[PDF] ..Theory and Practice in Light of

View - Download ..Theory and Practice in Light of

Previous PDF

Next PDF

ABHANDLUNGEN

InterimMeasuresofProtection:

..Theory andPractice in Light of theIran-UnitedStatesClaimsTribunal

DavidD.Caron

Contents

I.TheExtentand

Significance

oftheInterimMeasuresPracticeofthe

Iran-UnitedStates

ClaimsTribunal

11. A

Critical

Analysis

of the

Interim

Measures

Practice

of the

Iran-United

States

Claims

Tribunal

I .The

Functionand

Source

ofthe Power to Order

Interim

Measures

2. The

Precondition

of a

Requestby

a Party 3. The Power to Order

Temporary

Restraining

Measures

4. The Scope ofthe Power to Order

Interim

Measures

(a)

Limitations

Arising

from the

Subject-Matter

ofthe

Dispute

(b) The

Requirement

of p7ima facieJurisdiction (c)

TheRelation

of the

Merits

of the

Underlying

Claim to the

Appropriateness

of

Granting

Interim

Measures

(d) The

Requirements

of

Substantial

Prejudice

and

Urgency

(e)

Against

Whom

Interim

Measures

May beOrdered (f)

WhatActions

are

Subject

to

Interim

Measures

andWhat Types of

Measures

May be

Granted

5. The Right to a

Hearing

on

Interim

Measures

6. The Costs of

Interim

Measures

7

Tribunal

and

Municipal

Court

Relations

on theGranting of

Interim

Measures

8. The

Mandatory

Characterand

Enforceability

of

Interim

Measures

9.

Sanctions

for

Failure

to

Implement

Interim

Measures

10.

Reconsideration

and

Revocation

of

Interim

Measures

111.

Concluding

Observation:

Procedural

Decision-Making

in theArea of

Interim

Measures

I

Attorney,

Pillsbury,

Madison

&

Sutro,

San

Francisco.

Formerly

Legal

Assistant

to

Charles

N.

Brower

and

Richard

M. Mosk,

Members,

the

Iran-United

States

Claims

Tribunal.

This article was writtenwhile a

ResearchFellow

at the Max

Planck

Institutefor

Comparative

Public

Law and

International

Law. A bb rev i a t i o ns: AJIL

American

journal of

International

Law; BYBIL

British

466
Caron judicial andarbitral proceedings taketime --occasionally a great deal of time.Asaresultcourtsandtribunals may becalled upon to preserve the allegedrights ofthe partiesduringthe'pendency ofthe proceedings. What shouldacourtortribunaldo-when, for example, a party institutesan actionseeking thereturnofav .aluable piece of property whichisstored by theconclu- sionofthe proceedings?

Anarea

of procedural lawoftenreferredtoas "interimmeasures of protection" addrmes this question2.

ThisArticle

analyzes the practice ofthe

Iran-UnitedStates

ClaimsTri-

bunaJ3 (hereinafter"Tribunal") undertheUNCITRAL

RulesofArbitral

International

LegalMaterials;RIAAReports

ofInternationalArbitralAwards;Y.B.

Com.Arb.YearbookCommercialArbitration.

2 This area. of procedure..also hasbeenItermed provisional relief.Forarecentextensive annotated bibliography onthe subject, seeReichert,ProvisionalRemedies inInter- national

Litigation:

A

ComprehensiveBibliography,

19Int'l

Lawyer,

1429
(1985). 3

TheIran-UnitedStatesClaimsTribunalwas

establishedin1981 pursuant tothe

Popular.Republic

of

Algeria

(hereinafter the"GeneralDeclaration") and.theDeclarationoftheGovernmentofthe theSettlementofClaimsby the

Republic

of

Iran(hereinafter

referredtoasthe

Algiers

Accords.AstotheTribunal,seegenerally

TheIran-UnitedStatesClaimsTribunal

1981-1983(R.

Lilliched.,1984);

andStewart,

TheIran-UnitedStatesClaims

Tribunal:AReviewof

Developments1983784,

16Law&Poli

inInternationalBusiness,

677-754(1984).

whoweremembersof the panelrendering theaward.TheChairmanisalways listedfirstwiththeotherarbitrators followinginalphabetical order.

Parentheticallyfollowing

eachnameis,,as appropriate, a letterorletters reflecting thearbitrators' position vis-a-vistheTribunal'saward.These symbols are:

CConcurring

D

Dissenting

CSConcurring

viastatement bysignature g viastatementb'siDSDissentin yignature

COConcurringOpinion

DODissentingOpinion

SO

SeparateOpinion

RSRefusalto

sign indicate dissentorconcurrencewiththe particularproceduralpointbeing. discussedinthis study.

Specifically

relevantdissentsorconcurrences arecited directly.

Procedure

4 intheareaofinterimmeasures.In doing sotheArticlealso attempts to provide arestatementofthe customarypractice whichisoften drawn-upon to supplement the usuallyquotesdbs_dbs46.pdfusesText_46

[PDF] Le "truc" de Mr Villu

[PDF] Le 100 mètres du pharaon

[PDF] le 11 septembre 2001

[PDF] le 14 octobre 2012 felix baumgartner exercice corrigé

[PDF] Le 17-18 eme siecle :)

[PDF] le 17ème siècle résumé pdf

[PDF] le 1er janvier 2010 yoda un extraterrestre regarde la terre

[PDF] le 1er novembre 1954 en Algérie, jour de la Toussaint

[PDF] le 21 svp je ne comprend rien

[PDF] le 27 janvier 2012 peu avant 16h

[PDF] le 2eme exercice du dns n°3 de mathematique

[PDF] Le 2nd degre

[PDF] le 3 mai 1808

[PDF] le 360 en français

[PDF] le 4 août 1789 : l' abolition des privilèges histoire