7B8F

BJ847HGLB964E8GBG;8C?4<AG<99 5HGG;8C?4<AG<99CEB6887F

GB8A6BHAG8E4>ABJAE<F><@CBF875LG;87898A74AGF

5E846;B97HGL  HFH4??L@8E:87J<G;6B@C4E4G<I8 6BAGE<5HGBEL A8:?<:8A68  %4FG?84E;4A68+H?8

 8?<@<A4G8F)A8:?<:8A68J;8AA8:?<:8A68<F?4FG

 7B8FAG@4GG8E;BJ)FCE87<64@8AG4EBF8

 8?<@<A4G8F6B@CA8G5864HF8LBHE8?BB><A:F8DH8AG<4??L

 B96BHEF8 <96B@CA8:J4FFG4GHGBE<?L<@CBF87 G;8A

LBH6BH?7AG4E:H8%  B@C4E4G<I8'8:?<:8A68  GB@@BA%4J  %B@54E7%4JF  846;  )EBFF8E  %<I 28??BJ45B B9  6BHEG@BI8FGB6B@C4E4G<I8A8:?<:8A68

 )HE86B@C4E4G<I8A8:?<:8A684CCBEG<BAF?<45<?<GL

7<E86G?L<ACEBCBEG<BAGB94H?G   6B@C4E4G<I8A8:?<:8A684CCBEG<BAF<A CEBCBEG<BAGB94H?GHCHAG<?)<F BE@BE84G 94H?G <AJ;<6;64F8FE86BI8EL9EB@<F54EE87 ,C86<4?I8E7<6GFC?4L4A<@CBEG4AGEB?8<A4 6B@C4E4G<I8A8:?<:8A68FLFG8@5864HF8<AG;8<E

45F8A68<G<F<@CBFF<5?8GB>ABJG;8=HE<8FG;BH:;G

CEB68FF<F<G>56G;4G<F4??G;874@4:8F4A7)

<F9H??L?<45?8 BE5864HF8<F?<45?85HG 74@4:8FJ8E8 >  L%8:<F?4G<BA  %  '2  )  0"  +7F86

 &H?G<C?8898A74AGF#B<AG ,8I8E4? 4A7/<64E<BHF%<45<?<GL

 #B<A4A7,8I8E4?%<45<?<GL

 #B<AG?<45<?<GL4ALC8EFBAJ;B584EF4AB5?<:4G<BA64A58E8FCBAF<5?8

9BE4?BFF<9BG;8EF4E8HA45?8GBC4L

 ,8I8E4??<45<?<GL846;C8EFBA;4F4AB5?<:4G<BAGBC4LG;8<EF;4E8

4A7G;87894H?GB9BG;8EF7B8FABG<A6E84F8G;8ABA

7894H?G8EFNF;4E8  #B<AG 4A7

F8I8E4??<45<?<GL(5?<:BEF4E8=B<AGGBG;8B5?<:88 5HG584E

F8I8E4??<45<?<GL4@BA:FGG;8@F8?I8F

 .A<BA,GB6>24E7FB B9(@4;4I ;<64:B HE?<A:GBA 4A7*H<A6L

++

 =B<AG?<45<?<GL@84AF8<G;8E64A58FH87J<G;BHG<A78@A<GL

4:4<AFGG;8BG;8E  <I<?B78B9)EB687HE8 F86

 @8E<64A&BGBE6L6?8FFB6<4G<BAI ,HC8E<BEBHEG

 %< 7<F6HFF8745BI89BE<GF;B?7<A:E8?4G87GB6B@C4E4G<I8

A8:?<:8A68 7B8FABGA8:4G8=B<AG4A7F8I8E4??<45<?<GL

 4F84??BJF9BEC4EG<4?<A78@A<GL9EB@BG;8E6BA6HEE8AG

GBEG984FBEFBA46B@C4E4G<I894H?G54F<F

 @8E<64A&BGBE6L6?8F88@FGB<A7<64G8G;4G<AFB?I8AGF

F;4E8F;4??58C4<75LBG;8EF 4ABG;8E4?<9BEA<464F8F4LF

G;4G<AFB?I8AGFF;4E8<FFC?<G<ACEBCBEG<BAGBG;8

C8E68AG4:8B96B@C4E4G<I8E8FCBAF<5<?<GLBE<:<A4??L4FF<:A87

58GJ88AE8@4<A<A:F4A7)-;<E7E8FG4G8@8AG8A7BEF8F

G;<F4CCEB46; J<G;8K68CG<BAF9BE<AG8AG<BA4?GBEG984FBEF

C8EFBAF46G<A:<A6BA68EG I<64E<BHF?<45<?<GL 4A7C8EFBAF

J;B94<?GBCEBG86G)9EB@G;8FC86<9<6E<F>B94A<AG8AG<BA4?

GBEG

 F8GG?8@8AGEH?8F9BEBA8@4L49986G<A68AG<I8FGBF8GG?8

 E87<GEH?8<9LBHF8GG?8G;8BG;8E64AFG<??CBG8AG<4??LBJ8

G;8E8FGB9G;8BE<:<A4?FH<G6BH?758J4L@BE8G;4AG;8L

BE<:<A4??LJBH?7;4I8BJ87<9F8GG?8@8AG<FF@4?? 6E84G8F

<A68AG<I8GBF8GG?8  4EI8

BHGEH?8):<I8FHC8I8ELG;<A:G;8L7BANG:8G9EB@

FG<A@H?G< C4EGLFH<GFJ<G;4F8GG?8@8AG "9<GF  F8GG?<A:J<G; :HL@84AFBA?L <F?89G E8:4E7?8FFB9 F8GG?8@8AGF<M8  /<64E<BHF%<45<?<GL  "E4, HF;8L,BAF "A6 I .,

 /<64E<BHF?<45<?<GL6BI8EF46G<BAFG4>8A5L8@C?BL88F<AG;8

6BHEF8B9G;8<E7HG<8F4F4A8@C?BL88?FB6BI8EFF@4??

78I<4G<BAF9EB@6BHEF8B97HG<8F

"AG8AG<BA4?GBEGF@4L586BAF<78E87J<G;<AG;86BHEF8B9

8@C?BL@8AG<9G;8L4E8<AG8A787GBF8EI8G;88@C?BL8ENF

<AG8E8FG 5HGG;<FFG4A74E7<F7<99<6H?GGB@88G

 <A6<78AGJ4FE8?4G87GBF8494E<A:?<98F4<?BEF8@C?BL@8AG

 46G<BAFJ8E8ABGFBHA9BE8F8845?84FGB@4>8<GHA94<EGB

6;4E:88@C?BL8EJ<G;?<45<?<GL  )8GEBI<6;I ,;4E8!84?G;)?4AB9"% "A6

 I<64E<BHF?<45<?<GL@4L8K<FG9BE<A78C8A78AG6BAGE46GBEF

J;8A4A4:8A6LE8?4G<BAF;<C<F8FG45?<F;87  4CC4E8AG4HG;BE<GL  <@C?<874HG;BE<GL  4HF4G<BA  4HF8<A46G

 4A868FF4EL6BA7<G<BA9BEG;8;4E@G4><A:C?4685HG9BEK LJBH?7

ABG;4I8;4CC8A87  '28AGE4?++ I  E<@FG47

 CEBK<@4G864HF8J4F786878AG94??<A:<AGBJ4G8E58?<89G;4G

5HBLJBH?7;4I8F4I87;<@J4FCHE8FC86H?4G<BA

 ABG;<A:GBF;BJG;4G5HG9BEG;8?46>B9?<98CE8F8EI8E ;8

JBH?7;4I8FHEI<I87  3H6;BJ<6MI .,

 946G9<A78E6BH?7;4I86BA6?H787G;4G74AB6E<A8J4FG;8

64HF8B9<A=HEL 5HG<G@HFG58G;8A8:?<:8AGBI8E7BF8G;4G

64HF87<A=HEL

 "944A8:?<:8AG46GJ4F788@87JEBA:9H?5864HF8G;4G46G

<A6E84F87G;86;4A68FG;4G4C4EG<6H?4EGLC8B9466<78AG

JBH?7B66HE 4A754@<F;4CB9G;4GI8ELFBEG7<7;4CC8A

G;<FJ4F8ABH:;GBFHCCBEG49<A7<A:5LG;8GE<8EB9946GG;4G

G;8A8:?<:8AG58;4I<BE64HF87G;8;4E@  <AFGE<6G?<45<?<GL64F8F G;8E8<FHFH4??L@BE8 FGE<A:8AGFG4A74E7)@HFGF;BJCHF; CH??GLC8B9 64HF4?6BAA86G<BA  I #B<A8E

 6BHEG<F8I<78AG<4EL:4G8>88C8E64A786<78J;4G8KC8EG

G8FG<@BAL 8G6 :B8F<A  FGH7<8FJ8E8ABG8ABH:;GBCEBI864HF4??<A>  !8EF>BI<GFI  EBHC!84?G;BBC8E4G<I8  7EBC<AFHEI<I4?E4G8J4F8ABH:;GB:BGB=HEL

 ABGBG4?E86BI8EL BA?LE86BI8EL9BECE8@4GHE8784G;

 6BHEGF4E8FC?<GBAJ;8G;8E)64A5E<A:FH<G<9G;8E8J4F?8FF

G;4A FHEI<I4?6;4A68<A<G<4??L  $<A:FGBAI ;<64:B'2+L  9<E8F64F8

 "9F9<E8J4FF@4??4A7@<:;GABG;4I878FGEBL87CEBC8EGL

4A7J4FFJ4??BJ87HC5LBG;8E9<E8 <GJBH?7584A <AG8EI8A<A:64HF8 5HGABGG;864F8

 ALBA8B9GJBBE@BE8=B<AGGBEG984FBEFJ;BF86BA6HEE<A:

46GFB9A8:?<:8A68E8FH?G<A<A=HEL4E8846;<A7<I<7H4??L

E8FCBAF<5?89BEG;88AG<E874@4:8E8FH?G<A:9EB@G;8<E=B<AG

BE6BA6HEE8AG46GFJ;8E8G;8E84E8GJB64HF8F 846;

A8:?<:8AG <A=HEL4GGE<5HG45?8GB8<G;8E 8<G;8E<F54F<F9BEFH<G

 ,H@@8EFI -<68

 5BG;7898A74AGFJ8E8A8:?<:8AG 5HG64AABGG8??J;<6;B9GJB

J4F64HF8 FB5HE78AF;<9GFGB7898A74AGF

CFG8<A4E:H8FG;4G64F8FFH6;4FG;<FF;BH?758F8I8E4?

?<45<?<GLFBG;4G<A64F8FB94A<AFB?I8AGG;88KC86G87I4?H8

9BEG;8BG;8E<FABG@BE8G;4A<9J8;47C8E986G>ABJ?87:8

 ,><CJBEG;I %847"A7HFGE<8FFFB6<4G<BA

 HF8B9@4E>8GF;4E8?<45<?<GLABG4CCEBCE<4G8;8E8G<@8GBB

:E84G C4<AGFABG9HA:<5?8 ABG4??C4EG<8F=B<A87  )EBK<@4G84HF8!8E8<AB9HGL  4F<6F  4FFH@8F64HF8<A946G

 >8LDH8FG<BA<FJ;8G;8EF6BA7H6GJ4F4FH5FG4AG<4?946GBE

<ACE<A:<A:45BHG)F;4E@  GJBC8EFC86G<I8F

 9BE8F8845<?<GL9BEJ4E7?BB><A:9EB@G<@8B946G<BA

J4F<G9BE8F8845?8  7<E86GA8FF546>J4E79EB@;4E@J4FG;8E84A <AG8EI8A<A:64HF8G;4GF8I8E8764HF4?6BAA86G<BA  );LF<64?"A=HEL  46BA  ,GE88G  +L4AI '28AGE4?++  FE8FCBAF<5?89BECEBK<@4G8 5HGABGE8@BG8 74@4:8F78FGEH6G<BA5L9<E8B9F86BA7 G;<E7

5H<?7<A:F<FABG4A4GHE4?E8FH?GB9G;89<EFG9<E8

 <9CHGF)<A4CBF<G<BAJ;8E8;8E84FBA45?L984EF

9BE;<FF498GL 4A<A=HELE868<I877HE<A:4E84FBA45?8

8F64C8;4F4E<:;GGB46G<BA  <9)46GF<A:BB794<G;GB@<A<@<M8E<F>F9EB@4

74A:8EBHFF<GH4G<BAB9F@4><A: G;BF846G<BAF7B

ABGF8I8E64HF4?6;4<A  8EELI ,H:4E'BG6;BEBH:;  A8:?<:8AGFC887<A:J4FABGG;864HF8B9G;8

466<78AG@8E86;4A68G;4GGEB??8LJ4FG;8E84GG<@8

B9466<78AG  )F6BA7H6G<FABG64HF4??L6BAA86G87J<G;;<F <A=HE<8F<9<G7B8FABG<A6E84F8G;8E<F>B958<A: <A=HE87

 <9846;B9GJBFH668FF<I846GF<FFH99<6<8AGGB;4E@)

5HGG;8F86BA7BA?LB66HEF5864HF8B9G;8

A8:?<:8A68B9G;89<EFG G;8F86BA7<F78C8A78AGBA

G;89<EFGFBG;4GG;8F86BA7<FABE@4??LE8FCBAF<5?8

BA?L9BEG;8<A6E8@8AG4?74@4:8F <94AL

 7LA4@<G864C64F8A8:?<:8AGGB?84I8464CBAG;8

:EBHA7 5HGC4E8AGF58<A:4J4E8<F4A<AG8EI8A<A: 64HF8 FBAB?<45<?<GL  EBJ8EI '28AGE4?!++  HA78EB?7G;8BE<8F BA?LG;8?4FGJEBA:7B8EJ4F

E8FCBAF<5?8 FB6E<@<A4?6BA7H6GF8I8E87G;864HF4?

6BAA86G<BA

 6HEE8AGG8FG<9G;8?<>8?<;BB7G;4G4G;<E7C4EGL@4L

46G<A468EG4<AJ4F<FBA8B9G;8946GBEFG;4G@4784

C4EGLA8:?<:8AG FH6;4A46G7B8FABGCE8I8AGG;8 46GBE9EB@58<A:?<45?89BE;4E@64HF87G;8E85L  04:A8EI "AG8EA4G<BA4?+2  E8F6H864F8 E84FBA45?84GG8@CGF4GE8F6H87BABG5E84>G;8 6;4<AB964HF4G<BA

 HAE84FBA45?8899BEGF4GE8F6H8F;BH?7586BI8E875L

6B@C4E4G<I8A8:?<:8A68 ABGFHC8E687<A:64HF8  "AE8)?B8@<FHEA8FF 0<G;LB  7<E86GA8FFG8FG<FE8FCBAF<5?89BE4??46GF

FG8@@<A:7<E86G?L9EB@;<FA8:?<:8AG46G 8I8A<9ABG

9BE8F8845?8  )4?F:E49I%BA:"F?4A7++  ABA8:?<:8A68<AG;845FGE46G  ?<45<?<GL@HFG58?<A>87GB9BE8F8845<?<GL  &4EF;4??I 'H:8AG  <97<FGHE587J4G8EF4E8ABGL8GC?46<7 @4L58

?<45?89BE9BEG;6B@<A:<A=HE<8F8I8A<9ABGFC86<9<64??L

CE87<6G45?8

 ?<45<?<GLB9A8:?<:8AG46GBE6BA9<A87GBG;BF8;4E@9H?

6BAF8DH8A68FJ;<6;E8FH?G9EB@G;8BC8E4G<BAB9G;8

E<F> BEB94E<F> G;89BE8F8845<?GLB9J;<6;E8A78E87

G;87898A74AGOF6BA7H6GA8:?<:8AG 

(I8EF84F-4A>F;<C.$%G7 I &BEGFB6>A:<A88E<A:

B %G7 04:BA&BHA7

 9BE8F8845<?<GLG8FG9BE8F<:;GB9G;8E84FBA45?8@4A

78G8E@<A8FE8FCBAF<5<?<GL  @8E<64A6BHEGFF88@ :8A8E4??L GB4:E88J<G; )B?8@<F  /<E78AI 8GGF4A788EBAFGEH6G<BAB  7898A74AGF5E846;B9G;8<E7HGLB964E8<FBA?L

46G<BA45?8<9<G<F4?FBG;8CEBK<@4G864HF8B9G;8

<A=HEL  !8E58EGI ABF

 <A=HELJ4FABGB94GLC8G;4GJBH?7589BE8F8845?L

64HF875LG;8A8:?<:8A684A7<FG;HFABG?<45?8  @BG<BA4?<FGE8FF

 DH8FG<BA<FJ;<6;64F8FF;BH?7587<F@<FF875LC8EF8EH?8

4A7J;<6;F;BH?7:BGBG;8=HEL  &<G6;8??I +B6;8FG8E+L

 ABE86BI8ELG;8E8<FJBEELG;4G8@BG<BA4?7<FGE8FF

<FGBB84FLGB94>8  FH5F8DH8AG?L47BCG87G8FGF  <@C46GEH?8G;8E8@HFG586BAG46G9BE E86BI8EL  MBA8B974A:8EEH?8<@C46GBE)58<A:<AG;8 MBA8B974A:8E@84AFE86BI8EL<FCBFF<5?8  <??BAI %8::

 E8C?4687MBA8B974A:8EEH?8J<G;6?BF8E8?4G<BAF;<C

BE7<E86GB5F8EI4G<BA

 984EFH<GF@HFG:8A8E4??LF;BJG;4G984E<FE4G<BA4?

 99<E@4G<I8HG<8F  -;8HGLGB+8F6H8  %H>8  H6;I @BEI&4AH946GHE<A:B  AB7HGLGB4GE8FC4FF8E  AB<A6E84F877HGLGB46;<?7GE8FC4FF8E  !HE?8LI 77<A:9<8?7 AB499<E@4G<I87HGL9BE7B6GBEFGBC8E9BE@  B;?8A  @8F

 EH?8G;4GBA8J;B94<?FGBF4I84ABG;8E <9;864AJ<G;?<GG?8

BEAB<A6BAI8A<8A68 F;BH?758CHA<F;87  CFG8<A

 4E:H8F4:4<AFG@8F<GJBH?7587<99<6H?GGB8A9BE68

CEBC8E?L4A7I<B?4G8FCE<A6<C?8B94HGBAB@L  )BFA8E  8A78E  &BAG:B@8ELI '4G<BA4?BAIBL4A7-EH6><A:B

 <9F6BA7H6G G;BH:;ABGGBEG<BHF 6E84G8FE<F> 74A:8EBHF

F<GH4G<BAG;846GBE;4F47HGLGB8K8E6<F8E84FBA45?864E8GB

CE8I8AGBE@<A<@<M8G;8;4E@

 <9HA78EG4>8F4E8F6H8 8I8A<9HA78EABB5?<:4G<BAGB7B

FB 4A746GH4??L;4E@F) G;8E8<F?<45<?<GL<9E84FBA45?864E8

BE64E8<F7<F6BAG<AH87  HG<8FB9(JA8EF4A7(66HC<8EF

 +B58EGI 77<8,BAFB?<8E<8F %G7 I H@5E86>

 G;E8864G8:BE<8FB9I<F<GBEF

 <AI<G88F;<:;8FG?8I8?B97HGLGBG4>8E84FBA45?8

64E8GB8AFHE8CE8@<F8F4E8F498

 ?<68AF88FF86BA7;<:;8FG?8I8?7HGLABGGB6E84G84

GE4CBE4??BJ46BA684?8774A:8E  GE8FC4FF8EFAB7HGL  8K68CG<BA9BEJ4AGBABEJ<??9H?6BA7H6G  4GGE46G<I8AH<F4A68

 6;<?7GE8FC4FF8EF64AE86BI8E<9?HE87BAGB?4A75L

G8@CG<A:6BA7<G<BA6E84G87 @4<AG4<A875L  8?8@8AGF  >ABJFBEF;BH?7>ABJG;4G6;<?7E8A4E8 ?<>8?LGBGE8FC4FF  >ABJFBEF;BH?7>ABJG;4G<GJBH?758 HAE84FBA45?L74A:8EBHF  5HE78AB98?<@<A4G<A:G;8E<F><FF?<:;G 6B@C4E87GBG;8E<F>  94<?FGB8K8E6<F8E84FBA45?864E8GBCEBG86G 6;<?7E8A  +BJ?4A7I ;E<FG<4A  6BHEGGBFF8FBHGG;E88 GLC87<FG<A6G<BA

 <AFG<GHG8F4E84FBA45?8A8FFG8FG;4F?4A7BJA8E46G874F4

E84FBA45?8C8EFBAJBH?7<A?<:;GB9G;8CEB545<?<GLB9<A=HEL

GBBG;8EF

 BG;8EFG4G8F;4I8454A7BA87<AI<G88 ?<68AF887<FG<A6G<BA 5HG

>8CGGE8FC4FF8E  +58FGFLFG8@>88CFG;E8878F<:A4G<BAF  G;8L4E8<@C8E986G

 G;<F@BI8F7<99<6H?GLGB8FG45?<F;<A:G;86?4FFGB

J;<6;K58?BA:FBA688FG45?<F;87 64F8<F84FL  E4GH<GBHF.A78EG4><A:F  B::FI 8EA4E7  BJA8EGEHFG<A:KJ<G;:BB7F<F6BAF<78E4G<BA  5E846;B9GEHFGE8FH?GF<A?<45<?<GLE8?<4A68  &B6;B I +8AFF8?48E04G8EB ,C86<4?+8?4G<BAF;<CF  +7F86  $?<A8I  &I8 C4EG@8AGBEC

 %4A7?BE7F;4I847HGLGBG4>8FG8CFGBCEBG86GG8A4AGF9EB@

6E<@8J;8AABG<68B9CE8I<BHF6E<@8F<A4E84FHA78E;<F

6BAGEB?;4F588A:<I8A

 ,C86<4?E8?4G<BAF;<C7HG<8F;4I8588A8KC4A787GB6B??8:8F

9BEG;8<EFGH78AGF 6B@@BA64EE<8EF4A7G;8<EC4FF8A:8EF

6BA7B4FFB6<4G<BAF 4A79BEB99 CE8@<F8F?<45<?<GL 5HG6BHEGF ;4I8:8A8E4??L;8F<G4G87GB8KC4A77HGL@H6;  -4E4FB99I +8:8AGFB9.A<I8EF<GLB94?<9BEA<4

 'BA8:?<:8A68<A:8GG<A:CE87<6G<BAB974A:8EJEBA: 5HG<9

CFL6;<4GE<FG58?<8I8FG;4GFB@8BA8CE8F8AGF4F8E<BHF

74A:8EGB4FC86<9<6C8EFBABEC8EFBAFG;8E8<F47HGLGB

8K8E6<F8E84FBA45?864E8GBCEBG86GG;89BE8F8845?8I<6G<@B9

G;4G74A:8E

 AB7HGLGBCEBG86G4:4<AFG:8A8E4?<M8774A:8E@HFG584

CE8I8AG45?874A:8E

 HGHE8CEB@<F8F64A4?FB58G;854F<F9BE?<45<?<GLJ8J<??

64??LBHJ;8AJ8E8?84F8;<@  -E47<G<BA4?,GE<6G%<45<?<GL

 .?GE4;4M4E7BHFBE5ABE@4??L4A:8EBHF6G<I<G<8F

 +7F86  One who carries on an abnormally dangerous activity is This strict liability is limited to the kind of harm, the +7F86  In determining whether an activity is abnormally dangerous, (a) existence of a high degree of risk of some harm (b) likelihood that the harm that results from it will (c) inability to eliminate the risk by the exercise of (d) extent to which the activity is not a matter of (e) inappropriateness of the activity to the place (f) extent to which its value to the community is +7F86  (a) A defendant who carries on an abnormally dangerous (b) An activity is abnormally dangerous if: (1) the activity creates a foreseeable and highly (2) the activity is not a matter of common usage.

+H?GE4;4M4E7BHFF;BH?7CEB545?L58:BI8EA875LFG4A74E7

A8:?<:8A68  )EB7H6GF%<45<?<GL  BHEFG4:8FEBH:;?L  <EFGC8E<B7E4A9EB@@<7 A<A8G88AG;68AGHELGB84E?LGJ8AG<8G;

J;8A@4=BE7854G8J4FJ;8G;8EGB4??BJ4ALFH<GF4G4??4:4<AFG

CEB7H6G@4AH946GHE8EFBEF8??8EF%4FG;4?9B9A<A8G88AG;68AGHEL

J<GA8FF874FG847L5HG?<@<G878EBF<BAB9PCE<I<GL?<@<G4G<BAJ;<6;

FGBCC876BAFH@8EF9EB@FH<A:4ALBA8BG;8EG;4AJ;B8I8E7<E86G?L

FB?7G;8@G;8CEB7H6G

 ,86BA7C8E<B758:4AJ<G;&46);8EFBA 4??BJ<A:9BEA8:?<:8A68

4:4<AFG4@4AH946GHE8EJ<G;J;B@G;85HL8E;47AB6BAGE46GH4?

E8?4G<BAF;<C

 -;<E7FG4:858:4AJ<G;F6B?4 4CC?L<A:FGE<6G?<45<?<GLCE<A6<C?8FGB

CEB7H6GF?<45<?<GL64F8F

 BHEG;4A79<A4?FG4:8784?GJ<G;78986G<I878F<:A4A77HGLGBJ4EA

64F8F  KCBF<G<BA  0<AG8E5BGGB@I 0E<:;G

 8K4@C?8B946BHEGE89HF<A:GB4??BJCEB7H6GF?<45<?<GL64F8

5864HF8B9 CE<I<GLB96BAGE46G  &46);8EFBAI H<6>&BGBEB

 "9G;8E8<F>ABJ?87:8G;4GG;8G;<A:J<??58HF875LC8EFBAF

BG;8EG;4AG;8CHE6;4F8E 4A7HF87J<G;BHGA8JG8FGF G;8A

G;8@4AH946GHE8E<FHA78E47HGLGB@4>8<G64E89H??L

<EE8FC86G<I8B96BAGE46G

 -;8E8@HFG58>ABJ?87:8B974A:8E ABG@8E8?LCBFF<5?8

5HGCEB545?8  F6B?4I B64B?4BGG?<A:B B9E8FAB

 I8A<9G;8E8<FABA8:?<:8A68 CH5?<6CB?<6LE8DH<E8FG;4G

E8FCBAF<5<?<GL589<K87J;8E8

Politique de confidentialité -Privacy policy