Glande Pinéale : 5 techniques ancestrales pour ouvrir son 3ème œil
L'hypothalamus l'hypophyse et la glande pinéale jouent des rôles particulièrement importants dans l'expérience spirituelle. On les abordera plus en détail
Glande Pinéale : 5 techniques ancestrales pour ouvrir son 3ème œil
L'hypothalamus l'hypophyse et la glande pinéale jouent des rôles particulièrement importants dans l'expérience spirituelle. On les abordera plus en détail
Épisode 10 de Cosmic Disclosure - Éveiller la glande pinéale
glande pinéale et envoyaient des vagues soniques à cet endroit. génétique mais avait aussi une nature spirituelle et ils tentaient de nous rehausser ...
Le stress : ami ou ennemi ?
12 sept. 2016 La glande pinéale carbure vraisemblablement à la lumière du soleil. ... l'effet de la spiritualité sur le cerveau humain. Résultat?
Les reflets cornéens un miroir ouvert sur lâme
René Descartes désigne ainsi la glande pinéale comme le siège de l'âme4 dans son ouvrage L'homme également connu sous le titre Traité de la lumière.
LE « SACRÉ NOIR » CHEZ GEORGES BATAILLE ET HUBERT
Théorie de la religion L'Érotisme
Corps arts et spiritualité chez François DELSARTE (1811-1871)
Corps arts et spiritualité chez François DELSARTE contact entre l'âme et le corps se ferait par la glande pinéale – mais l'explication de l'union de ...
Lunion de lâme et du corps dans la philosophie de Descartes
5 févr. 2019 corporelle pour le mouvement et spirituelle pour le vouloir. ... 5 La glande pinéale comme siège principale de l'âme est unique ...
Les mues du serpent
irlandaises3 que dans l'art de l'Islam religion qui s'est qu'est la glande pinéale et
la naturopathie pour harmoniser les centres energetiques
psychique et spirituel. Il est à noter que seuls les êtres humains sont pourvus d?une glande pinéale. Dysfonctionnements et signes de perturbation du chakra.
UNIVERSITÉ DE STRASBOURG -:yf 1:-4:âèyf 1f6 2vhè3p4f6 [ CREPHAC, EA 2326 ] THÈSE présentée par : Megumi TOYOOKA soutenue le : 27 septembre 2018 pour obtenir le grade de : Docteur de l'université de Strasbourg Discipline : Philosophie L'union de l'âme et du corps dans la philosophie de DescartesM THÈSE dirigée par : M. Frédéric DE BUZON Professeur, université de Strasbourg RAPPORTEURS : M. Denis KAMBOUCHNER Professeur, université Paris I Panthéon-Sorbonne M. Thierry MARTIN Professeur, université de Franche-Comté, Besançon AUTRES MEMBRES DU JURY : Mme Kim-Sang ONG-VAN-CUNG Professeur, université Bordeaux-Montaigne
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`(,,(.!F4'(!%5+(.!a!U-66(5 4!,#D6(!(4!,(!2-') .!)(%&(54`+,.!F4'(!.%M.4354+(,,(6(54!0+.4+524.8!.#+,.!.-54!'(,+;.!3%!)-+54!/%#-5!)%+..(!)3',('!0#%5+-5!(54'(!,(.!0(%=!a!U(!.-54!2(.!/%(.4+-5.!/%(!,3!)';.(54(!'(2*('2*(!.(!)'-)-.(!0#;4%0+('8!(5!.#(5!4(5354!@!,3!)(5.;(!0( !1(.2 3'4(.8!+5 0;)(50366(54!0(!.(.!0; &(,-))(6(5 4.!2-54(6)-'3+5.>!I%4'(6(54!0+48!5-4'(!'(2*('2*(!(54(50!;4%0+('!,(.!0+<<+2%,4;.!.-%,(&;(.!)3'!,3!4*N.(!0(!,b%5+-5!0(!,bD6(!(4!0%!2-').!035.!,3!)(5.;(!0(!1(.23'4(.>!R,!.#3:+'3!),%.!)';2+.;6(54!0b(=36+5('!,(.!<3c-5.! 0-54!-5!)(%4!+54(')';4('!,3!) (5.;(!0(!1( .23'4(.!2-52('5354!2(44(!.+4%34+-5!2-54'30+24-+'(8!/%#(.4!,3!)-.+4+-5!.+6%,435;(!0(!,3!0+.4+524+-5!';(,,(!(4!0(!,#%5+-5!.%M.4354+(,,(!0(!,#D6(!(4!0%!2-').8!(4!0#+0(54+<+('!/%(,,(!36-'2(!0(!.-,%4+-5!1(.23'4(.!5-%.!.%::N'(8!.32*354!/%(!2(44(!4(5434+&(!0(!.-,%4+-5!(.4!(,,(`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b3)'N.!,3/%(,,(!2(.!0(%=!.%M.4352(.!.-54!2-52(&3M,(.!,#%5(!.35.!,#3%4'(8!)%+.!035.!%5!.(2-50!4(6).!+,!2-5.+0N'(!%5(!%5+-5!.%M.4354+(,,(8!2*3':;(!0(!'(50'(!2-6)4(!0(!,3!2-66%5+234+-5!0(!2(.!0(%=!.%M.4352(.>!"(!4+4'(!,34+5!0(.!68+$%4%$"*2!+50+/%(!/%#+,!.#3:+4!0(!6'+$%4%$"*'2(+'(/0$)4(/&$1"2"/& $4!$*(97$-72(3'$(':$2%'*%$4;($(4*$)4'(&7)4*4'(4(!"0/"0'(+$2%$*!%$";(+')"*2%04%70!L+6!O[\\dP!=&$1"2"/&.(">(6$*+8![0!(0>8!e-%,0('!Y!X(.4&+(K!?'(..!C!4'30>!<'>!O[\\fP8!=&$1"2"/&$'(+'(15'2/0$%8!?3'+.!Y!"(.!g0+4+-5.!0#R4*3/%(8!)>!]>!_350'+5(!h-%=8!/%+!2+4(!2(!)3..3:(!0(!J3(:K-5!L+68!6-54'(!2,3+'(6(54!2-66(54!,(.!.2+(52(.!2-:5+4+&(.!2-54(6)-'3+5(.!*;'+4(54!0(!,3!';<,(=+-5!0(!1(.23'4(.8!2<>!_>!h-%=!O[\H^P!0+'>8!?'(!"0/2( '%(15'2/0$%(@(=0 "-1A)'2(!40%82$'*2;(/0"-1A)'2 (!"*%')/"04$*28!?3 '+.!Y!g0 +4+-5.!0(.!I'2*+&(.!2-54(6)-'3+5(.!C!&-+'!;:3,(6(54!0%!6F6(!3%4(%'!?5')/0'$*%'(!40%82$'**'<(?5$*%'04!%$"*(/2.!&"/&.2$97';(+8-4%2(!1422$97'2('%(!"*%')/"04$*28!?3'+.!Y!U,3..+/%(.!i3'5+('8![\Hf>!
!!]!,3!<-+.!,#(=+.4(52(!0(!1+(%!(4!,3!0+.4+524+-5!0(!,#D6(!0#3&(2!,(!2-').>!A5!2-5.434(!3+5.+!0#%5(!)3'4!/%(!1(.23'4(.!,+(!+2+!,3!0;6-5.4'34+-5!0(!,#(=+.4(52(!0(!1+(%!(4!,3!/%(.4+-5!0(!,3!0+.4+524+-5!0(!,#D6(!(4!0%!2-').8!,+3+.-5!/%#+,!5-%.!<3%0'3!+54(''-:('8!(4!0#3%4'(!)3'48!/%#+,!5#(.4!)3.!< 3+4!';<;'(52(!@!,# %5+-5!0(!,# D6(!(4!0%!2-').8 !63+.!.(%,(6(54!@!,(%'!0+.4+524+-5>!!E4!0(!<3+48!0(!,3!)'(6+N'(!68+$%4%$"*!@!,3!)'(6+N'(!)3'4+(!0(!,3!.+=+N6(8!+,!4'3+4(!0(!2(44(!0+.4+524+-58!(4!2#(.4!.(%,(6(54!035.!,3!0('5+N'(!)3'4+(!/%(!,3!/%(.4+-5!0(!,(%'!%5+-5!(.4!3M-'0;(>!U-66(54!3,-'.!(5!3''+&(`4`+,!@!4'3+4('!0(!,#%5+-5!0(!,#D6(!(4!0%!2-').!a!j%(,,(!)-.+4+-5!,%+!0-55(!4`+,!)3'!'3))-'4!@!,3!0+.4+524+-5!(4!3%..+!/%(,,(!.+:5+<+234+-5!'(c-+4`(,,(!a!!"(!M%4!0(!,3!)';.(54(!'(2*('2*(!;4354!0#;4%0+('!,(.!0+<<+2%,4;.!.-%,(&;(.!)3'!,3!4*N.(!0(!,#%5+-5!0(!,#D6(!(4!0%!2 -').8!(4 !0-52!0(!6(44'(! 3%!2,3+'!,(%'!'(,34+-5!(5!2-5.+0;'354!,3!Q!<-'2(!0(!,#D6(!W38!+,!2-5&+(54!0(!4 '3+4('!,(.!/%(.4 +-5.!.%+&354 (.8!/%+!)('6(44(54!0#;2,3+'('!,(!0(..+5!4-43,!0(!,3!'(,34+-5!(54'(!,(.!0(%=!.%M.4352(.!Y!!U-66(54!1(.23'4(.!,%+`6F6(!2-52+,+(`4`+,!,(.!0(%=!4*N.(.!)-%'!)(5.('!,3!'(,34+-5!(54'(!,#D6(!(4!,(!2-').!a!!j%(,,(!;&-,%4+-5!)( %4`-5!3)('2(&-+'! 035.!,3! )(5.;(!0(!1(.23'4(.!(54 '(!,(.!68+$%4%$"*2()8%4/&.2$97'2!(4!,3!B"00'2/"*+4*!'!3&(2!E,+.3M(4*!a!E4!/%(,,(!(.4!,#+5<,%(52(!0(!2(44(!2-''(.)-50352(!.%'!,3!.-,%4+-5!23'4;.+(55(!0(!,3!0+<<+2%,4;!@!)(5.('!,#%5+-5!0(!,#D6(!(4!0%!2-').!a!!?-%'/%-+!1(.23'4(.! 3`4`+,!+54'-0%+4!, 3!2-52()4+-5!0(!,b%5+-5!035. !,3!.+=+N6( !68+$%4%$"*;(-9!(,, (!2-5.4+4%(!%5!)'-M, N6(!2(54'3,!0%!4(=4( !a!E4!)-%'/%-+8!1(.23' 4(.!'(2-%'4`+,!@!,#(=)'(..+-5!.2-,3.4+/%(!0#k%5+43.!.%M.4354+3,+.k!a!!"3!/%(.4+ -5!.(!)-.(!;:3,(6(54!0(!.3& -+'!.+8! ,-'./%(!1(.23'4(.!4'3+4(!0(!,3!0+.4+524+-5!';(,,(!(54'(!,#D6(!*%63+5(!(4!,(!2-').!035.!,(.!68+$%4%$"*28!+,!.#3:+4!)-%'!,%+!0(!';)-50'(!@!,3!/%(.4+-5!Y!/%#(.4`2(!/%(!,#*-66(!a!B3+.!1(.23'4(.!3!0;7@8!.(6M,(`4`+,8!3M-'0;!2(44(!/%(.4+-5!035.!.-5!4'3+4;!3'(15&"))'8!)%M,+;!(5!Hddl8!63+.!';0+:;!0N.!,(.!355;(.!Hd]\>!_35.!0-%4(!,3!/%(.4+-5!(.4!035.!2(!4(=4(!4'3+4;(!@!%5!5+&(3%!.2+(54+<+/%(8!2(,%+!0(!,3!) *S.+-,-:+(8!4350+.!/%(! ,(.!68+$%4%$"*2!.(!0;&(,-) )(54!.%'!,(!),35!6;43)*S.+/%(>!A5!5(!)(%4!0-52!2-5<-50'(!2(.!0(%=!)('.)(24+&(.>!R,!'(.4(!/%(!,3!'(,34+-5!(54'(!,(!4(=4(!0(.!68+$%4%$"*2!(4!,(.!4*N.(.!0;&(,-));(.!035.!,(!4'3+4;!3'(15&"))'!0(&'3!F4'(!+54(''-:;(>!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!]!U<>!1(5+.!L36M-%2*5('8!?5&"))'(+'2(/422$"*28!?3'+.!Y!I,M+5!B+2*(,8!Hmm^8!))>!Hd]`Hdl>!
!!l! 135.!,(!C.*"/2$2!)';.(54;!(5!-%&('4%'(! 0(.!68+$%4%$"*28!1(.23'4(.!3..+:5(!@! ,#-%&'3:(!2+5/!M%4.!@!,3!.+=+N6(!68+$%4%$"*!Y!!H>!Q!+54(,,(24+-!3M!+63:+534+-5(!.(2('5+4%'!C!0+.4+524+-5%6!.+:53!0(.2'+M%54%'!W!OQ!7(!0+.4+5:%(!,#324+-5!0(!,#(54(50(6(54!0#3&(2!2(,,(!0(!,#+63:+534+-5!C!,(.!63'/%(.!0(!2(44(!0+.4+524+-5!S!.-54!0;2'+4(.!WPl>![>!Q!6(54(6!'(3,+4('!3!2-')-'(!0+.4+5:%+8!)'-M34%'!W!OQ!J#S!6-54'(!/%(!,#D6(!0(!,#*-66(!(.4!';(,,(6(54!0+.4+524(!0%!2-').!WP>!]>!Q!436!3'24(!+,,+&2-')-'+'(..(!2-57%524368!%4!%5%6!/%+0!2%6!+).3!2-6)-5348!-.4(50+4%'!W!OQ!(4!4-%4(<-+.!n!/%#(,,(!5(!2-6)-.(!/%(!2-66(!%5(!6F6(!2*-.(!3&(2!,%+!WP>!l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oRR8!H^P5>!U-66(!2(!6-4!0(!Q!*$&$1")$*72!W6!,#+50+/%(8!1(.23'4(.!.-%,+:5(!3%032+(%.(6(54!/%(!,(.!0(%=!.%M.4352(.!/%+!.(!0+.4+5:%(548!0-+&(54!3))3'(66(548!F4'(!2-6)'+.(.!035.!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!l!V'30%24+-5!<'35c3+.(!0(!p('0+5350!I,/%+;8!+5!3'2!40%'2(GH7I0'2(=&$1"2"/&$97'2(V-6(!RR8!i3'5+('!p'N'(.!Y!?3'+.8!Hmdq8!)>!l\]>!^!J-08#88!IV!Rr8!HH`H[!Y!Q!E5<+58!035.!,3!.+=+N6(8!7(!0+.4+5:%(!,#324+-5!0(!,#(54(50(6(54!0#3&(2!2(,,(!0(!,#+63:+534+-5!C!,( .!63'/%(.!0 (!2(44(!0+.4+524+-5!S!.-54! 0;2'+4(.> !J#S!6-54'(!/%(!,#D6 (!0(!,#*-66(!(.4!';(,,(6(54!0+.4+524 (!0%!2-').8!(4!4-%4(<-+.!/%#( ,,(!,%+!( .4!.+!;4'-+4(6(54!2-5 7-+54(!(4 !%5+(8!/%#(,,(!5(!2-6)-.(!/%(!2-66(!%5(!6F6(!2*-.(!3&(2!,%+!W>!E5!<'35c3+.8!k*$&$1")$*72k!(.4!4'30%+4!)3'!Q!(4!4-%4(<-+.!W>!R,!6(!.(6M,(!/%(!,#+0;(!0(!1(.23'4(.!.%'!,(!'3))-'4!(54'(!,#D6(!(4!,(!2-').!(.4!+50+/%;(!+2+>!!d!"3!5;:34+-5!(5!,34+5!(.4!.%.2()4+M,(!0(!0(%=!<-'6(.!Y!,#%5(!(.4!,#%.3:(!)3'30-=3,8!(4!,#3%4'(!(.4!,#%.3:(!0%!2-54'3.4(>!U(!6-4!0(!k*$&$1")$*72k!(.4!0(!,3!) '(6+N'(!< -'6(!O)3'30-=3,(P>!U<>!U*3',4-5!V>!"(K+.8!J*(
!!^!%5(!%5+4;8!2(!/%(!&+.(!,#(=)'(..+-5!Q!7*7)(97$+!W>!I!2(!.430(8!1(.23'4(.!.(6M,(!2-5.2+(54!0(!,3!0+<<+2%,4;!0(!)(5.('!,3!'(,34+-5!(54'(!,(.!0(%=>!B3+.8!(5!6F6(!4(6).8!@!2(44(!;43)(!0(.!68+$%4%$"*2;(,(.(0(%=!.%M.4352(.(.-54!0+.4+5:%;(.>!1-52!,(!)'-M,N6(!3%/%(,!5-%.!0(&-5.!<3+'(!<32(!(.4!2(44(!3))3'(54(!2-54'30+24+-58!(4!5-%.!0(&-5.!3+5.+!(=36+5('!.+!1(.23'4(.!)-%''3!,3!';.-%0'(!-%!5-5>!!"#(=);'+(52(!5-%.!.(6M,(!.#-'+:+5('!035.!,3!0+&('.+4;!0(!5-4'(!'3))-'4!@!5-4'(!)'-)'(!2-').8!'3))-'4!/%+!5(!2(..(!0(!2*35:('8!.+!M+(5!/%(!5-%.!)-%&-5.!0+'(!/%(!5-%.!3&-5.!5-4'(!2-').!.35.!0+'(!/%(!5-%.!.-66(.!5-4'(!2-').>!E.4`2(!2(44(!0+&('.+4;!/%+!(=),+/%(!/%(!5-4'(!.(54+6(54!3%!.%7(4!0(!,3!.-,+03'+4;!0%!2-').!(4!0(!,#D6(!5(!2(..(!0#;&-,%('!a!U3'!,(!0%3,+.6(!3<<+'6(!,3!.;)3'3M+,+4;!0%!2-').!(4!0(!,#D6(8!63+.!,#(=);'+(52(!0%!.(54+6(54!(4!0(!,3!.(5.34+-5!5-%.!(5.(+:5(!,(%'!+5.;)3'3M+,+4;7>!"3!.(5.34+-5!(4!,(!.(54+6(54!.-54!(5!+54+6(!'(,34+-58!63+.!,(%'.!.+:5+<+234+-5.!.-54!.-+4!0+.4+5:%;(.8!.-+4!+0(54+<+;(.8!.(,-5!, (.!4(= 4(.!0(!1(.23'4(.>!I+5.+8!,3!KA#1'!rRR!;2' +4!@!)'-)-.!0(! ,3!.(5.34+-5!Y!Q!"3!<+:%'(!/%#+,!s,(!.(5.!(=4('5(t!'(c-+4!.(!4'35.)-'4(!@!%5(!3%4'(!)3'4+(!0%!2-').!/%#-5!3))(,,(!,(!.(5.!2-66%58!(4!2(2+8!(5!%5!+5.43548!(4!.35.!/%#+,!S!3+4!)3..3:(!';(,!0#3%2%5!F4'(!0#%5!(50'-+4!@!,#3%4'(!Wf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m>!135.!,3!.+=+N6(!68+$%4%$"*8!,3!0; <+5+4+-5!0%!.(54+6(54!5#(.4!)3.!%5+&-/%(>!E,,(!+52,%4!3%..+!,#3));4+4!-%!,(!0;.+'8!(42>!!"3!0- %,(%'!5-%.!)'-%&(!,#%5+-5!0(!,#D6(!( 4!0%!2-').8!(5!4 354!/%(! 6-0(!0(!)('2()4+-5!0(!,3!'%)4%'(!0(.!<+,(4 .!5('&(%=8!(4!<3+4!)3'4+(!0#% 5(!;5%6;'34+-5!0(!.(54+6(54.!/%+!2-6)'(50!3%..+!,(!2*34-%+,,(6(548!,(.!.(5.34+-5.!0(!,+..(!(4!0(!'%0(8!0(!2*3%0!(4!0(!<'-+08!0#*%6+0(!(4!0(!.(28!(42>8!2#(.4`@`0+'(!,(.!0+&('.(.!.(5.34+-5.!4324+,(.8!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!'1')'*%40.(14%$*(+$!%$"*40.8!A=<-'08!Hm^d8!)>!^]d>!?-%'!u*$&$1")$*72T8!+,!(.4!(=),+/%;!+2+!/%(!Y!Q!*"*'(%&'(1'22;(F72%(42()7!&;(*"(1'22;(*'I'0%&'1'22(W>!V-%.!.(.!6-4.!.-54!%4+,+.;.!)3'30-=3,(6(54>!!q!135.!?5L"))'8!+,!6(!.(6M,(!/%(!,(!.(54+6(54!(.4!4'3+4;!0+<<;'(66(54!0(!,3!.(5.34+-5!(5!4354!/%(!6-0(!0(!)('2()4+-5>!Q!j%350!1+(%!%5+'3!%5(!I6(!h3+.-53M,(!@!2(44(!632*+5(n!+,!,%+!0-55('3!.-5!.+N:(!)'+52+)3,!035.!,(!2('&(3%8!(4!,3!<('3!0(!4(,,(!534%'(!/%(!.(,-5!,(.!0+&('.(.!<3c-5.!/%(!,(.!(54';(.!0(.!)-'(.!/%+!.-54!(5!,3!. %)('<+2+(! +54;'+(%'(!0(!2(!2('&(3%!.('-54!-%&('4 (.!)3'!,#(54'(6+.(!0(.!5('<.8 !(,,(!3% '3!0+ &('.!.(54+6(54.!W!OIV!rR8!Hl]P>!!f!K'#714(MDD8!IV!r8!lHl>!!m!IV!Rr8!d\>!!
!!d!0-54!,3!0(.2'+)4+-5!(.4!.%+&+(!)3'!,(.!.(5.34+-5.!0%!:-v48!0(!,#-0-'348!0(!,#-%w(!(4!0(!,3!&%(8!.35.!/%#+,!S!3+4!3%2%5(!0+.2-54+5%+4;!(54'(!4-%4(.!2(.!0(.2'+)4+-5.10>!!!135.!,3!.+=+N6(!68+$%4%$"*8!,#(=);'+(52(!6-54'(!/%(!.+!7(!.%+.!,(!6F6(8!,-'./%(!6-5!2-').!.%M+4!%5(!36)%434+-58!2#(.4!/%(!7(!5(!.%+.!)'-)'(6(54!/%#%5(!D6(!Y!!!Q!R,!S!3!%5(!:'350(!0+<<;'(52(!(54'(!,#(.)'+4!(4!,(!2-').8!(5!2(!/%(!,(!2-').8!0(!.3!534%'(8!(.4!4-%7-%'.!0+&+.+M,(8!(4!/%(!,#(.)'+4!(.4!(54+N'(6(54!+50+&+.+M,(>!U3'!(5!(<<(48!,-'./%(!7(!2-5.+0N'(!6-5!(.)'+48!2#(.4`@`0+'(!6-+`6F6(!(5!4354!/%(!7(!.%+.!.(%,(6(54!%5(!2*-.(!/%+!)(5.(8!7(!5#S!)%+.!0+.4+5:%('!3%2%5(.!)3'4+(.8!63+.!7(!6(!2-5c-+.!2-66(!%5(!2*-.(!.(%,(!(4!(54+N'(>!E4!/%-+/%(!4-%4!,#(.)'+4!.(6M,(!F4'(!%5+!@! 4-%4!,(!2-').8!4- %4(<-+.!%5!)+(0 8!-%!%5!M'3 .8!-%!/%(,/%#3%4'(!)3'4+(!;4354!.;)3';(!0(!6-5!2-').8!+,!(.4!2('43+5!/%(!)-%'!2(,3!+,!5#S!3%'3!'+(5!0(!'(4'352*;!@!6-5!(.)'+4!W!O6'+(ND8!IV!Rr8!dfP>!!!R2+8!1'!2-').!(.4!.(%,(6(54!%5(!0;5-6+534+-5!(=4;'+(%'(>!B-5!2-').!'(2(&354!.-5!%5+4;!,-'./%(!7(!2-5.+0N'(!5-5!.(%,(6(54!/%(!7#3+!%5!2-').8!63+.!3%..+!/%(!7(!.%+.!%5!2-').>!!I,-'.!,(!0%3,+.6(!(.4`+,!,#3<<+'634+-5!0(!,3!.;)3'3M+,+4;!0%!2-').!(4!0(!,#D6(!-%!M+(5!.(%,(6(54!2(,,(!0(!,3!)-..+M+,+4;!0(!,(%'!.;)3'34+-5!a!E4!5-%.!0(&-5.!(=36+5('!2(!/%(!1(.23'4(.!3<<+'6(!.35.!4(5+'!2-6)4(!0(!5-4'(!)-+54!0(!&%(!0#*-66(!&+&354!3%!rrR(!.+N2,(11>!!1(!<3+48 !:;5;'3,(6(548!,3!)(5. ;(!0(.!)*+,-.-)*( .!(.4!(5!322-'0!3&(2!%5!(5&+'-55(6(54!*+.4-'+/%(! Y!)3'!(=(6),(!,(.!4'30+4+-5 .8!,(.!2-%4% 6(.8!,(!2-54(=4(!.2+(54+<+/%(8!2%,4%'(,8!(42>!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!H\!J(O'P!42%1'8!-24-M'(!Hdl^8!IV!Ro8!][d>!"(.!.(54+6(54.!0(!0-%,(%'8!0(!<3+68!(4!0(!.-+!!HH!j%350!-5!2-5.+0N '(!0(.!)* +,-.-)*+(.!-%!0(.!)*+,-.-)*(. !0%!)3. .;8!-5 !3!M(.-+5 !0(!2-6) '(50'(!2,3+'(6(54!,(%'.!344+4%0(.!(4!,(%'.!2-6)-'4(6(54.>!j%350!-5!;4%0+(!,3!)*+,-.-)*+(!0(!1(.23'4(.8!+,!(5!&3!0(!6F6( !Y!+,!2-5& +(54!0(!.(!0(6350('!0(!/%(,.!)-+54.!0(!&%( !(4!035.!/%(,.!M%4.!(.4! (54'()'+.(!.3!)*+,-.-)*+(!a!"(!M%4!0(!63!4*N.(!(.4!0(!<3+'(!,3!0+.4+524+-5!(54'(!,3!)(5.;(!0(!1(.23'4(.!(4!,3!2-5.4'%24+-5!0(!.3!0-24'+5(8!035.!,3!6(.%'(!-9!,(!.S.4N6(!0%!)*+,-.-)*(!(4!.3!)(5.;(!5(!2-''(.)-50(54!)3.!4-%7-%'.!.+6%,435;6(54>!"( .!:'350.!)* +,-.-)*(.!-'+:+53%=!. -54!)3'4+2%,+N'(6(54!2,3+'&-S354.8!(4 !+,!(= +.4(!.-%.!,#(=)-.+4+-5!0%!.S.4N6(!)*+,-.-)*+/%(!%5(!2-5.4'%24+-5!0(!,3!)(5.;(!/%+!5#(.4!)3.!0+'(24(6(54!&+.+M,(>!!!
!!q!BF6(!,-'./%#(,,(!'-6)4!3&(2!%5(!4'30+4+-58!,3!)*+,-.-)*+(!4'-%&(!.(.!<-50(6(54.!035.!.-5!'3))-'4!3%!2-54(=4(!035.!,(/%(,!(,,(!.(!2-5.4'%+4>!"b+54(')';434+-5!0(!,3!)(5.;(!0(!1(.23'4(.!0(6350(!0-52!@!2-553x4'(!.-5!(5&+'-55(6(54!M+-:'3)*+/%(!(4!2%,4%'(,!a!E5!0#3%4' (.!4('6(.8!+,!(.4!+6)-'4354 !0b(=36+5('!,(!2-54(=4( !*+.4-'+/%(!035.!,(/%(,! 1(.23'4(.!';<,;2*+4>!B3+.8!,3!)(5.;(!0(!1(.23'4(.!5(!.(!';0%+4!)3.!@!2(!2-54(=4(!C!+,!5-%.!<3%4!;,%2+0('!,(!2-54( 5%!0#%5(!)*+,-.-)*+(! (4!0#%5(!(=);'+(52(! /%+!,%+! (.4!)'-)'(>!"b(5&+'-55(6(54!)'+.!(5!2(!.(5.!5b(.4!)3.!2(,%+!0(!,b+0;-,-:+(!(%'-);(55(!-'0+53+'(!-%!0(!,3!.)* N'(!2%,4%'(,,(>!U(4!(5&+'-55(6(54!035.!,(/%(,! .(!2-5.4'%+4!,3!)(5.;(!0(!1(.23'4(.!5(!.(!';0%+4!)3.!@!%5!(5.(6M,(!0(!)-+54.!2-66%5.!2-5<+'6;.!)-.+4+&(6(548!63+.!+,!(.4!),%4G4!2(!@!)3'4+'!0(!/%-+!(4!2-54'(!/%-+!(,,(!.(!0;&(,-))(>!J(!.-%*3+4(!0-52!34432*('!M(3%2-%)!0b344(54+-5!@!,b3''+N'(`),35!0(!,3!)(5.;(!23'4;.+(55(8!(4!2(,3!0(!0(%=!)-+54.!0(!&%(!Y!*+.4-'+/%(!(4!6;43)*S.+/%(>!U(,3!.+:5+<+(!/%(!7(!0-+.!)'(50'(!(5!2-6)4(!,(!2-54(=4(!)('.-55(,!(4!*+.4-'+/%(!035.!,(/%(,!)(5.(!1(.23'4(.8!63+.!(5!6F6(!4(6).!(=36+5('!2-66(54!,(!)*+,-.-)*(!+54(')'N4(!)('.-55(,,(6(54!2(!2-54(=4(>!A5!)-%''3!3,-'.!<-%'5+'!@!,3!68+$%4%$"*!)*+,-.-)*+/%(!,(!)-+54!0b3))%+!/%+!(.4!,(!.+(58!63+.!3%..+!;4%0+('!,3!<3 c-5!0(!6;0+4('!0(!1(.23'4(.!(4!2(!/%#+,!.3+.+4!3&(2!,%2+0+4;!0(!2(!)-+54! 0b3))%+>!I+5.+8!,(!M%4!0(!63!4*N.(!(.4!0(!2-6)'(50'(!2,3+'(6(54!,3!<3c-5!0-54!1(.23'4(.!)(5.(!,3!' (,34+-5!(54'(!,bD6(!(4!,(!2-').>!U(44(!/%(.4+-5!(.4! 3%!2$%'!0%!.S.4N6(!)*+,-.-)*+/%(!0(!1(.23'4(.>!B3+.!)-.;(!0#3M-'0!.%'!,(!),35!6;43)*S.+/%(8!+,!)3'&+(54!(5!<+5!0(!2-6)4(!@!2-52,%'(!/%b+,!.b3:+4!0b%5(!/%(.4+-5!0b%5!3%4'(!-'0'(8!+5&-/%354!,(!),35!)'34+/%(>!"3!/%(.4+-5!(.4!3,-'.!0(!.3&-+'!.+!,3!'(,34+-5!D6(`2-').!'(,N&(!0b%5(!0+6(5.+-5!4*;-'+/%(!-%!0b%5(!0+6(5.+-5!)'34+/%(>!A'!1(.23'4(.!(=),+/%(!,3!0+.4+524+-5!';(,,(!(54'(!,#D6(!(4!,(!2-').!0%!)-+54!0(!&%(!0(.!.2+(52(.!0(!,3!534%'(>!U(,,(`2+!(.4!%5!230'(!(..(54+(,!(4!<-5036(543,!@!,#+54;'+(%'!0%/%(,!)(5.(!1(.23'4(.>!U()(50354!2(!5b(.4!)3.!<32+,( >!i;5;'3, (6(548!,(.!-%&'3:( !0#*+.4-+'(!0(!,3!)*+,-.-)*+(!5b+50+/%(54!/%(!,(.!';.%,434.!0(!,#324+&+4;!)*+,-.-)*+/%(!;4%0+;(!C!3+5.+!,(.!6-4+&34+-5.!0%!)*+,-.-)*(!(4!,(.!)'-2(..%.!0(!2-5.4'%24+-5!0(!,3!68+$%4%$"*!.-54!-%M,+;.!(4!0+..+6%,;.8!-%!.-54!-6+.!+54(54+-55(,,(6(54>!Ub(.4!)-%'/%-+!7(!2*('2*(!0(!,3!634+N'(!035.!,3!2-''(.)-50352(!(4!,#$%&'(!)-.4*%6(!<'3:6(543+'(>!V-%4!2-6)4(!<3+48!7(!)(5.(!/%(!5-%.!0(&-5.! <3+'(!';3))3'3x4'( !,3!)(5. ;(!0%!)*+,-.-)*(!( 5!2-5<'-54354!5-4'(!)(5.;(!@!,3!.+(55(>!R,!<3%4!<+53,(6(54!4(54('!0(!)*+,-.-)*('!@!.3!),32(8!-%!),%4G4!3&(2!,%+>!1b%5(!635+N'(!2-52' N4(8!5-%.!3&-5.!M(.- +5!0(!6;0+4('!(4!0(!)*+,-.-)*( '!
!!f!)('.-55(,,(6(54!.%'!,(!)'-M,N6(!)*+,-.-)*+/%(!/%(!5-%.!;4 %0+-5.!2*(y!4 (,!-%!4(, !)*+,-.-)*(8!4-%4!(5!4(5354!2-6)4(!0(!,3!4'30+4+-58!0%!2-%'354!0b+0;(.!/%b%5!)*+,-.-)*(!3!'(c%!-%!M+(5!0%!';.%,434!0(!,b(=);'+(52(!/%b+,!3!'(c%8!(4!0(!,3!<3c-5!0-54!-5!0-+4!4'3+4('!2(44(!/%(.4+-5>!I%!'(:3'0!0(!2(.!';<,(=+-5.8!5-%.!.-%*3+4-5.8!035.!,(!)'(6+('!2*3)+4'(!;4%0+('!,3!2-5.4'%24+-5!0(!,3!/%(.4+-5!0(!,3!'(,34+-5!(54'(!,#D6(!(4!,(!2-').!035.!,(.!68+$%4%$"*2!)-%'!6(44'(!(5!, %6+N'(!,(!)'-M,N6(! /%#(,,(!. -%,N&(>!"(!.(2-50! 2*3)+4'(!;4 %0+(!), %.!0+'(24(6(54!,3!'(,34+-5!0(!,#D6(!(4!0%!2-').!4(,,(!/%#(,,(!(.4!0;&(,-));(!)3'!1(.23'4(.!035.!,3!.+=+N6(!68+$%4%$"*!(4!(=36+5(!,(.!+54(')';434+-5.!0(.!2-66(5434(%'.!2,3..+/%(.8!I,/%+;8!i%('-%,4!(4!i+,.-5!@!)'-)-.!0(!2(44(!/%(.4+-5>!!135.!,(!2*3)+4'(!RRR8!7(!)';2+.('3+!,(!)-+54!(..(54+(,!0(!,3!/%(.4+-58!4(,!/%#+,!.(!)';.(54(!035.!,(.(68+$%4%$"*2((4!,(.(G-F'!%$"*2('%(K8/"*2'2!3&(2!I'53%,08!i3..(50+!(4!2(,%+!/%+!0-6+5(!035.!,3!2-''(.)-50352(!3&(2!,#zS)('3.)+.4(.>!E4!7(!&-%0'3+.!.%::;'('!,3!2,(!B3+.!2-66(!,3!)'(%&(!0(!,b(=+.4(52(!0%!6-50(!(=4;'+(%'!5b3!0b3%4'(!<+5!/%(!0b;43M,+'!,3!0+.4+524+-5!';(,,(!0(!,bD6(!(4!0%!2-').8!+,!<3%4!3,,('!7%./%b@!0+'(!/%(!,3!)'(%&(!0(!,(%'!0+.4+524+-5!.b3))%+(!.%'!,(!<3+4!0(!,(%'!%5+-5!W128!3+5.+!/%(!,#;2'+4!i+,.-5>!!I%!2*3)+4'(!Ro8!7#353,S.('3+!,3!2-''(.)-50352(!0(!1(.23'4 (.!3&(2!E,+.3M(4* !(4!6-54'('3+!.-5!'G,( !035.!,(!0;&(,- ))(6(54!0(!,3 !/%(.4+-5!0(!,# %5+-58!(4!,3!)'+ .(!(5!2-6)4(!0(!.3!0+6(5.+-5!)'34+/%(8!0-52!3%..+!2(,,(!0%!'G,(!0(!,#+63:+534+-5!(4!0(.!.(5.!035.!.-5!3))';*(5.+-5>!U#(.4!)-%'/%-+8!035.!,(!2*3)+4'(!o8!7#;4%0+('3+!,#-))-.+4+-5!(54'(!,3!'()';.(5434+-5!0(!z-MM(.!(4!2(,,(!0(!1(.23'4(.!@!)'-)-.!0(!,3!'(,34+-5!(54'(!,(.!+0;(.!(4!,(.!-M7(4.!.(5.+M,(.8!(4!7#(..3+('3+!0#+0(54+<+('!,3!0+<<;'(52(!<-5036(543,(!(54'(!,(%'.!0-24'+5(.>!"(!2*3)+4 '(!oR! )-'4('3!.%'!,3!'(,3 4+-5! (54'(!,3!2-52()4+-5!6;0+23,(!0(!1(.23'4(.!(4!,3!4*N.(!0(!,#%5+-5!0(!,#D6(!(4!0%!2-').8!(4!7(!6(44'3+!,#322(54!.%'!,3!),32(!(4!,(!'G,(!0(!,3!0-%,(%'!035.!.3!'(,34+-5!@!,#%5+-5>!"3!/%(.4+-5!0(!,3!2-6)34+M+,+4;!0(!,3!4*N.(!0(!,3 !0+.4+524+-5!(4!0(!2(,, (!0(!,#%5+-5!(.4! 0-52!4'35.)-'4;(! .%'!, (!),35!)'34+/% (8!(4! 7#;4%0+('3+!)3'!2-5.;/%(54!3%!2*3)+4'(!oRR!,(.!'G,(.!0%!0;.+'!(4!0(!,3!:;5;'-.+4;!2-66(!'(6N0(!3% =!)3..+-5.>!I%!4('6( !0(!2(44(!;4%0 (8!7(!2*( '2*('3+!@!6-54'('! /%(!,3!)*+,-.-)*+(!0(!1(.23'4(.!)-..N0(!%5(!.+:5+<+234+-5!@!,3!<-+.!6;43)*S.+/%(!(4!6-'3,(>!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!H[!U<>!i+,.-58!H%7+'2(270(1'(0Q1'(+'(14(/'*28'()8+$8I41'(+4*2(14(>"0)4%$"*(+7(2.2%A)'(!40%82$'*8!?3'+.!Y!o'+58!Hmq^8!)>![l^>!
!!!!!!!"#$%&'()!&!!LASTRUCTUREDELASIXIÈMEMÉDITATIONETLARELATIONDEL'ÂMEETDUCORPS I.LaquestiondelasixièmeMéditation"*++,!-./-012! 3415!67189!47!58:1;81:,!/,5!Méditations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éditationC!! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!M!AElisabeth9!NP!Q1-.!MORS9!$'!&&&9!OTSC!N!CfC!$'!&U9!ORC!
!!MV!I-1.LelieudesdifficultésdanslasixièmeMéditationD,5!Méditations!5*.8!;*.58-812,5!/,!5-E!Méditation52;:-8,59!6*:+-5!4,!Q*1:!/1! W7>>789!;*++,!1.!,.8:7-.,+,.8!/,!4=,53:-89!2@*017.8!4,5!Méditation5!;6:28-,..,5!X01,!4=*.!3,18!7155-!:733:*;6,:!/=1.,!3:78-01,!75;28-01,!>*1//6-58,9!@-57.8!Y!788,-./:,!4,!Z-:@7.7[C!'*18!/=7>*:/9!<,5;7:8,5!/2@,4*33,!1.,!:2J4,E-*.!/,!4=,53:-89!,.!2;:-@7.8!1.,!Méditation!37:!Q*1:9!/*.8!4,!>18!,58!Y!47!J*-5!/=7>*18-:!Y!1.,!;*.;415-*.!,8!/,!;*.58-81,:!1.!,E,:;-;,!53-:-81,4C!<,5;7:8,5!2;:-8!71!/2>18!/,!47!3:,+-?:,!Méditation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`!XMedI9!$'!&U9!MS[3C!!",88,!3:78-01,!/1!/*18,!5F582+78-01,!3,:+,887.8!/,!5,!/2>7::755,:!/,!8*18,5!4,5!-/2,5!:,^1,5!57 .5!1.!,E 7+,.!;:-8- 01,!,8!J*./78,1:! 3:2747>4,!/,@-,.8!1.!+*/?4,!/A733:,.8-557a,C!<,5;7:8,5!4,!:733,44,:7!/7.5!4,5!Secondesréponses!,.!-./-017.8!01,9!/7.5!4,5!Méditations,!-4!7!51-@-!47!@*-,!7.74F8-01,!\!!]!DA7.74F5,!+*.8:,!47!@:7-,!@*-, !37:!4701,44,!1., !;6*5,!7! 282!+286*/-01,+,.8!-.@,.82,9!,8!J7-8!@* -:!;*++,.8 !4,5!,JJ,85!/23 ,./,.8!/,5!;715,5!_!,.! 5*:8,!01,9! 5-!4,! 4,;8,1:!47!@,18 !51-@:,9!,8 !Q,8 ,:!4,5!F,1E!5*-a.,15,+,.8!51:!8*18!;,!01A,44,!;*.8- ,.89!-4!.A, .8,./:7!375!+*-. 5!37:J7-8,+,.8!47!;6*5,!7-.5-!/2+*.8:2,9!,8!.,!47!:,./:7!375!+*-.5!7551:2,!01,!5-!41 -G+L+,!4A7@7- 8!-.@,.82,C!bcd!Pour moi, j 'ai suivi seulement la voie analytique dans mes Méditations, parce qu'elle me semble être la plus vraie, et la plus propre pour enseigner!`!X$'!&U9!MRe[C!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!S!).!D78-.9!$'!f&&9!MeGMPC!
!!MM!!",8!*1@:7a,!;*+3*:8,!5-E!86?+,5C!!!<7.5!47!3:,+-?:,!Méditation9!DeibisquaeindubiumrevocaripossuntX<,5!;6*5,5!01,!4=*.!3,18!:2@*01,:!,.!/*18,[!<7.5!47!5, ;*./,!Méditation9!Denatu ramentishumanae:quod ipsasitnotior quamcorpus!X<,!47!.781:,!/,!4=,53:-8!61+7-.!_!,8!01=-4!,58!3415!7-52!Y!;*..7g8:,!01,!4,!;*:35[!!<7.5!47!8:*-5-?+,!Méditation9!DeDeo,quodexistat!X<,!<-,1!_!01=-4!,E-58,[!!<7.5!47!0178:-?+,!Méditation9!Devero$falso!X<1!@:7-!,8!/1!J71E![!!<7.5!47!;-.01-?+,!Méditation9!Deessentiarerummaterialium;$iterumdeDeo,quodexistat!X<,!4=,55,.;,!/,5!;6*5,5!+782:-,44,5!_!,89!/,:,;6,J!/,!<-,19!01=-4!,E-58,[!!<7.5!47!5-E-?+,!Méditation9!Dererummaterialiumexistentia,$realimentisacorporedistinctione!X<,!4=,E-5 8,.;,!/,5!;6*5,5!+782:-,44,59!,8!/,!47 !:2,44,!/-58-.;8-*.!,.8:,!4=B+,!,8!4,!;*:35!/,!4=6*++,[!!!Z*15!3*1@*.5!/-:,!01,!47!;7:7;82:-58-01,!/,5!Méditations,58!/,!/2@,4*33,:1.,!:2J4,E-*.!/,!4A,53:-85*15!47!J*:+,!/=1.!/-74*a1,!-.82:-,1:C!h7-5!47!01,58-*.!,55,.8-,44,!,58!/,!;*+3:,./:,!4,!>18!01,!3*1:51-8!<,5;7:8,5!,.!2;:-@7.8!4,5!MéditationsCDA7:a1+,.878-*.!/2@,4*332, !37:!<,5;7:8,5!/7.5!47!5-E-?+,!Méditation!,58!5-.1,15,!_!47!3:,+-?:,!+*-8-2!/,!47!Méditation!3*:8,!51:!47!/-58-.;8-*.!/,!4=B+,!,8!/1!;*:35C!D7!/ ,:.-?:,!+* -8-2!;*.;,:.,!4,1:!1.-*.C!$337:,++,.8!-4!5,+>4,!01,!47! ;*.;,38-*.!/,!;,88,!1.-*.!7!282!5*1/7-.,+,.8!-.8:*/1-8,!37:!<,5;7:8,5!/7.5!47!/,:.-?:,!+*-8-2!/,!47!5-E-?+,!MéditationC!I:!;,5!/,1E!86?5,5!5,!3:25,.8,.8!;*++,!;*.8:7/-;8*-:,5C!i1,4!,58!-;-!4,!>18!/,!<,5;7:8,5!H!!).!/A718: ,5!8,:+,59!4A-.8,:3:2878-*. !/,!47!86?5,!/2@,4*332,!/7.5 !47!5-E-?+,!Méditation!:23*./!Y!1.,!/*1>4,!58:782a-,!J*:+142,!/7.5LeTraitédel'HommeRC!!L'Homme!,18!/,1E!2/-8-*.59!8*18,5!/,1E!3*5861+,5C!&4!J18!31>4-2!3*1:!47!3:,+-?:,!J*-5!,.!MOON9! Y!D,F/,9! 37:! j4*:,.8!W;61F4 !XMOMTGMOOT[k9!/*;8,1:! ,.!36-4*5*36-,!/Al8:,;68!XMOST[!,8!/*;8,1:!,.!+2/,;-.,!/,!D,F/,!XMOOR[!01-!8:7/1-5-8!,.!478-.!1.,!;*3-,!/1!8,E8,!J:7.^7-5!/,!<,5;7:8,5!5*15!4,!8-8:,!\!DeHominefigurisetlatinitatedonatusC!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!R!]!<,5;7:8,5!.,!31>4-,!375!;,8! *1@:7a,9 !;*++,!-4!5=,.!,E34-0 1,!71!/2>18!/,!4 7!"-.01-?+,!37:8 -,!/1!DiscoursdelaMéthode`C!j:2/2:-;!/,!m1n*.9!<,.-5!o7+>*1;6.,:9!D,!;*.;,38!/,!47!36F5-01,9LecturesdeDescartes,%7:-5!\!)44-35,59!NVMk9!3C!MPOC!k!).!MO OR9!j4*:,.8!W;61F4!/,@-.8!3:*J,55,1:!Y! 4A&.58-818!+2/-;74!/,!D,F/,9!,89! ,.!MOOO9!3 :*J,55,1:!/,!>*87.-01,C!&4!,.5,-a.7!47!+2/,;-.,!,8!47!>*87.-01,!Q1501AY!57!+*:8C!
!!MN!<,1E!7.5!341 5!87:/9!"471/,! "4,:5,4-,:!XMOMRGMOPR[9!7@*;78!71!%7: 4,+,.8!/,!%7:-5!,8!36-4*5*36,!;7:825-,.9!31>4-7!4,!8,E8,!J:7.^7-5!3:2;2/2!/A1.,!-+3*:87.8,!3:2J7;,!,8!51-@-!/,!47!8:7/1;8-*.!/,!47!3:2J7;,!478-.,!/,!jC!W;61F4C!<7.5!57!3:2J7;,9!"4,:5,4-,:!7/:,55,!01,401,5!;:-8-01,5!,8!:,3:*;6,59!3415!*1!+*-.5!+*/2:259!Y!jC!W;61F4C!",!/,:.-,:9!/-8G-49!7!18-4-52!1.,!;*3-,!3,1!J-/?4,!/1!8,E8,!/,!<,5;7:8,5!3*1:!:274-5,:!57!@,:5-*.OC!
!!MS!37:!47!4,88:,!qC9!;,44,5!/,!hC!/,!D7!j*:a,!X+*-.5!.*+>:,15,5[!37:!47!4,88:,!jCPC!<,1E!J-a1:,5!5,14,+,.89!57.5!4,88:,9!5*.8!/,!<,5;7:8,5C!%*1:!4,5!+15;4,59!-4!7@7-8!a:-JJ*..2!1.,!J-a1:,C!D7!J- .!/,!47!3:2J7;, !,58!36-4*5 *36- 01,!,8!5,!:733*:8,!71E!/, 1E!51>587.;,59!;*:3*:,44,!3*1:!4,!+*1@,+,.8!,8!53-:-81,44,!3*1:!4,!@*14*-:C!i17.8!Y!47!3:2J7;,!/,!W;61F49!,44,!,58!,55,.8-,44,+,.8!36-4*5*36-01,9!>752,!51:!47!/-JJ2:,.;,!,.8:,!4AB+,!,8!4,!;*:359!51:!47!5- a.-J-;78-*.!/,!4AB+,!/,5! mL8,59!5,4*. !<,5;7:8,5!01-!7!:,Q ,82!4,5!-/2,5!J71 55,5!,.!:2J*:+7.8!4,5!3:,+-,:5!J*./,+,.85!/,!47!36-4*5*36-,C!]!&4!7!+*.8:29!/-8G-49!01,44,5!5*.8!4,5!J*.;8-*.5!/,!4A,.8,./,+,.8!,8!/,!47!@*4*.82!,8!,.!01*-!;*.5-58,!47!3,:J,;8-*.!/,!4A1.!,8!/,!4A718:,C!&4!7!.,88,+,.8!/-58-.a12!4,5!-/2,5!*1!4,5!.*8-*.5!01-!5*.8!.2,5!7@,;!.*159!,8!01-!5*.8!3:*/1-8,5!37:!4A,53:-8!5,149!/,!;,44,5!01-!5*.8!28:7.a?:,5!*1!01-!@-,..,.8!/1!/,6*:5!_!,8!4,5!1.,5!,8!4,5!718:,59!/,!;,44,5!01-!.,!5*.8!J7-8,5!,8!-.@,.82,5!01,!37:!.*8:,!J7.87-5-,!`C!D,5!.*8 -*.5!/,!36F5-*4*a-,!;*.^1,5!3 7:!<,5;7 :8,5!,.8:,:*.8!/7.5!4,!/* +7-.,!,E32:-+,.874!5,14,+,.8!7 1!U&U,!5-?;4,!*1!71!UU,C!DA,E34-;78-*.! /,5!J*.;8-*.5!/,5!SPO!*:a7.,5!.,!5,:7!3415!5,14,+,.8!+2;7.-01,9!,44,!51-@:7!4,5!3:*a:?5!/,!47!36F5-01,!,8!5,:7!8:->187-:,!/,!47!.7-557.;,!/,!47!;6-+-,!,8!/,!5,5!3:*a:?5C!W,4*.!5*.!347.9!-4!,58!8,+359!+7-.8,.7.89!01,!<,5;7:8,5!/2;:-@,!4AB+,!Y!37:89!,8!,.J-.!01A-4!+*.8:,!;*++,.8!]!;,5!/,1E!.781:,5!`!/*-@,.8 !L8:,!Q*-.8,5!,8!1.-,5!3*1:!; *+3*5,:!/, 5!6*++,5!01-!.*15!:,55,+>4,.8!`TC!! Généralement, les lecteurs de Descartes interprètent sa pensée de la manière suivante!\! $[!D7!+2873 6F5-01,!/,!<,5;7:8,5!-+34-01,!47!:,;*..7-557. ;,!/=1.,! distinctiorealis9!Y!57@*-:!47!/-58-.;8-*.!,.8:,!rescogitans!,8!resextensaC!!m[!i17./!.*15!;*.5-/2:*.5!,.51-8,!4A1.-*.!/,!4=B+,!,8!/1!;*:359!.*15!/,@*.5!7@*1,:!01,!4,1:!/-58-.;8-*.!2;6*1,!J7;,!Y!4A,E32:-,.;,!/,!@-,!01*8-/-,..,C!!I.!;*+3:,./!37:!4Y!01,!47!/-JJ-;1482!,55,.8-,44,!01,!:,.;*.8:,!47!+28736F5-01,!;7:825-,..,!,589!;*++,!*.!4=7!-./-0129!;,!01,!4,5!;*a.-8-@-58,5!;*.8,+3*:7-.5!733,44,.8!4,!mind-bodyproblemC!!!",88,!748,:.78-@,!,.8:,!X$[!,8!Xm[!,58!/28,:+-.7.8,!3*1:!47!;*+3:26,.5-*.!/,!47!5-E-?+,!Méditation.X$[!,8!Xm[!5*.8!a2.2:74,+,.8!7;;,3825!37:!4,5!4,;8,1:5!,8!-.8,:3:?8,5!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!P!"4,:5,4-,:!;*.5-/?:,!;,5!J-a1:,5!3415!3:*3:,5!Y!4A-.8,44-a,.;,!/1!8,E8,!01,!;,44,5!/,!W;61F4C!T!&4!37:8! /A1.!;*:35G+7;6-.,!/,!8,::,9!31-5 !5A,E3:- +,!,.!;,5!8,:+,5!\!]!i1 7./!<-,1!1.-:7 !1.,!B+,!:7-5*..7>4,!Y!;,!;*:35CCC!`9!Del'homme,$'!U&9!MRSC!
!!MR!/,!47!3,.52,!/,!<,5;7:8,59!+L+,!5=-45!7/+,88,.8!J-.74,+,.8!3*1:!47!34137:8!01,!X$[!,58!57!@2:-87>4,!86?5,C!)8!/,!J7-89!;,88,!-.8,:3:2878-*.!5,+>4,!5=-+3*5,:9!;7:!,44,!,58!;*.J-:+2,!37:!/=718:,5!8,E8,5!/,!<,5;7:8,5C!$-.5-9!2;:-8G-4!/7.5!57!4,88:,!Y!)4-57>,86!/1!NM!+7-!MORS!\!!!!]!c!F! 7F7.8! /,1E!;6*5,5!,.!4= B+,!61+7- .,9!/,501,44,5!/23,./!8*18,!47!;*..7-557.;,!01,!.*15 !3*1@*.5! 7@*-:!/,!5 7!.781:,9!4=1.,!/,50 1,44,5!,58!01=,44,!3,.5,9!4=718:,9!01=287.8!1.-,!71!;*:359!,44,!3,18!7a-:!,8!3B8-:!7@,;!41-!_!Q,!.=7-!0175-!:-,.!/-8!/,!;,88,!/,:.-?:,9!,8!+,!51-5!5,14,+,.8!281/-2!Y!J7-:,!>-,.!,.8,./:,!47!3:,+-?:,9!Y!;715,!01,!+*.!3:-.;-374!/,55-.!287-8!/,!3:*1@,:!47!/-58-.;8-*.!01-!,58!,.8:,!4=B+,!,8!4,!;*:35!`9!XAElisabeth9!NM!+7-!MORS9!$'!&&&9!OORGOOk[C!!!!!D7!86?5,!X$[!5=7;;*:/,!7@,;!4,!8-8:,!/,!47!5-E-?+,!Méditation.&4!5=7a-8!>-,.!/=1.,!/-58-.;8-*.!:2,44,!,.8:,!4=B+,!,8!4,!;*:35!01-!,58!4,!>18!3*1:51-@-!-;-!37:!<,5;7:8,59!,8!.*15!3*1@*.5!7155-!;*+3:,./:,!01,!;,88,!/-58-.;8-*.!:2,44,!,58!4,!51Q,8!3:-.;-374!@-52!37:!<,5;7:8,59!;7:!4,!8,E8,!/,!<,5;7:8,5!3*:8,!>-,.!51:!47!/-58-.;8-*.!,8!.*.!51:!4A1.-*.C!!).!:,@7.;6,9!-4!J718!7/+,88:,!01,!4A-.8,:3:2878-*.!Xm[!,58!8*18!7155-!;*.@,.7>4,C!)8!,44,!-+3*5,!74*:5!/=7;;,38,:!1.,!/-58-.;8-*.!:2,44,!,.8:,!4=B+,!,8!4,!;*:35!,8!,.!+L+,!8,+35!4A1.-*.!/,5!/,1EC!%*1:01*- !H!%7: ;,!01,!4A-.8,:3:2878-*.! Xm[!,58!;*.J*:+,! 71E!36:75,5!51-@7.8,5!/,!47!;*::,53*./7.;,!/,!<,5;7:8,5!7@,;!)4-57>,86!\!!]!c!4, 5!;6*5,5!01 -!7337:8-,..,.8!Y!4=1 .-*.!/,!4=B +,!,8!/1!;*:359!.,!5,!;*..7-55,.8!01=*>5;1:2+,.8!37:!4=,. 8,./,+,.8!5, 149!.-!+L+,!37:!4=,.8,./,+,.8!7-/2!/,!4 =-+7a-.78-*.!_!+7 -5!,44,5! 5,!;*..7-55,.8!8:?5!;47-:,+,.8!37:!4,5!5,.5C!<=*r!@-,.8!01,!;,1E!01-!.,!36-4*5*36,.8!Q7+7-59!,8!01-!.,!5,!5,:@,.8!01,!/,!4,1:!5,.59!.,!/*18,.8!3*-.8!01,!4=B+,!.,!+,1@,!4,!;*:359!,8!01,!4,!;*:35!.=7a-55,!51:!4=B+,!_!+7-5!-45!;*.5-/?:,.8!4=1.!,8!4=718:,!;*++,!1.,!5,14,!;6*5,9!;=,58GYG/-:,9!-45!;*.^*-@,.8!4,1:!1.-*.!_!;7:!;*.;,@*-:!4=1.-*.!01-!,58!,.8:,!/,1E!;6*5,59!;=,58!4,5!;*.;,@*-:!;*++,!1.,!5,14,C!)8!4,5!3,.52,5!+28736F5-01,59!01-!,E,:;,.8!4=,.8,./,+,.8! 31:9!5,:@,.8!Y!.*15 !:,./:,!47!.*8-*.!/,!4=B+,!J7+-4-?:,!_!,8!4=281/,!/,5!+7862+78-01,59!01-!,E,:;,!3:-.;-374,+,.8!4=-+7a-.78-*.!,.!47!;*.5-/2: 78-*.!/,5!J-a1:,5!,8!/,5!
!!Mk!+*1@,+,.859!.*15!7;;*181+,!Y!J*:+,:!/,5!.*8-*.5!/1!;*:35!>-,.!/-58-.;8,5!_!,8!,.J-.9!;=,58!,.!157.8!5,14,+,.8!/,!47!@-,!,8!/,5!;*.@,:578-*.5!*:/-.7-:,59!,8!,.!5=7>58,.7.8!/,!+2/-8,:!,8!/=281/-,:!71E!;6*5,5!01-!,E,:;,.8!4=-+7a-.78-*.9!01=*.!733:,./!Y!;*.;,@*-:!4=1.-*.!/,!4=B+,!,8!/1!;*:35!`!XAElisabeth9!NP!Q1-.!MORS9!$'!&&&9!OTMGOTN[C!!!DA-.8,:3:2878-*.!Xm[!7!4,!+2 :-8,!/,! :,;*..7-8:,!01,!47!/-58-.;8-*.!:2,44,!,.8:,!4=B+,!,8!4,!;*:35!,8!4,1:!1.-*.!5*.8!8*18,5!/,1E!4=,E3:,55-*.!/,!47!3,.52,!/,!<,5;7:8,59!,8!,44,!+*.8:,!;*++,.8!;,5!/,1E!86?5,5!5*.8!5-812,5!/7.5!5*.!5F58?+,!/,!36-4*5*36-,C!!<7.5!;,88,!-.8,:3:2878-*.!Xm[9!*.!;*.5878,!01,!<,5;7:8,5!18-4-5,!4=,E3:,55-*.!K@-,!01*8-/-,..,K3*1:!/2J-.-:!4,!;7/:,!/,!4=1.-*.!/,!4=B+,!,8!/1!;*:35C!",47!5-a.-J-,!01,!47!3,:;,38-*.!/,!4=1.-*.!.,!:,4?@,!375!/,!4=,.8,./,+,.89!+7-5!,58!1.!J7-8!/,!4A,E32:-,.;,!01*8-/-,..,C!!",3,./7.89!4,!3:*>4?+,!/,+,1:,!3*529!;7:!5-!*.!;*.5-/?:,!4A-.8,:3:2878-*.!X$[9!*.!+7.01,!47!;*+3:26,.5-*.!/,!4A1.-*.9!,8!/A1.!718:,!;p829!5-!*.!;*.5-/?:,!4=-.8,:3:2878-*.!Xm[9!*.!/*-8!5,!/,+7./,:!3*1:!01,44,!:7-5*.!-4!J718!:,./:,!;*+38,!/,!4A1.-*.!01-!,58!1.!J7-8!2@-/,.8!3*1:!.*159!71!:-501,!/,!J7-:,!5A,JJ*./:,:!47!862*:-,!/,!47!/-58-.;8-*.!:2,44,!,.8:,!4,5!/,1EC!",!5*.8!;,5!/-JJ-;14825!,8!;,5!/-JJ2:,.;,5!/=-.8,:3:2878-*.5!01-!:,./,.8!3:*>42+78-01,!47!;*+3:26,.5-*.!/,!47!36-4*5*36-,!/,!<,5;7:8,5C!$@7.8!/=7.74F5,:!4,5!-.8,:3:2878-*.5!X$[!,8!Xm[9!*.!:,a7:/,:7!47!58:1;81:,!/,!47!O,!Méditation!7J-.!/A,E7+-.,:! 47!3*5-8-*.!7/*382,!37:!<,5;7:8,5!/ 7.5!;,44,G;-.D,5!Méditations5*.831>4-2,5!Y!%7:-5!,.!MORM9!+7-5!<,5;7:8,5!;*::-a,!41-G+L+,!4,5!;*01-44,5!/,!47!3:,+-?: ,!2/-8-*.C!D7!/,1E-? +,!2/-8-*.!,58!31>4-2,!Y !$+58,:/7+!,.!MORNC!q2.2:74,+,.89!>-,.!01=-4!5*-8!/=157a,!/A18-4-5,:!4=2/-8-*.!31>4-2,!37:!"67:4,5!$/7+!,8!%714!'7..,:F!X$'[9!hC!s7+7/7!:733,44,!01=]!-4!.AF!7!375!>,71;*13!/,!/-JJ2:,.;,5!01-!+*/-J-,.8!:7/-;74,+,.8!4A-.8,:3:2878-*.!,.8:,!47!/,1E-?+,!2/-8-*.!,8!4=2/-8-*.!$'9!+7-5!/,5!/-JJ2:,.;,5!/,!.17.;,!5*.8!2@-/,.8,5C!I.!,58!,.;4-.!Y!7;;*:/,:!3415!/=-+3*:87.;,!Y!47!/,1E-?+,!2/-8-*.!`MVC!%*1:01*-!74*:5!4=2/-8-*.!$'!,58G,44,!18-4-52,!37:!4,5!;6,:;6,1:5!H!&4!.AF!7!375!/, !37:7 a:736,5!/7.5 !47!/,1E- ?+,!2/-8-*.!_!,.!:,@7.;6,9! 4,5!:2/7;8,1:5!/,!4=2/-8-*.!$'!*.8!-.8:*/1-8!/,5!37:7a:736,5C!D=2/-8-*.!$'!,589!/,!;,!J7-89!3415!J7;-4,!Y!4-:,!3*1:!.*15!01-!@-@*.5!/,!.*5!Q*1:59!01,!47!/,1E-?+,!2/-8-*.C!'*18,J*-59!/7.5!47!/,1E-?+,!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!MV!#-:*7t-!s7+7/79!DesMéditations9!'utFu!\!"6-t1+7!W6*>*9!NVMM9!3C!PC!
!!MO!2/-8-*.9!47!3:25,. 878-*.!/1!8,E8,!.=,58!375!6*+*a?.,C!'* 18!/=7>*: /9!-4!.AF!7!375! /,!37:7a:736,5!_!4,!8,E8,!;*.8-.1,!-./2J-.-+,.8!57.5!5237:78-*.!,.!37:7a:736,5!/-58-.;859!+7-5!/7.5!47!3:,+-?:, !,8!47!/ ,1E-?+,!2/-8-*.59!/,5!37 :7a:736,5!5*.8!8*18!Y!;*13!-.8:*/1-85!Y!37:8-:!/,!47!R,!MéditationC!!&.82:,55*.5G.*15!-;-!Y!47!/- JJ2:,.;,!/,!58:1;81:,!,.!37:7a:736,5!/7.5!47!O,!Méditation!,.8:,!4=2/-8-*.!$'!,8!47!/,1E-?+,!2/-8-*.C!!D7!O,!Méditation,58!/2;*132,!,.!NT!37:7a:736,5!/7.5!47!3:,+-?:,!2/-8-*.9!,8!,.!NM!/7.5!47!/,1E-?+,!2/-8-*.C!)8!47!8:*-5-?+,!2/-8-*.9!31>4-2,!,.!MOkV!73:?5!47!+*:8!/,!<,5;7:8,59!:,3:,./!4,5!37:7a: 736,5!/,!47!/,1E-?+,!2/-8-*.C!<*.;9!47!:237:8 -8-*.!/,5!37:7a:736,5!/,!47 !O,!Méditation/,+,1:,!-.;67.a2,!Q1501AY!47!+*:8!/,!<,5;7:8 ,5.!<25*:+7-59!Q1501AY!4A2/-8-*.!31>4-2,!,.!MOPk9!47!J7^*.!/=*:/*..,:!4,5!37:7a:736,5!/1!8,E8,!,58!+7-.8,.1,!-/,. 8-01,+,.8C!).!: ,@7.;6,9!/7.5!4=2/-8-*.! $'9!4,!8,E8,!/ ,!47!O,!Méditation!,58!/2;*132!,.!NR!37:7a:736,5C!"*.5-/2:*.5!5*.!:251+29!7J-.!/A,E7+-.,:!47!58:1;81:,!/,!47!O,!Méditation!51:!47!>75,!/,!47!/,1E-?+,!2/-8-*.C!!MC!47!3*55->-4-82!/,!4=,E-58,.;,!/,5!;6*5,5!+782:-,44,5!NC!47!/-JJ2:,.;,!,.8:,!4=-+7a-.78-*.!,8!4=-.8,44,;8-*.!*1!;*.;,38-*.!31:,!SC!4,5!;6*5,5!01,!Q=7-!;-G/,@7.8!8,.1,5!3*1:!@:7-,5!;*++,!4,5!7F7.8!:,^1,5!37:!4,5!5,.5!!RC!4,5!:7-5*.5!01-!+=*.8!*>4-a2!Y!:2@*01,:!4,5!5,.5!,.!/*18,!kC!+7-.8,.7.8!01,!Q,!;*++,.;,!Y!+,!+-,1E!;*..7-8:,!+*-G+L+,!,8!Y!/2;*1@:-:!3415!;47-:,+,.8!4=718,1:!/,!+*.!*:-a-.,!!OC!:7-5*.5!;*.J-:+7.8!4=,E-58,.;,!/,5!;6*5,5!+782:-,44,5!eC!47!3:,1@,!/,!4=,E-58,.;,!/,5!;6*5,5!+782:-,44,5!!PC!<,!47!.781:,MM9!,8!37:8-;14-?:,+,.8!+7!.781:,!\!/,5!;6*5,5!01,!< -,1!+=7!/*..2,59!;*++,!287.8!;*+3*52!/,!4=,53:-8!,8!/1!;*:35!!TC!47!3:,+-?:,!;6*5,!01,!47!.781:,!+=,.5,-a.,MN!\!-4!.=F!7!:-,.!01,!;,88,!.781:,!+=,.5,-a.,!3415!,E3:,552+,.89!.-!3415!5,.5->4,+,.89!5-.*.!01,!Q=7-!1.!;*:359!01-!,58!+74!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!MM!<,5;7:8,5!2;:-8!\!]!-4!.=F!7!3*-.8!/,!/*18,!01,!8*18!;,!01,!47!.781:,!+=,.5,-a.,!;*.8-,.8!01,401,!@,:-82C!"7:!37:!47!.781:,9!;*5-/2:2,!,.!a2.2:749!Q,!.=,.8,./5!+7-.8,.7.8!718:,!;6*5,!01,!<-,1!+L+,9!*1!>-,.!4=*:/:,!,8!47!/-53*5-8-*.!01,!<-,1!7!287>4-,!/7.5!4,5!;6*5,5!;:,2,5C!)8!37:!+7!.781:,!,.!37:8-;14-,:9!Q,!.=,.8,./5!718:,!;6*5,!01,!47!;*+34,E-*.!*1!4=755,+>47a,!/,!8*18,5!4,5!;6*5,5!01,!<-,1!+=7!/*..2,5!`!X$'!&U9!OR[C!MN!]!$J-.!01=-4!.=F!7-8!:-,.!,.!;,;-!01,!Q,!.,!;*.^*-@,!/-58-.;8,+,.89!Q,!/*-5!3:2;-5,+,.8!/2J-.-:!;,!01,!Q=,.8,./5!3:*3:,+,.8!4*:501,!Q,!/-5!01,!47!.781:,!+=,.5,-a.,!01,401,!;6*5,C!"7:!Q,!3:,./5!-;-!47!.781:,!,.!1.,!5-a.-J-;78-*.!3415!:,55,::2,9!01,!4*:501,!Q,!4=733,44,!1.!755,+>47a,!*1!1.,!;*+34,E-*.!/,!8*18,5!4,5!
!!Me!/-53*52!017./!Q,!5,.5!/,!47!/*14,1:9!01-!7!>,5*-.!/,!+7.a,:!*1!/,!>*-:,9!017./!Q=7-!4,5!5,.8-+,.85!/,!47!J7-+!*1!/,!47!5*-J9!,8;C!!MVC!47!/,1E-?+,!;6*5,!01,!47!.781:,!+=,.5,-a.,!MMC!47!8:*-5-?+,!;6*5,!01,!47!.781:,!+=,.5,-a.,!MNC!4=1.-*.!/,!4=,53:-8!,8!/1!;*:359!,8!4,!:p4,!/,5!5,.5!MSC!47!5*1@,:7-.,!>*.82!/,!<-,19!,8!47!.781:,!;*++,!4=1.-*.!MRC!4,5!;6*5,5!71E01,44,5!.*15!5*++,5!/-:,;8,+,.8!3*:825!37:!47!.781:,!,8!47!.781:,!;*++,!1.,!5-+34,!/2.*+-.78-*.!!MkC!4=,::,1:!/,!47!.781:,!!MOC!<,!4=,53:-8!,8!4,!;*:35!!MeC!4=-.8,:7;8-*.!,.8:,!4=,53:-8!,8!4,!;*:35!!MPC!<,5!:,478-*.5!,.8:,!/,5!37:8-,5!+*F,..,5!/1!;,:@,71!,8!4=,53:-8!MTC!D7!;*::,53*./7.;,!,.8:,!4,5!+*1@,+,.85!,8!/,5!5,.5!NVC!4=,::,1:!/,!.781:,!;*++,!4=1.-*.!!NMC!D7!.781:, !/,!4=6*++,!;*++,!;*+3*52 !/,!4=,53 :-8!,8!/1!;*:35!/*..,!47 !;737;-82!/=2@-8,:!4=,::,1:9!,8!;,!01,!4,5!5,.5!3,1@,.8!.*15!733:,./:,!!i1,44,!,58!47!/-JJ2:,.;,!,.8:,!4=2/-8-*.!$'!,8!47!/,1E-?+,!2/-8-*.!H!)44,!;*.;,:.,!4,!N,!37:7a:736,!01-!8:7-8,!/,!47!/-J J2:,.;,! ,.8:,!4A-+7a-.78-*.!,8!4A-.8,44,; 8-*.9!,8!4,!S,!37:7a:736,!/,!4=2/-8-*.!$'!01-!;*++,.;,!Y!8:7-8,:!/,5!5,.5!\!]!Q,!:733,44,:7-!/7.5!+7!+2+*-:,!01,44,5!5*.8!4,5!;6*5,5!01,!Q=7-!;-G/,@7.8!8,.1,5!3*1:!@:7-,59!;*++,!4,5!7F7.8!:,^1,5!37:!4,5!5,.5!`MSC!D=2/-8-*.!$'!.,!a7:/,!375!;,5!37:7a:736,5!7447.8!/1!M,:!71!S,!;*++,!1.,!52:-,9!+7-5!/-@-5,!4=,.5,+>4,!,.!/,1EC!!).!,E7+-. 7.8!/A7>*:/!;,!S,!37:7a:736,9!*.!: ,+7:01,!01,!/7 .5!47!/,1E- ?+,!2/-8-*.9!-4!5=28,./! 51:!8:*-5!37a,5!,8!/,+- ,!X33C!ekGeP[C!)8!47!/,1E-?+,!2/-8-*.!5,!;*+3*5,!/,5!61-8!8,+35!51-@7.85!\!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!;6*5,5!01,!<-,1!+=7!/*..2,5!_!@1!01,!;,8!755,+>47a,!*1!;*+34,E-*.!;*+3:,./!>,71;*13!/,!;6*5,5!01-!.=7337:8-,..,.8!01=Y!4=,53:-8!5,149!/,501,44,5!Q,!.=,.8,./5!3*-.8!-;-!37:4,:9!,.!37:47.8!/,!47!.781:,!\!;*++,!37:!,E,+34,9!47!.*8-*.!01,!Q=7-!/,!;,88,!@,:-829!01,!;,!01-!7!1.,!J*-5!282!J7-8!.,!3,18!3415!.=7@*-:!3*-.8!282!J7-89!,8!1.,!-.J-.-82!/=718:,5!5,+>47>4,59!01,!Q,!;*..7-5!37:!47!41+-?:,!.781:,44,!57.5!4=7-/,!/1!;*:359!,8!01=-4!,.!;*+3:,./!7155-!3415-,1:5!718:,5!01-!.=7337:8-,..,.8!01=71!;*:35!5,149!,8!.,!5*.8!3*-.8!-;-!.*.!3415!;*.8,.1,5!5*15!4,!.*+!/,!.781:,!\!;*++,!47!0174-82!01=-4!7!/=L8:,!3,57.89!,8!3415-,1:5!718:,5!5,+>47>4,59!/,501,44,5!Q,!.,!37:4,!375!7155-9!+7-5!5,14,+,.8!/,5!;6*5,5!01,!<-,1!+=7!/*..2,59!;*++,!287.8!;*+3*52!/,!4=,53:-8!,8!/1!;*:35!`!X$'!&U9!Ok[C!MS!$'!&U9!kTC!
!!MP!MC!D,5!;6*5,5!01,!Q=7-!:,^1,5!37:!4,5!5,.59!;=,58GYG/-:,!01,!Q=7@7-5!1.,!8L8,9!/,5!+7-.59!,8;C9!718:,+,.8!/-8!8*18,5!4,5!37:8-,5!/*.8!+*.!;*:35!,58!;*+3*52!NC!D,5!5,.5!+=*.8!7155-!733:-5!01,!+*.!;*:35!,58!347;2!,.8:,!/=718:,5!;*:35!01-!3,1@,.8!L8:,!5*1:;,!/,!/*14,1:!*1!/,!347-5-:!SC!h*.!;*:35!+,!J7-8!23:*1@,:!7155-!/,5!5,.578-*.5!-.8,:.,5!XJ7-+59!5*-J[!,8!/,5!5,.8-+,.85!XQ*-,9!8:-58,55,[!RC!D,5!5,.5!+,!J*.8!3,:;,@*-:9!*18:,!4=,E8,.5-*.9!4,5!J-a1:,5!,8!4,5!+*1@,+,.85!/,5!;*:35!4,5!718:,5!0174-825!01,!5*.8!47!/1:,829!;674,1:9!;*14,1:9!*/,1:9!,8;C!!kC!]!v=,E32:-+,.8*-5!01=,44,5!5,!3:25,.8*-,.8!Y!,44,!b+7!3,.52,d9!57.5!01,!+*.!;*.5,.8,+,.8!F!J158!:,01-59!,.!5*:8, !01,! Q,!.,!3*1@*-5!5,.8-:!71;1.! *>Q,89!01,401,!@*4*.82!01,!Q=,.!,155,9!5=-4!.,!5,!8:*1@*-8!3:25,.8!Y!4=*:a7.,!/=1.!/,!+,5!5,.5!_!,8!-4!.=,8*-8!.144,+,.8!,.!+*.!3*1@*-:!/,!.,!4,!375!5,.8-:9!4*:501=-4!5=F!8:*1@*-8!3:25,.8!`C!!OC!]!",!.=,58*-8!375!57.5!01,401,!:7-5*.!01,!Q,!;:*F*-5!01,!;,!;*:35!4,01,4!37:!1.!;,:87-.!/:*-8!37:8-;14-,:!Q=733,4*-5!+-,.!`!eC!]!c!-4!.=F!7!;,:8,5!71;1.,!7JJ-.-82!.F!71;1.!:733*:8!X71!+*-.5!01,!Q,!31-55,!;*+3:,./:,[!,.8:,!;,88,!2+*8-*.!/,!4=,58*+7;!,8!4,!/25-:!/,!+7.a,:9!.*.!3415!01=,.8:,!4,!5,.8-+,.8!/,!47!;6*5,!01-!;715,!/,!47!/*14,1:9!,8!47!3,.52,!/,!8:-58,55,!01,!J7-8!.7-8:,!;,!5,.8-+,.8!`!PC!]!&4!+,!5,+>4*-8!01,!Q=7@7-5!733:-5!/,!47!.781:,!8*18,5!4,5!718:,5!;6*5,5!01,!Q,!Q1a,*-5!8*1;67.8!4,5!*>Q,85!/,!+,5!5,.5!`!!!<7.5!4=2/-8-*.!$'9!!,8!!5*.8!:,a7:/25!;*++,! J*:+7.8!1.!5,14!,8!+L+,!37:7a:736,C!&45!5*.8!-./ 23,./7.85C!v,! 3,.5,!01=$'!/-58:->1,!X;*13,[!1.!37:7a:736 ,!,.!;*.5-/2:78-*.!/,!47!47.a1,!,8!/1!;*.8,.1!/,!;,5!37:7a:736,5C!!!I.!:,37:4,!-;-!/,!k!7:8-;4,5!/,!K!WF.*35-5!K!,.;*:,!1.,!J*-5!_!!MC!intellectionabimaginationsecertur;distinctionumsignadescribunturC!NC!mentemrealiteracorporedistingui,probatur.!SC!tamarcteilli(corpori'esseconjun ctam,utunumquidcumipsacompnat,ostenditurC!RC!omneserroresquiasensibusoririsolenterecensentur,modiquibusvitaripossintexponuntur,modiquibusvitaripossintexponunturC!
!!MT!kC!rationesomnesexquibusr erummaterialiumexis tentia possitconclude, afferunturC!!$4*:59!5-!*.!J7-8!47!;*+37:7-5*.!/,!;,5!;-.0!7:8-;4,5!7@,;!47!/,1E-?+,!2/-8-*.!,8!4=2/-8-*.!$'!/,!47 !O,!Méditation9!*.!3,18! 5=73,:;,@*-:!01,!4A*:/:,!,58!/ -JJ2:, .8C!",47!5-a.-J-,9!/7.5!47!/,1E-?+,!2/-8-*.!,8!4=2/-8-*.!$'9!3*1:!4A*:/:,9!k9!M9!N9!S9!,8!RC!)8!31-59!-;-9!*.!/*-8!: ,+7:01,:!01,!<, 5;7:8,5!37:4,!/,!intellectus9!imaginatio9!,8!sensus!,.!-.8,:@,.7.8!/,!47!86?5,!/,!47!/-58-.;8-*.!:2,44,!,8!4A1.-*.!51>587.8-,44,!/,!4=B+,!,8!/1!;*:35C!!!!I-2.Lapositiondebasepourl'interprétationdusystèmephilosophiquedeDescartesI.!57-8!a2.2:74,+,.8!01,!<,5;7:8,5!3*5,!1.,!/-58-.;8-*.!:2,44,!,.8:,!4=B+,!,8!4,!;*:359!+7-5!;*++,!*.!4=7!:,+7:0129!-4!-.8:*/1-8!7155-!47!86?5,!/,!4,1:!1.-*.!51>587.8-,44,C!&4!5=7a-8! 3*1:!.*15!/=1.,!2.-a+,!01-!.*15!;*.8 :7-.8!Y !3,.5,:!]!,.!+L+,!8,+3 5!`!47!862*:-,!;7:825-,..,!/,!4=1.-*.!51>587.8-,44,!/,!4=B+,!,8!/1!;*:35!,8!4,1:!/-58-.;8-*.!:2,44,C!W-!<,5;7: 8,5!.,!/2J-.-557-8!375!4=1.-*.!;*++,!51>587.8-,44,9!47!01,58-*.!5,:7-8!3415!5-+34,C!m-,.!5w:9!-4!.=18-4-5,!375!8*1Q*1:5!4=,E3:,55-*.!/=1.-*.!51>587.8-,44,9!+7-5!-4!3,.5,!4=1.-*.!,.!87.8!01,!51>587.8-,44,9!Y!57@*-:!;*++,!1.-557.8!/,1E!51>587.;,5!:7/-;74,+,.8!/-58-.;8,5!/7.5!]!1.1+!01-/!`C!h7-5!;,!01,!4=*.!/*-8!,E7+-.,:!,58!/,!57@*-:!5-!<,5;7:8,5!8:7-8,!4=1.-*.!/,!47!+L+,!+7.-?:,!/7.5!8*15!5,5!8,E8,5C!%*1:!4=-.8,:3:2878-*.!/1!5F58?+,!/,!<,5;7:8 ,59!>,71;*13!/ ,!532;-74-58,5!/,!<,5;7:8,5!*.8!3:25,.82!/,5!*3-.-*.5 !/-JJ2:,.8,59!01,!4=*.!3,18!*:/*..,:!,.!8:*-5!8F3,5!/-58-.;85!01,!4=*.!3,18!-/,.8-J-,:!37:!8:*-5!;*++,.878,1:5 !/,!4=x1@:,!/,!<,5;7:8,5!\!h7 :8-74!q1,:*1489!j,: /-.7./!$401-29!h-;6-*!o*>7F756-C!!D7!/-JJ2:,.;,!3:-.;-374,!,.8:,!4,1:5!3*5-8-*.5!5=,E3:-+,!4,!3415!;47-:,+,.89!017./!*.!J7-8!3*:8,:!4=788,.8-*.!51:!4,!5,.5!/1!;*.;,38!/=]!*:/:,!`!/,!47!3,.52,!;7:825-,..,C!D=]!*:/:,!`!3,18!5,!;*+3:,./:,!/,!/,1E!+7.-?:,5C!D=1.,!;*.;,:.,!4=*:/:,!-.8,:.,!/1!5F58?+,9!,8!4=718: ,!;*.;,:.,!5*.!2@*418-*.!;6:*.*4*a-01,C!q1,:*148!7887;6,!1.,!-+3*:87.;,!37:8-;14-?:,!Y!4=*:/:,!/1!5F58?+,9!87./-5!01=$401-2!;*.5-/?:,!4=*:/:,!5,4*.!4,!8,+35C!!
!!NV!%*1:!q1,:*1489!]!;,5!/,1E!/,55,-.5!\!3:*1@,:!47!/-58-.;8-*.!:2,44,!/1!;*:35!,8!/,!4=B+,9!3:*1@,:!4,1:!1.-*.!51>587.8-,44,9!5,!;*.8:7:-,.8!`MRC!)8!q1,:*148!3*1:51-8!\!]!<=*r!4=*.!@*-8!01,!47!;*..7-557.;,!/,!47!/-58-.;8-*.!,8!;,44,!/,!4=1.-*.!5,!:2J?:,.8!Y!/,5!57@*-:5!/-JJ2:,.859!4,!3:,+-,:!Y!47!:7-5*.9!4,!5,;*./!71!5,.8-+,.8C!%*1:!7;;2/,:!Y!47!3:,+-?:,9!-4!J718!]!J,:+,:!4,5!F,1E9!5,!>*1;6,:!4,5!*:,-44,5!`9!>:,J9!]!/28*1:.,:!8*15!5,5!5,.5!`!_!3*1:!7;;2/,:!7!47!5,;*./,9!-4!J7189!,.!01,401,!5*:8,9!5,!J,:+,:!Y!4=,.8,./,+,.8!31:9!]!5,!/2J7-:,!/,5!-/2,5!;47-:,5!,8!/-58-.;8,5!,8!,.!37:8-;14-,:!/,5!:7-5*.5!01-!*.8!3:*1@2!47!/-58-.;8-*.!/,5!51>587.;,5!`9!3*1:!5=7>7./*..,:!,.8-?:,+,.8!Y!4=,E-58,.;,!/1!5,.8-+,.8C!h7-5!3*1:!prouver!47!:274-82!/,!4=1.-*.!,8!,.!+L+,!8,+35!3*1:!/2;*1@:-:!cequ'elleest9!;=,58GYG/-:,!1.,!1.-*.!51>587.8-,44,!/,!/,1E!51>587.;,5!/-58-.;8,59!-4!,58!.2;,557-:,!/,!5=7/:,55,:!Y!4=,.8,./,+,.8!,8!/=287>4-:!3:2747>4,+,.89!,8!01,!4,!;*:35!,58!:2,44,+,.8!/-58-.;8!/,!4=B+,9!,8!01,!4,!;*:35!,E-58,C!).J-.!;=,58!4=,.8,./,+,.8!01-!@74-/,:7!47!;*+328,.;,!/1!5,.8-+,.8!,8!8:7;,:7!4,5!4-+-8,5!/,!;,44,G;-!`MkC!"=,58!/*.;9!5,4*.!q1,:*1489!,.!:,58-817.8!4=*:/:,!/,5!:7-5*.5!Y!4=x1@:,!/7.5!47!VIeMéditation!01,!4=*.!3,18!;*+3:,./:,!;*++,.8!5=7:8-;14,.8!,.5,+>4,!47!/-58-.;8-*.!:2,44,!,8!4=1.-*.!51>587.8-,44,!/,!4=B+,!,8!/1!;*:35C!"=,58!;,!01-!J7-8!47!;*+34,E-82!/,!;,!8,E8,C!]!D7!VIeMéditation!.,!/*-8!375!L8:,!;7:7;82:-52,!5,4*.!1.,!5,14,!/,!;,5!/,1E!3,:53,;8-@,5!Xx!*1!y[9!+7-5!4,5!/,1E!Y!47!J*-5C!)44,!,58!Y!47!J*-5!1.,!/2+*.58:78-*.!8*1:.2,!@,:5!4,5!;6*5,5!,E82:-,1:,5!\!3:*1@,:!4=,E-58,.;,!/,5!;*:359!4,1:!/-58-.;8-*.!:2,44,!/=7@,;!+*.!B+,9!4=1.-*.!51>587.8-,44,!/,!+*.!B+,!,8!/,!+*.!;*:359!J*./,:!4,5!/-@,:5,5!5;-,.;,5!_!,8!1.,!-.@,58-a78-*.!;:-8-01,!8*1:.2,!@,:5!+*.!-.82:-,1:!\!@74-/-82!*>Q,;8-@,!/,!+,5!;*..7-557.;,5!5,.5->4,59!3:*>4?+,!61+7-.!/,!4=,::,1:!5,.5->4,9!3:*>4?+,!/=1.,!862*/-;2,!Q158-J-;78:-;,!`MOC!!).!:,@7.;6,9!3*1:!$401-29!]!&4!F!7!CCC!1.,!2@*418-*.!/,!47!3,.52,!/,!<,5;7:8,59!,8!;,88,!2@*418-*.!+,8!,.!41 +-?:,!1.,!/2 ;*1@,:8,!3:* a:,55-@,9!,8!3:*3:,+,.8!+28736F5-01,9!/,!4=6*++,C!D=*:/:,!/7.5!4,01,4!5=,58!J*:+2,!47!/*;8:-.,!/,!<,5;7:8,5!.=,58!375!4=*:/:,!01=-4!,E3*5,!,.!5,5!/,:.-,:5!8:7@71EC!D*-.!/=L8:,!37:8-!/,!;*.5-/2:78-*.5!+28736F5-01,5!3*1:!J*./,:!47!5;-,.;,9!<,5;7:8,5!,58!37:8-!/,!47!5;-,.;,!,44,G+L+,9!Y!4701,44,!-4!7!/,+7./2!47!5*418-*.!/,!8*15!4,5!3:*>4?+,59!,8!.=7!/2;*1@,:8!01=,.51-8,!01,!47!5;-,.;,!.,!3*1@7-8!L8:,!3,.52,!01=Y!37:8-:!/,!5,5!;*./-8-*.5!+28736F5-01,5C!&4!7!/*.;!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!MR!h7:8-74!q1,:*1489!Descartesselonl'ordredesraisons9!&&9!4=B+,!,8!4,!;*:359!%7:-5!\!$1>-,:Gh*.87-a.,9!MTOP9!3C!PGTC!Mk!Ibid.9!3C!TC!MO!IbidC9!3C!MPGMTC!
!!NM!3:*a:,552!/,5!5;-,.;,5!Y!47!36- 4*5*36-,!@:7-,9!,8!47!:2J4,E-*.!51:!4=6*++,!_!,8! .*15!3,.5*.5!01,!5=,E34-01,.8!7-.5-!;,!01=*.!7!;*181+,!/,!.*++,:!5,5!]!;*.8:7/-;8-*.5!`!`MeC!!!)8!-4!5,+>4,! 01,!o*>7F756-!5=,JJ*:;,!/=1.-:!4,5!3*-.8 5!J*:85!/,!q1,:*148 !,8!/=$401-2!\!-4!3,.5,!01,!4=*.!.,!/*-8!375!5,14,+,.8!;*.5-/2:,:!1.,!;,:87-.,!37:8-,!/=1.!*1@:7a,!/,!<,5;7:8,59!+7 -5!4=*.!/ *-8!,E7+-.,:!8*15! 4,5!*1@:7a,59!57.5!01*-!*.!.,!3*1::7-8!375!;*+3:,./:,!47!@2:-87>4,!-.8,.8-*.!/,!<,5;7:8,5C!%*1:!;,479!*.!/*-8!51-@:,!4=788-81/,!52@?:,!/,!q1,:*148C!h7-5!-4!.*15!3:*3*5,!/,!51-@:,!2a74,+,.8!4=-.8,:3:2878-*.!/=$401-2!3*57.8!01,!47!36-4*5*36-,!/,!<,5;7:8,5!5,!;*.58:1-8!3,8-8!Y!3,8-8C!!D=-.8,:3:2878-*.!/,!o*> 7F756-!3,18!7337:7-8:,!;*.8:7/-;8*-:,!37:;,!01=,44,!:,53,;8,!4,1:5!4,;81:,5!,.!7/+,887.8!4,5!/,1E!86?5,5!;7:825-,..,5!_!47!/-58-.;8-*.!:2,44,!,8!4=1.-*.!51>587.8-,44,!/,!4=B+,!,8!/1!;*:35C!$18:,+,.8!/-89!o*>7F756-!7/*38,!1.,!3*5-8-*.!01-!-.8,:3:?8,!47!36-4*5*36-,!/,!<,5;7:8,5!;*++,!q1,:*1489!5,4*.!47!:-a1,1:!4*a-01,!,8!;*++,!$401-29!5,4*.!4=,E32:-,.;,!*.8*4*a-01,C!!o*>7F756-!-.5-58,!3*1:!01,!4=*.!3,.5,!47!/-58-.;8-*.!:2,44,!;*++,!1.,!/-+,.5-*.!532;1478-@,9!,8!4=1.-*.!51>587.8-,44,!/,!4=B+,!,8!/1!;*:35!;*++,!1.,!/-+,.5-*.!/,!47!@-,!3:78-01,C!&4!7JJ-:+,!01=-4!.=F!7!375! ;*.8:7/-;8-* .!,.8:,!4,5!/,1E! 86?5,5!a:B;,! Y!47!/-58-.;8-*.!/,!;,5!/,1E!/-+,.5-*.5C!).!,JJ,89!-4!F!7!;*.8:7/-;8-*.!5-!/,1E!;6*5,5!5*.8!/-JJ2:,.8,5!,8!.,!5*.8!375!/-JJ2:,.8,5!,.!+L+,!8,+35C!)8!o*>7F756-!+*.8:,!01,!4,5!/,1E!86?5,59!;,44,5!/,!47!/-58-.;8-*.!,8!/,!4=1.-*.!/,!4=B+,!,8!/1!;*:359!5*.8!/-JJ2:,.8,5!37:;,!01=,44,5!7337:8-,..,.8!Y!/,1E!347.5!/-JJ2:,.85!,8!7155-!37:;,!01=,44,5!5,!51;;?/,.8!/7.5!4,!8,+35C!!!).!J7-89!*.!:,+7:01,!01,!/,::-?:,!4,5!/-JJ2:,.;,5!/=-.8,:3:2878-*.9!;,!5*.8!/,5!8,E8,5!/-JJ2:,.85!01-!5*.8!3:-@-42a-25!37:!4,5!4,;8,1:5!/,!<,5;7:8,5C!"*++,!Q,!4=7-!/2QY!/-89!;,47!,58!37:8-;14 -?:,+,.8!@:7-!/,5!Méditationsmétap hysiques!/*.8!-4!,58!/-JJ-;-4,!/,!/28,:+-.,:!4,!51Q,8!3:*3:,9!,8!01-!515;-8,!/*.;!/,!a:7./,5!@7:-2825!/=-.8,:3:2878-*.5C!!D7!/-JJ-;1482!,58!/,!3,.5,:!47!/-58-.;8-*.!:2,44,!,8!4=1.-*.!51>587.8-,44,!/,!4=B+,!,8!/1!;*:35!,.!+L+,!8,+35!/7.5!47!+L+,!x1@:,C!W-!4,5!-/2,5!/=1.!3,.5,1:!5*.8!/-JJ2:,.8,5!/7.5!1.!3:,+-,:!+*+,.8!/,!5*.!x1@:,!,8!/7.5!1.!5,;*./!+*+,.89!;*++,!;=,58!4,!;75!/,!D1/y-a!z-88a,.58,-.9!*.!3,18!281/-,:!4,5!;67.a,+,.85!/,!3,.52,!Y!;67;1.!/,!;,5!+*+,.85C!h7-5!<,5;7:8,5!3,.5,!/7.5!1.!+L+,!4-@:,9!4,5!Méditationsmétaphysiques,!/A1.!;p82!1.,!/-58-.;8-*.!:2,44,!,.8:,!4=B+,!,8!4,!;*:359!/A73:?5!4701,44,!4AB+,!,8!4,!;*:35!.,!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!Me!j,:/-.7./!$401-29!Ladécouvertemétaphysiquedel'hommechezDescartes,Paris:P.U.F.,19509!3C!MVC!
!!NN!3,1@,.8!7@*-:!/,!:,478-*.5!:2;-3:*01,5!/7.5!1.,!5,14,!,8!+L+,!3,:5*..,9!,8!/,!4=718:,!4=1.-*.!/,!4=B+,!,8!/1!;*:35!01-!-+34-01,!71!;*.8:7-:,!4,1:5!:,478-*.5C!D=-.8,:3:2878-*.!/=$401-2!7JJ-:+,!01,!<,5;7:8,5!/2@,4*33,!5,5!-/2,5!a:7/1,44,+,.89!87./-5!01,!;,44,!/,!o*>7F756-!;*.5-58,!Y!3,.5,:!47!/-JJ2:,.;,!,.8:,!47!/-58-.;8-*.!,8!4=1.-*.!37:!,.!4,5!347^7.8!/7.5!/,1E!/-+,.5-*.5!/-JJ2:,.8,5C!!%*1:!51:+*.8,:!;,88,!/-JJ-;14829!47!01,58-*.!5,!3*5,!/,!57@*-:!5-!4=*.!3,18!-.@*01,:!/=718:,5!8,E8,59!,E82:-,1:5!71E!MéditationsC!D,5!4,;8,1:5!/,!<,5;7:8,5!*.8!1.,!;*.5;-,.;,!7-a1,!/,!;,!3:*>4?+,C!%*1:!q1,:*1489!-4!,58!-+3*:87.8!/,!J7-:,!733,4!71!;x1:!/,!4*a-01,!-++7.,.8!/,5!8,E8,59!,8!-4!;*.5-/?:,!01=-4!,58!3:2J2:7>4,!/,!.,!375!:,;*1:-:!71E!J7;8,1:5!*1!-.J41,.;,5!,E82:-,1:5!3*1:!:,./:,!;*+38,!/,5!/-JJ-;14825!/,!47!3,.52,!/,!<,5;7:8,5C!&4!2@-8,!/*.;!/=18-4-5,:!4,5!*>Q,;8-*.5!,8!:23*.5,!,8!47!;*::,53*./7.;,!/,!<,5;7:8,5!3*1:!:,58-81,:!47!3,.52,!/,!<,5;7:8,5!/7.5!47!VIeMéditationC!!&4!,58!-+3*:87.8!/,!.*8,:!01,!4,5!4,;81:,5!/,!q1,:*148!,8!/=$401-2!5*.8!/-JJ2:,.8,5!/=1.!3*-.8!/,!@1,!+286*/*4*a-01,!3*1:!4=-.8,:3:2878-*.!/,5!Méditationsmétaphysiques9!+7-5!,44,5!5,!:,Q*-a.,.8!/7.5!47!;*+3:26,.5-*.!/1!8,E8,!/,5!MéditationsmétaphysiquesC!o*>7F756-!3,.5,!01=-4!.,!J718!375!-a.*:,:!4=*:/:,!/1!/2@,4*33,+,.8!/,!4=7:a1+,.878-*.9!017./!*.!@,18!;*+3:,./:,!4,!5,.5!@2:-87>4,!/,5!Méditations!métaphysiques9!+7-5!-4!,58!3,:+-5!/,!J7-:,!+,.8-*.!/=718:,5!8,E8,5!7J-.!/,!;*++,.8,:!/,5!37557a,5!37:8-;14-,:5!/,5!MéditationsC!v,!.,!3,1E!375!733:*1@,:!47!J7^*.!/*.8!o*>7F756-!/-@-5,!,.!/,1E!37:8-,5!4,5!Méditations9!37:;,!01,!4=-.8,:3:2878-*.!/,!o*>7F756-!;*13,!47!51;;,55-*.!/1!8,+35C!&4!+,!5,+>4,!01,!<,5;7:8 ,5!7!/w!,E7+-., :!/=7>*:/!47!/-58-.;8-* .9!31-5!4=1.-*.C!o*>7F756-!-a.*:,9!,.!01,401,! 5*:8,9!47!;*.8-.1-82!/1!8,+35!3*1:!571@,:!< ,5;7:8,5 !/,!47!;*.8:7/-;8-*.!/,!5*.!5F58?+,!36-4*5*36-01, C!W,4*.!o*>7F756-9!5-! *.!7/+,8 87-8!5-+1487.2+,.8!4,5!/,1E!86?5,59!47!/-58 -.;8-*.!,8!4 =1.-*.9!*.!5,!6,1:8,:7-8!Y!1.,! ;*.8:7/-;8-*.!4*a-01,C!)8!4=-.8,:3:2878-*.!/,!o*>7F756-!.=,58!375!,.!;*.8:7/-;8-*.!4*a-01,9!;7:!4,5!/,1E!86?5,5!:,4?@,.8!/,!/,1E!/-+,.5-*.5!/-JJ2:,.8,5C!",3,./7.8!Q,!;*.5,.5!Y!;,88,!+286*/*4*a-,!01-!,58!/-JJ2:,.8,!/,!;,44,5!/,!q12:*148!,8!$401-2C!!v,!+=,JJ*:;,!/,!;*.5-/2:,:!;-G/,55*15!47!J7^*.!/*.8!<,5;7:8,5!41-G+L+,!,E3*5,!;,5!/,1E!5-8178-*.5!/-JJ-;-4,5!01,!5*.8!47!/-58-.;8-*.!:2,44,!,8!4=1.-*.!51>587.8-,44,!/,!4=B+,!,8!/1!;*:35!,.!+L+,!8,+359!,.!18-4-57.8!47!+286*/*4*a-,!/,!o*>7F756-C!)8!-4!,58!7-.5-!3*55->4,!/,!57@*-:!5-!57!J7^*.!/,!51:+*.8,:!4=*33*5-8-*.!,.8:,!47!/-58-.;8-*.!:2,44,!,8!4=1.-* .!51>587.8-,44,!/,!4=B+, !,8!/1!;*:35!3,:+,8!,JJ,;8-@,+,.8!/,!:25*1/:,!47!/-JJ-;1482!/1!5F58?+,!;7:825-,.C!
!!NS! I-3.Lesystèmephilosophiqu edeDescartes:seheurte-t-ilàunecontradiction?"*++,!*.!4=7!-./ -0129!47!58:1;81:,!/,5!Méditations!5*14?@,!1.!3:*>4?+,!/=-.8,:3:2878-*.9!,8!;=,58!47!O,!Méditation!01-!,58!47!;4,J!/,!4=2.-a+,9!;7:!;=,58!,44,!01-!J7-8!01,58-*.9!31-501=,44,!;*+>-.,!5-+1487.2+,.8!4,5!/,1E!86?5,5!\!47!/-58-.;8-*.!:2,44,!,8!4=1.-*.!51>587.8-,44,!/ ,!4=B+,!,8!/1!;*:35C!%7:!;*.5201,.89!4,5!4,;8,1:5!/,!<,5;7:8 ,5!281/-,.8!,8!*>5,:@,.8!4,!:733*:8!/,!47!O,!MéditationY!4=x1@:,!/,!<,5;7:8,5C!"*++,!*.!4=7!5-a.742!3415!67189!*.!3,18!;4755,:!a:*55-?:,+,.8!4,5!-.8,:3:2878-*.5!/,5!Méditations!,.!8:*-5!3:-.;-374,5C!m-,.!5w:9!;,5!8:*-5!-.8,:3:2878-*.59!/*.8!*.!7/+,8!a2.2:74,+,.8!01=,44,5!5*.8!/,@,.1,5!;4755-01,59!37:8-;14-?:,+,.8!;,44,5!/,!q1,:*148!,8!/=$401-29!*.8!;67;1.,!/,5!7@7.87a,5!,8!/,5!-.;*.@2.-,.859!;*++,!8*18,!-.8,:3:2878-*.C!D=-.8,:3:2878-*.!/,!q1,:*148!,58!1.,!,E34-;78-*.!;47-:,!,8!5-+34,9!01-!-.5-58,!/,!J7^*.!3,:8-.,.8,!51:!47!01,58-*.!/,!4=]!*:/:,!/,5!:7-5*.5!`C!h7-5!5-!4=*.!+,8!5,14,+,.8!,.!@74,1:!47!/-58-.;8-*.!:2,44,!/7.5!4,5!Méditationsmétaphysiques9!01,44,!5-a.-J-;78-*.!J718G-4!:,;*..7g8:,!Y!47!86?5,!/,!4=1.-*.!/,!4=B+,!,8!/1!;*:35!H!&4!,58!3*55->4,!01=74*:5!4=1.-*.!3,:/,!57!:7-5*.!/=L8:,!/7.5!;,8!*1@:7a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aa?:,.8!01,!<,5;7:8,5!.,!;*.5-/?:,!375!4=1.-*.!71!/2>18!/,5!Méditations9!+7-5! 01=-4!7!/2;*1@,:8!4=6*++,!;*++,!1.-*.!51 >587.8-,44,!a:B;,!Y!57!;*::,53*./7.;,!7@,;!)4-57>,86C!!%*1:01*-!1.,!8,44,!7JJ-:+78-*.!H!%7:;,!01,!;,5!4,;8,1:5!/,!<,5;7:8,5!;:7-a.,.8!/,!J7-:,!7337 :7g8:,!1.!/2J718!/,!4*a-01 ,!/7.5!4,5!Méditations9!,.!@*147.8!:,58-81,:!J-/?4,+,.8!47!3,.52,!/,!<,5;7:8,5C!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!MP!"JC!#-:*7t-!s 7+7/79!Dekarutoseis atsunokenkyu[ÉtudessurlesMéditationsdeDesc artes],'utFu!\!W*>1.5679!MTTR9!3C!RVMC!!
!!NR! v,!+=7;;*:/,!7@,;!4=-.8,:3:2878-*.!/=$401-2!51:!4=-/2,!/,!47!/2;*1@,:8,!;7:825-,..,!/,!4=6*++,9!+7-5!-4!,58!:,a:,887>4,!01=-4!-.8,:3:?8,!47!O,!Méditation!/7.5!1.,!*:-,.878-*.!01=*.!3*1::7-8!.*++,:!]!,E-58,.8-,44,!`C!)8!51:8*189!*.!.,!3,18!7/+,88:,!01,!<,5;7:8,5!7-8!;*++,.;2!57!:2J4,E-*.!51:!4=1.-*.!/,!4=B+,!,8!/1!;*:35!5,14,+,.8!Y!37:8-:!/,!47!;*::,53*./7.;,!7@,;!)4-57>,86C!I.!3,18!;,3,./7.8!;*+3:,./:,!01,!;,:87-.5!4,;8,1:5!Q73*.7-5!-.8,:3:?8,.8!47!3*5-8-*.!/,!4=1.-*.!7-.5-9!;7:9!;*++,!*.!4=7!:,+7:0129!<,5;7:8,5!41-G+L+,!2;:-8!01,!5*.!]!3:-.;-374!/,55,-.!287-8!/,!3:*1@,:!47!/-58-.;8-*.!01-!,58!,.8:,!4=B+,!,8!4,!;*:35!`9!7Q*187.8!01,9!/,5!]!/,1E!;6*5,5!,.!4=B+,!61+7-.,9!/,501,44,5!/23,./!8*18,!47!;*..7-557.;,!01,!.*15!3*1@*.5!7@*-:!/,!57!.781:,9!4=1.,!/,501,44,5!,58!01=,44,!3,.5,9!4=718:,9!01=287.8!1.-,!71!;*:359!,44,!3,18!7a-:!,8!3B8-:!7@,;!41-!`9!5,14,!47!3:,+-?:,!3*1@7-8!5,:@-:!;,!/,55,-.9!]!4=718:,!F!71:7-8!282!.1-5->4,!`MTC!!D=-.8,:3:2878-*.!/,!o*>7F756-!3:*3*5,!/,!/-58-.a1,:!/,1E!/-+,.5-*.5!/,!47 !01,58-*.9!47!/-+,.5-*.!862*:-01,!,8!47!/-+,.5-*.!3:78-01,C!&4!,557-,!37:G4Y!/,!571@,:!47!3,.52,!/,!<,5;7:8,5!/,!47 !;*.8:7/-;8-*.C!$551:2+,.8!4=-.8,:3:2878-*.!/, !o*>7F756-!3,:+,8!/,!;*+3:,./:,!4=2@*418-*.!/,5!Méditationsmétaphysiques!37:!47!/-58-.;8-*.!/,5!/,1E!/-+,.5-*.59!862*:-01,!,8!3:78-01,9!+7-5!-4!+,!5,+>4,!01=71!;*.8:7-:,!;,47!.*15!+*.8:,!1.,!/-@,:a,.;,!,.8:,!/,1E!5-8178-*.5!;*++,!;,44,!/,!/,1E!;*1;6,5!a2*4*a-01,5C!'7.8!01=*.!5=,.!8-,.8!71!37557a,!/1!WF.*35-59!*.!.,!3,18!01=73,:;,@*-:!47!;*.8:7/-;8-*.!,.8:,!4,5!/,1E!86?5,5C!!",!01-!,58!-;-!-+3*:87.8!,58!47!J7^*.!/*.8!<,5;7:8,5!41-G+L+,!,E3:-+,!;,5!/,1E!86?5,5C!)8!*.!3,18!-;-!5,!:2J2:,:!Y!47!R,!:23*.5,5!;*.8:,!4=*>Q,;8-*.!/=$:.714/!\!v,!.*++,!;,5!8,E8,5!-+3*:87.85!U9!sC!!!U!\!]!&87!.,;!+-6-!@-/,*:!.-+-1+!3:*>755,9!.,;!,8-7+!.-+-5!37:1+9!/-;,./*!-447+!,55,!;*:3 *:-!51>587.8-74 -8,:!1.-87+9!01-7!1.-*!- 447!51>587.8-74-5!.*.!-+3,/-8!01*+.15!;47:15!,8!/-58-.;815!5*4-15!+,.8-5!87.017+!:,-!;*+3+,87,!;*.;,815!67>,781:!`!XR7,!(,5C!$'!f&&9!NNP[20C!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!MT!<,5;7:8,5!Y!)4-57>,869!NM!+7-!MORS9!$'!&&&9!OORC!NV!]!c!7-.5-!Q,!.,!3,.5,!375!7@*-:!8:*3!3:*1@2!,.!+*.8:7.8!01,!4=,53:-8!3,18!L8:,!57.5!4,!;*:359!.-!7@*-:!7155-!8:*3!3,1!/-89 !,.!/-57.8!01=- 4!41-! ,58!51>587.8-,44,+,.8!1. -!_!37 :;,!01,!;,88,!1.-*. !51>587.8-,4 4,!.=,+3L;6,!375!01=*.!.,!31-55,!7@*-:!1.,!;47-:,!,8!/-58-.;8,!-/2,!*1!;*.;,38!/,!4=,53:-89!;*++,!/=1.,!;6*5,!;*+34?8,!`!X4eResC!$'!&U9!Mee[C!
!!Nk!s!\!]!Z7+!-.!,7/,+!5,E87!h,/-878-*.,9!-.!017!,a-!/,!/-58-.;8-*.,!+,.8-5!7!;*:3*:,9!5-+14!,8-7+!3:*>7@-!51>587.8-74-8,:!-44-!,55,!1.-87+!`!XR7,!(,5C!$'!f&&9!NNeGNNP[21C!%*1:!U9!;*++,!<,5;7:8,5!/-8!01,!]!;,88,!1.-*.!51>587.8-,44,!.=,+3L;6,!375!01=*.!.,!31-55,!7@*-:!1.,!;47-:,!,8!/-58-.;8,!-/2,!*1!;*.;,38!/,!4=,53:-8!`9!*.!3,18!;*+3:,./:,!01=-4!3,.5,! 01,!4=1.-*.!51>58 7.8-,44,!/,! 4=B+,!,8!/1!;*:35!/*-8!5=67:+*.-5,:!7@,;!47!/-58-.;8-*.!:2,44,C!)8!3*1:!s9!<,5;7:8,5!41-G+L+,!.*15!,E34-01,!]!3:*>7:-!`C!h7-5!017./!*.!;6,:;6,!;,! 8,:+,!/7.5!4,!WF.*35-59!*.!;*.587 8,!01,!<,5;7:8,5!.,!/-8!37 5!01=-4! 7!3:*1@2!4=1.-*.!/7.5!47!O,!MéditationC!<,!34159!4=,E3:,55-*.!/=]!1.-*.!51>587.8-,44,!/,!4=B+,!,8!/1!;*:35!`!.=,58!375!18-4-52,!/7.5!4,!8,E8,!/,!47!O,!Méditation9!,8!4=,E3:,55-*.!/,!]!3:,1@,!`!/,!]!4=1.-*.!`!.=F!J-a1:,!375!.*.!3415C!v,!3,.5,!01,!;,!3*-.8!/28-,.8!1.,!;4,J!-+3*:87.8,!-;-C!"*++,.8!<,5;7:8,5!3:*1@,G8G-4!]!4=1.-*.!`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i1 ,44,!-.J41,.;,!47!;*::,53*./7 .;,!7@,;!)4-57>,86!7G8G,44,!51:!4,!/2@,4*3 G3,+,.8!/,!47!:,478-*.!,.8:,!47!/-58-.;8-*.!,8!4=1.-*.!/,!4=B+,!,8!/1!;*:35!H!!SC!%*1:01*-!<,5;7:8,59!4*:501=-4!7>*:/,!47!86?5,!/,!]!4=1.-*.!`9!18-4-5,G8G-4!4,!8,:+,!5;*4758-01,!/=]!1.-*.!51>587.8-,44,!`9!>-,.!01,!4,5!Méditations!3:*;47+,!47!/-58-.;8-*.C!m-,.!5w:9!-4!,58!.2;,557-:,!/,!;*+3:,./:,!47!:7-5*.!3*1:!4701,44,!<,5;7:8,5!.,!5,!578-5J7-8!375!5,14,+,.8!/,!47!86?5,!/,!47!/-58-.;8-*.!,8!5=7887;6,!Y!,E7+-.,:!4=1.-*.9!+7-5!*.!7!>,5*-.!/,!5,!J7-:,!1.,!-/2,!3415!;47-:,!/,5!/,1E!01,58-*.5!;-G/,55*15!\!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!NM!]!"7:!/7.5!47!+L+,!5-E-,+,!Méditation9!*r!Q=7-!37:42!/,!47!/-58-.;8-*.!/,!4=,53:-8!/=7@,;!4,!;*:359!Q=7-!7155-!+*.8:2!01=-4!41-!,58!51>587.8-,44,+,.8!1.-!`!XIbid.[C!&4!,58!Y!.*8,:!01,!4,!8,:+,!]!3:*>7:-!`!.=7!375!282!;*.5,:@2!/7.5!47!8:7/18-*.!J:7.^7-5,C!
!!NO!MC!<,5;7:8,5!3,.5,G8G-4!01=-4!5,!;*.8:,/-8!,.!7JJ-:+7.8!47!/-58-.;8-*.!,8!4=1.-*.!/,!4=B+,!,8!/1!;*:35!71!+*+,.8!/,5!Méditations!H!NC!<,5;7:8,5!3,.5,G8G-4!01=-4!,58!F!7!;*.8:7/-;8-*.!,.8:,!;,5!/,1E!86?5,5!/7.5!47!;*::,53*./7.;,!7@,;!)4-57>,86!H!!v=7-+,:7-5!,JJ,;81,:!4,!3:*Q,8!+,.8-*..2!;-G/,5515!37:!/,5!7.74F5,5!/,!8,E8,5!/,!<,5;7:8,59!,.!7F7.8!;,5!01,58-*.5!,.!8L8,C!! II.l'examencritiqueportantsurlarelationentreladistinctionetl'uniondel'âmeetdu corpsd anslesMéditationsetlesObjectionetRéponse"*++,.8!<,5;7:8,5!8:7-8,G8G-4!4,5!/,1E!86?5,5!/,!47!/-58-.;8-*.!,8!/,!4=1.-*.!/,!4=B+,!,8!/1!;*:3 5!/7.5!47!O,!Méditation!H!v=7- +,:7-5!;*.5-/2:,:!;,5!/,1E!86?5,5!,.!:,53,;87.8!4=*:/:,!/,!47!3,.52,!/,!<,5;7:8,5C!<=7>*:/9!*.!;*++,.;,:7!37:!3:,./:,!1.,!;*.5;-,.;,!7-a{,!/,!;,!3:*>4?+,9!31-5!*.!7.74F5,:7!47!O,!MéditationC!)8!*.!7JJ-:+,:7!,.!;*.;415-*.!4=,E-58,.;,!/,!/,1E!.781:,59!/=73:?5!'*t*:*NNC!v=7-+,:7-5!J-.74,+,.8!+*.8:,:!01,!4=7JJ-:+78-*.!/,!47!/*1>4,!.781:,!/,!4=6*++,!/2J-.-8!1.,!3-58,!01-!3,:+,8!/,!3,.5,:!47!:,478-*.!,.8:,!47!/-58-.;8-*.!,8!4=1.-*.!/,!4=B+,!,8!/1!;*:35!/7.5!4,5!MéditationsC!! II-1.laconscienceduproblèmedela6eMéditationD,!3415!a:7./!3:* >4?+,!01,!5*14?@, !3*1:!.*15!47!O,!Méditation!,58!/,!;*+3:,./:,!3*1:01*-!<,5;7:8,5!-.8:*/1-8!-;-!47!01,58-*.!/,!4=1.-*.!/,!4=B+,!,8!/1!;*:35C!&4!,58!;,:87-.!01,!<,5;7:8,5!-.8:*/1-8!;,88,!;*.;,38-*.!/,!4=1.-*.!8*18!Y!;*13!/7.5!47!O,!MéditationC!)8!-4!,58!5w:!7155-!01,!<,5;7:8,5!41-G+L+,!4,!:,;*..7g8!4*:501=-4!3:2;-5,!\!]!Q,!.=7-!0175-!:-,.!/-8!/,!;,88,!/,:.-?:,!b4=1.-*.d!`C!<1!;*139!47!;*.;,38-*.!/,!4=1.-*.!8,44,!01=,44,!J-a1:,!/7.5!4,5!Méditations!J7-8!3:*>4?+,C!%,18!L8:,!;,:87-.5!3*1::7-,.8!3,.5,:!01,!47!;*.;,38-*.!/,!4=1.-*.!5=,58!2;7:82,!/1!>18!01,!<,5;7:8,5!7@7-8!J-E2!71E!Méditations9!;7:!4,!>18!/,!;,8!*1@:7a,!,58!/,!/-58-.a1,:!4=B+,!,8!4,!;*:35C!h7-5!-4!+,!5,+>4,!01,!<,5;7:8,5!8:7-8,!;,88,!;*.;,38-*.!52:-,15,+,.8C!",3,./7.8!;,88,quotesdbs_dbs1.pdfusesText_1
[PDF] glc
[PDF] gle coupe prix maroc
[PDF] glidescope
[PDF] global net telecom
[PDF] globalnet gabes
[PDF] glossaire art plastique
[PDF] glossaire arts plastiques pdf
[PDF] glossaire arts plastiques réunion
[PDF] glossaire des termes comptables
[PDF] glossaire des termes douaniers internationaux
[PDF] glossaire financier français anglais pdf
[PDF] glossaire français anglais comptabilité pdf
[PDF] glossaire informatique pour les nuls
[PDF] glossaire istqb
