[PDF] [PDF] La phonologie aux interfaces: de la structure des racines et - CORE

HAL Id: tel-01133256

Submitted on 20 Mar 2015

HALis a multi-disciplinary open access

Copyright

I $#$D"#C79676:,-!"D"!"$3)7065636/1-) ),9-;0H6918<--;,64)15--471918<- ),9-;0H6918<-

64)15--471918<-

65:;9<1;;0H6918<-6<9H)31;H7:@+0636/18<-

H415-93L);;)8<-

H415-93);I;-

7670651--;!915+17-,<65;6<9 *31/);619--3):;9<+;<9-15;-95-,-:/)*)91;:

65+3<:165

6473-?1;H,-:E3H4-5;:-;01H9)9+01-

6473-?1;H:-/4-5;)3-

H64H;91-,-:;9)1;:

65+3<:165

633-+;--;;9)1;-4-5;,-:,655H-:

5=-5;)19-,-::-/4-5;:

III 9,9-,L)+8<1:1;165,-::-/4-5;:4)5-

65+3<:165-;7-9:7-+;1=-:

1 !" Des idées audacieuses, des anticipations injustifiées et des spéculati ons constituent notre seul moyen d'interpréter la nature, notre seul outil, notre seul instrument pour la saisir. Nous devons nous risquer à les utiliser pour remporter le prix. Ceux parmi nous qui refusent d'exposer leurs idées au risque de la réfutation ne prennent pas part au jeu scientifique. » p. 286 " [E]n partant d'une nouvelle idée, avancée à titre d'essai et nullement justifiée à ce stade - et qui peut être une prévision, une hypothèse, un système théorique ou tout ce que vous voulez -, l'on tire par une déduction logique des conclusions » p. 28 Karl Popper. La logique de l a découver te scien tifique. Paris : Payot, traduction 1973 [1935].

2 MOLMLPAB (IBPQARP>DBNRRK@>KAFA>QgI'>?FIFQ>QFLKg#FOFDBOABP1B@EBO@EBPNRFIPLFQRKFSBOPFQ>FOBLRFPPRARKLOD>KFPJB ABOB@EBO@EB MOmPBKQB RKJmJLFOBABPVKQElPBABPBPOB@EBO@EBP

4KBUBO@F@BKLKP>KPRQFIFQmMLROIB@>KAFA>QMRFPNRFIIRFMBOJBQ>RJLFKPABC>FOBIBMLFKQPROPBPQO>S>RUABIBPPFQRBOA>KPPLKALJ>FK BAB@LJMmQBK@BBQABIBPJBQQOBBKM BOPMB@QFSB

"BPQA>KP@BQBPMOFQNRB@BJmJLFOBBPQOmAFDmGVCBO>FRKBMOmPBKQ>QFLKPVKQEmQFNRBABJBPQO>S>RUABPALRWBABOKFlOBP>KKmBP>SB@IBPLR@FABIBPPQOR@QROBOBQABIBPJBQ QOBBKO>M MLOQ>SB@IB POB@EBO@EBP> @QRBIIBPBKMELKLILDFBBKJLOMELILDFBBQgIFKQBOC>@B>SB@I>PVKQ>UB

+L@@>PFLKPBO>mD>IBJBKQP>FPFBMLROA FOBRKJLQPROI>K >QROBMEL KLILDFNRBBQLRJLOMELILDFNRBABPOB@EBO@EBPNRBGBMOmPBKQB

/OBKLKPIBUBJMIBABI>MELKLILDFBNRBPQ@BNRBPFDKFCFBnQOBMELKLILDRB/IRPM>OQF@RIFlOBJBKQNRBIBPQIBMmOFJlQOBA>@QFLKARMELKLILDRB#LFQFIPBIFJFQBOPQOF@QBJBKQgRK@E>JMAmQRABNRFOBDOLRMBRKBFKCFKFB S>OFmQmABMEmKLJlKBPNRFMLRO@BOQ>F KP>M MBIIBKQABPFKQBOCmOBK@BP>SB@A>RQOBP@E>JMPMELKmQFNRBJLOMELILDFBPVKQ>UBBQ>@NRFPFQFLKMLROKBOBPQBONRBA>KPIBALJ>FKBIFKDRFPQFNRB#LFQFIJ>KFMRIBOABPBKQFQmPBU@IRPFSBJBKQMELKLILDFNRBP@LKkRBPBQGRPQFCFmBPM>OBQMLROIBP?BPLFKPABI>K>IVPB MELKLILD FNRB3LRQRP>DBA>KP IBO>FPLKKBJBKQALRQFIPJLQFSmPBKABELOPABI>MELKLILDFB@LKA>JKBO>FQABC>FQI>S>IFAFQmAB@BO>FPL KKBJBKQ

-BALFQFIPFKQmOBPPBONRg@BNRF MBRQnQOBBUMIFNR mBKQFlOBJBKQA>KPI>MELKLILDFBBQALK@JBQQOBAB@sQmQLRQMEmKLJlKBNRFBKQ>@EBO>FQARKBJ>KFlOBLRA RKB>RQOBI>MROBQmARO>FPLKKB JBKQMELKLILDFNRB"BPLKQIgNRBINRBPNRBPQFLKPNRFS>IBKQ>RPPFA>KPIBP

3 >RQOBPALJ>FKBPABI>IFKDRFPQFNRBNRBPQ@BNRBPFDKFCFBmQRAFBOI>PVKQ>UBI>MELKmQFNRBI>PmJ>KQFNRBBQ@

"BPAFP@FMIFKBPLKQBK@LJJRKI>I>KDRB @LJJBL?GBQABAm@LRSBOQBBQMLOQBKQPROABPMOL@BPPRP@LDKFQFCPJ>IDOmIBPOm@BKQPAm?>QP>RQLROAR@LKQBKRA BI>DO>JJ>FOBABI>C>@R IQmABI>KD>DBBQAB I>Om@ROPFSFQm@LJJBMOLMOFmQmPVKQ>UFNRBMOmQBKARJBKQ>?PBKQBBKMELKLILDFBSLFOg@BMOLMLPIBAm?>QBKQOB%FQ@E'>RPBO"ELJPHVBQ)>@HBKALCC/FK HBO

+>NRBPQF LKBPQABP>SLFOGRPNRgNRB IMLFKQ @BOQ>FKPMEmKLJlKBPMBRSBKQnQOBO>JBKmPgI>MELKLILDFBPBRIBJBKQ0RBIDBKOBA>K>IVPBPgIFKQBOC>@B>SB@A>RQOBP@LJMLP>KQBPABI>DO>JJ>FOBALFQLKBKSFP>DBOIB@>Pm@Em>KQ+>IFQQmO> QROBOBDLODBABUBJMIBPABMEmKLJlKBPNRFOmPFPQBK Q>RU>MMOL@EBPPQOF@QBJBKQMELKLILDFNRBPQBIPIBPMEmKLJlKBPALM>@FQmBQABP>KAEFBUQBOKB

/LRO@BRUNRF PBPFQRBK QA>KPI>QO>AF QFLKDmKm O>QFSBIBQVMBABNRBPQFLKPNRBKLRPSBKLKPABMLPBOgMOLMLPABI>MELKLILDFBAm@LRIBABILOD>KFP>QFLKJLARI>FOBABI>DO>JJ>FOB

4 :7DIB;IB7D= K;I?D:E

"BPQ>RPPFI>IFDKB AB@LKARFQBNRLKOBQOLRSBA>KPIBPQO>S>R UOm@BKQPPROIBPME> PBPJLOMELPVKQ>UFNRBPBKMELKLILDFB,>OSFK2>JRBIP/FDLQQ-BTBIIBKQOB>RQOBPQ>KQFIBPQSO>FNRRK?LKKLJ?OBABMEmKLJlKBPMELKLILDFNRBPNRFOmPFPQBKQ>RUQEmLOFBP@I>PPFNRBPPBI>FPPB KQ?FBK>K>IVPBOA>KPIBPBKPA RKBFKQBO>@QFLKRKFAFOB@QFLKKBIIBQLMALTKLvI>MELKLILDFBEmOFQBAFKCLOJ>QFLKPJLOMELPVKQ>UFNRBPBQKLKIFKSBOPB

+BP@>QmDLOF BP>?PQO>FQBPNRBI>PVKQ>UBJ>KFMRIBBQNRFMBRSBKQPBOBQOLRSBOBKMELKLILDFBC>@FIFQBKQABPRO@OLoQIFKQBO>@QFLK

(IKBPQKRI?BPLFKA>KP@BPBKPABOB@LROFOgABP +>MELKLILDFBBPQ@LKkRBA>KP@B@>AOB@LJJBRKB@LJMLP>KQBFKQBOMOmQ>QFSB>RJnJBQFQOBNRBI>@LJMLP>KQBPmJ>KQFNRB

4KBMLPFQFLKNRBILKOBQOLRSBAmGgA>KPIBPMOBJFlOBPSBOPFLKPABI>DO>JJ>FOBDmKmO>QFSB]3EBMELKLILDF@>I@LJMLKBKQLC>DO>JJ>OABQBOJFKBPQEBMELKBQF@CLOJLC>PBKQBK@BDBKBO>QBA?VQ EBPVKQ>@QF@ORIBP

3E>QFPFQOBI >QBP> PQOR@QROBDBKBO>QBA?VQEBPVKQ>@QF@@LJMLKBKQQL>MELKBQF@>IIVOBMOBPBKQBAPFDK>I

3E>QFPFQOBI>Q BP>P QOR@QROBDBKBO>QBA?VQEBP VKQ>@QF@ @LJMLKBKQQL>@ BOQ>FKPBJ>KQF@OBMOBPBKQ>QFLK

5 L?GBQPMELKLILDFNRBPFKAmMBKA>KQP@LJJBIBJLQMOL PLAFNRBSLFOBKQOB>RQOBP+F?BOJ>KK/OFK@B2BIHFOH-BPMLO5LDBILRABAFPQFKD RBOABPAmOFS>QF LKP@V@IFNRBPIBUF@>IBPBQMLPQIBUF@>IBPSLFO*FM>OPHV1R?>@EBQ1R?>@E!LLFGLRJnJBABALQBOABPAF>@OFQFNRBPABQVMB2/$ABNRBINRB OsIBMELK LILDFNRBNR>KAABP@LKPQFQR>KQPPVKQ>UFNRBPOB@LKKRPBQJLQFSmP@LJJBABPME>PBPPRCCFPBKQgOBKAOB@LJMQBABPC >FQP

+>DO>JJ>F OBKBKABSFBKQNRB MIRPm@LKLJFNRB Q>KAFPNRBIBJLQMOLPLAFNRBIBP@V@IBPMELKLILDFNRBPBQ>RQOBPL?GBQPABJnJBQVMB>MM>O>FPPBKQ>RJFBRU@LJJBOBALKA>KQP@C

2@EBBOMLROMIRPABAmQ>FIPPRO@BMLFKQ

$IIBQO>KPM>O>FQA>KPI>K>IVPB ABP@>P@I>PPFN RBPALM>@FQmMELKLILD FNRBBQABP>KAEFBUQBOKBBK>J>WFDEBQBIIBPNRBI>IQBOK>K@BABPSLVBIIBPE>RQBPBQABPDIFABPBQI>MOL M>D>QFLK ABIBJME>PBBUQBKPF?IBgI>O>?BJ>OL@>FK>ILOP NRBA>KPA>RQOBP@>P@LJJBI>@LJMmQFQFLKBKQOBJ>ONRBROPDO>JJ>QF@>RUIB@ELFUBPQMIRPAFP@RQ>?IB

(IBPQ@LJJR KmJBKQ>AJFPBK>J>WFDE BNRRKBSLVBIIBE>RQB PBOm>IFPB@LJJBDIFABILOPNRBIIBBPQ>RSLFPFK>DBFJJmAF>QARKB>RQOBSLVBIIB

R@>PAB=HK7=H7MNRBILKSFBKQGRPQBABJBKQFLKKBOLKMBRQ>GLRQBO>RPPF@BRUABNBKAmQORFQP7CNB7MCLR?K@EBBK?LFP?

6 MI>K@EBPBK?LFPBQ?AHK@EBSOB>R?AHM7D@EBSOB>RU

?PBOm>IF PB@BU>@QBJBKQA>KPIBJnJB@LKQBUQB LK> M>OB UBJMIB8H?@LK@>PPB78H7@DO>FKBP@LK@>PPmBPAC?CRJB7ACC7@CRJBROBQ?IAHFI>C>FQH7@IAHFICBO>

(IBPQQLRQgC>FQMLPPF?IBABUMIFNRBO@BQVMBA>IQBOK>K@BPBKQBOJBPBU@IRPFSBJBKQMELKLILDFNRBP#BPQ>FKD MMIBD>QB &RBOPPBIBQ#BII$IJBAI>LRF

/LRONRLFM>OBUBJMIBKF>"M>TBG>FBRABP@>R@EB J>OPPBOm>IFPB:KFA >"M>TB< M>OFKPBOQFLKABI>@LKPLKKB:BKQOBI>SLVBIIBARMOmCFUBD?BQ@BIIBARSBO?BJ>FPKFDF">"D>JLPB"G>FJ>O@Em>SB@ABPO>NRBQQBP OBPQBFK@E>KDmP>KP>R@RKBmMBKQElPBBKQOBI>SLVBIIBARMOmCFUB=?pBQ7PRFS>KQ4KB>K>IVPB PQOF@QBJBKQMELKLILDF NRB@LKARFO>FQgAFPQFKDR BOBK>J>WFDEBAFCCmOBKQPKFSB>RUMELKLILDFNR BPRKK FSB>RIBUF @>IMLROI>IQBOK>K@B=HK7=H7MBQRKKFSB>RMLPQIBUF@>IMLROImMBKQElPBAB@A>KP

7 =HK@7I

.KM LROO>FQ>RPPF>QQOF?RBORKOsIBPMm @FCFNRB>RUCOLKQFlOBPJLOMELILDFNRBPLRFJ>DFKBOABPGLK@QROB PgPQ>QRQMELKmJFNRBG RK@QROB MELKBJBPgI>3O>DBO LRPFJMIBJBK QRKBCLOJBA >IILJLOMEFBO>AF@>IB

%>@Bg@BQVMB ALM> @FQmME LKLILDFNRB GBAmCBKAPIB@ELFUARKB>K>IVPBgIFKQBOC>@B BKQOB MELKLILDFBBQJLOMELPVKQ>UB

"BPQA>KP@BPME>PBPNRBPLKQ@LKPQORFQBPIBPCLOJBP=HK7=H7M8H?78H7@NBK7CNB7MBQAC?7ACC7@JBKQF LKKmBPMIRPE>RQ

+BPME>PBP JLOMELPVKQ>UFNRBPMOm PBKQBKQI>S>KQ>DBAnQOBBKQFlOBJBKQJLQFSmBPBQ@LKQO>FK QBPBKABELOPAB I>MELK LILDFB

$IIBPKBMBRSBKQnQOB@OmmBPPBRIBJBKQMLROIBP?BPLFK PABI>A mOFS>QFLKMELKLILDFNRB@LJJB@BPQIB@>PM >OBUBJMIB >SB@IBP@V@IBPBK MELKLILDFBIBUF@>IBBQMLPQIBUF@>IB

4K>RQOBQ VMBABC>FQPBK >J>WFDEBNRF >MMBIIBR KB>K>IVPBgIFKQBOC>@BBKQOBMELKLILDFBBQJLOMELPVKQ>UB@LK@BOKBI>CLOJ>QFLKABImQ>Q@LKPQORFQBQPLKF KQBO>@QFLK >SB@I>J>ON RBARDBKOBC mJFKFK

8 gImQ>Q@LKPQORFQKLKM>PgJKFP?FBKgJ )BUMIFNRB@BMEmK LJlKBBK[ M>ORKBCL OJBAB@LJMmQ FQFLKD>?>OFQFNRBBKQOBABRUJ>ONRBROPDO>JJ>QF@>R U

RPBFKARKJLAlIBLvIBPJLQPPLKQCLOJmPBKPVKQ>UBBQBK@LKCLOJFQm>SB@IFAmBPBILKI>NRBIIB@BOQ>FKBPMOLGB@QFLKPPVKQ>UFNRBP>@@RBFIIBKQ ABPMLPFQFLKPD>?>OFQFNRB PGBMOLMLPBNRRK"5BPQFKPmOmPLRPK/

I>IRJFlOBAB@BPC>FQPBQABPNRBPQFLKPNRFIPPLRIlSBKQNRBPQ@BALK@NRBAB PFKQmOBPPBOgAB PMEmKLJlK BPNRFCLKQ>MM BIgABP@LKPFAmO>QFLKPBUQO>MELKLILDFNRBP"LJJBKQPB@LKPQORFQI>K>IVPBA>KPRKQBI@>AOB0RBIIBP@>QmDLOFBPBKQOBKQBKGBR,LKL?GB@QFCA>KPI>PVKQElPBNRFPRFQBPQABJLKQ OBONRRKB >MMOL@EBgIFK QBOC>@BBKQOBMELKLILDFBJLOMELILDFBBQPVKQ>UBBPQKLK PBRIBJBKQMLPPF?IB J>FPmD>IBJBKQPLRE>FQmB>SB@BKQO>JBABCLKAI>NRBPQFLKABI>K>QROBBQAROsIBABP@>QmDLOFBPNRBI>MELKLILDFBBQLRI>JLOMELILDFBMBRSBKQJ>KFMRIBO

+>@@BKQPBO>JFPA>KPIB@>AOBABI>MELKLILDFBABDLRSBOKBJBKQ*>VB+LTBKPQ>JJ 5BODK>RABQARJLAl IB"5"5+LTBKPQ>JJPROIB OsIBA BPD>?>OFQ PBQABPRKFQm P"5NRFI BP@LJMLPBKQ

"BPD>?>OFQPFKFQF>IBJBKQ@LKkRPM>O,@">OQEV @LJJBABPPRFQBPABMLPFQFLKP@LKPLK>KQFNRBPBQSL@>IFNRBPMOmAmCFKFBPNRFOBKPBFDKBKQQLRQ>RMIRPPROI>NR>KQFQmMELKLILDFNRBABPPBDJBKQPNRFIBROPLKQ>PPL@FmPAB SFBKKBKQPLRPI FJMRIPFLK ABPQO>S>RUAB&RBOPPBI

9 +LTBKPQ>JJBQ+LTBKPQ >JJABPL?GBQP @LJMIBUBPALQmPARKBPQOR@QROBFKQBOK B

+BPOB@EBO@EBP mSLIRBKQ>RMLFKQ ABMI>@BO@BPD>?>OFQPgIFKQBOC>@BB KQOBME LKLILDFBBQPVKQ>UBABPM LPFQFLKP" 5PMm@FCFNRBPVPLKQFPLImBPBQmQF NRB QmBP@LJJBABPB UMLP>KQPABQnQBPPVKQ>UFNRBP@C

1R@>OQ+LTB KPQ>JJ!BKAG>?> II>E'>FABK O?>LRF+>JMFQBIIF%>RPQ!BKAG>?>II>E

+>PVKQElPB ABJBPQO>S>R UBQIBPMBOPM B@QFSBPNRBGBALKKB gJBPOB@EBO@EBPOBQO>@BKQJ>@LKQOF?RQFLKgImQRABABI>O@EFQB@QROBABPD>?>OFQP>FKPFNRBJ>OmCIBUFLKPROIBROOsIBgIFKQBOC>@BBKQOBMELKLILDFBJLOMELILDFBBQPVKQ>UB

"BJmJLFOBPLOD>KF PBBKABRUM>OQFBP +>MOBJFl OBM>OQFBOmPRJBJBPQO>S>RUBKMELKLILDFBBQgIFKQBOC>@B>SB@I>JLOMELILDFBBQI>PVKQ>UB

)BMOBKAO>FM>OQ>RAm?>Q>RQLROABPLKPQ>QRQBKJLKQO>KQ C>FQPgI >MMRFNRBIIB@LKPQFQRBRKBOm>IFQm IFKDRFPQFNRBKm@BPP>FOBgI>@LJMOmEBKPFL KABPM OL@BPPRPABC LOJ>QFLKABPJLQPBK>J>WFDEBBQBKPmJFQFNRBJ>IDOm IBPQO>S>RUOm@BKQP BK3EmLOFBABI.MQFJ>IFQm.3M>OI>PRFQBNRFQBKABKQgOBJBQQOBBK@>RPBPLKBUFPQBK@BSLFOBKQOB>RQOBP!>Q$I4PPFPEHFK,@">OQEV/OFK@BBQ#BII$IJBAI>LRF

#BPALKKmBPLOFDFK>IBPABI>KD>DBPPB@OBQPPBOLKQMOmPBKQmBPMLROJLKQOBOABNRBIIBJ>KFlOBIBPIL@QBROPFPLIBKQA>KPIBPJLQP>J>WF DEBPABPO>@FKBPB U@IRPFSBJBKQ@LKPLK>K QFNRBPBQIBPJ>KFMRIBKQA>KPIBROPPQO>QmDFBPAB ?OLRFII>DB

10 GBAFO>FNRBINRBPJLQPBK[PROIBP@LKQO>FKQBPNRFMlPBKQPROI>AFPQOF?RQFLKABPSLVBIIBPA>KPIBPMIROFBIPBK>COL>PF>QFNRB

+L@@>PFLKPBO>P>FPFBMLROOBSFPFQBOI>QEmLOFB> MLMELKFNR BMOLMLPmBM>O&RBOPPBI +LTBKPQ>JJ +>[PBO>@L KP>@OmBgImQRABABPD>?>OFQ PBQABIBROPQOR@QR OBFKQBOKB

+>ABRUFlJB M>OQFBBUMLPBO>NRBINRBPMBOPMB@QFSBPKLRSBIIBPMLROOmFKQBOOLDBOIBPNRBPQFLKPQO>FQmBPA>KPI>MOBJFlOBM>OQFB

(IPBO>NRBPQFLKKLQ> JJBKQABI>KL QFLKAB@L JMIBUFQmBQAB@BIIBOBI >QFSBJBKQ Om@BKQBABI>DmLJmQOFBABPmImJBKQP

$K[GBUMLPBO>FIBPOmPRIQ>QPABJBPOB@EBO@EBPBK@LROPPROI>JLOMELPVKQ>UBABPMIROFBIPFKQBOKBPBQBUQBOKBPBK>O>?B J>OL@>FK

$KCFKG BMOmPBKQBO>FBK[IBPOmPRIQ>Q PMOmIFJFK>FOBPARKBmQRABILKDFQRAFK>IBPROI>@NRFPFQFLKMELKLILDFNRBI>MOBJFlOBA>KPPLKDBKOBBK>J>WFDEB

11 /1$,($1$/ 13($28-3'$2$#$231 5 47+ /'.-.+.&($ 47(-3$1% "$2

12 ">AOBQEmLOFNRBBQALJ>FKBBJMFOFNRB

7:H;J>[EH?GK;=BE87B,BPOB@EBO@E BPPBMI>@B KQA>KPRKBMBOPMB@QFSBD mKmO>QFSFPQBA BI>DO>JJ>FOBFKQBOKBBQRKFSBOPBIIBA>KPP>@LK@BMQF LKBQJLARI>F OBA>KPPLKLOD>KFP>QFLK

(IC>RAO>PBRIBJBKQMOm@FPBOMLROIBP?BPLFKP ABI>ODRJBKQ>QFLK gNRBIMLFKQ IFAmBABILOD>KFP>QFLKJLARI>FOBABI>DO>JJ>FOB@LKAFQFLKKBIBPEVMLQElPBPBQIBP>K>IVPBPMOmPBKQmBPF@FPROQLRQ@BIIBPNRFPBPFQRBKQ>RUFKQBOC>@BP

#>KPP>SBOPFLKPQ>KA>OA>MMBImB/OFK@FMBPBQ/>O>JlQOBP"ELJPHV@LJJBA>KPP> SBOPFLKJFKFJ>IFPQB>@QRBIIB"ELJPHVI>DO>JJ>FOBBPQMBKPmBBKQBOJBPABJLARIBPFKAmMBKA>KQPJ>FPFKQBO>DFPP>KQLvI>MELKLILDFB>RJnJBQFQOBNRBI>PmJ>KQFNRB>DFPPBKQ@LJJBABP@LJMLP>KQBPFKQBOMOmQ>QFSBPAB PAmOFS>QFLKPPVKQ>UFNRBP

(IBPQKLOJ>IA>KP@BPBKPABMBKPBONRBIFKQBO>@QFLKBPQRKFAFOB@QFLKKBIIBQLMALTKNRB@BOQ>FKBP FKCLOJ>QFLKPPVKQ>UFNRBPFJM>@QBKQI>@LJMLP>KQBMELKLILDFNRBBQKLKIFKSBOPB

4KLRMIRPFBROPK|RA P>FKPFCRPFLKKmPMBRSBKQnQOBmMBImPLMmO>QFLKAB-F;BB )KJ@BPQgAFOBBKSLVmP>RU@LJMLP>KQBPFKQBOMOmQ>QFSBPMELKLILDFNRBBQPmJ>KQ FNRB @BI >P>GLRQBRKB>RQOBLMmO>QFLK'EL;Km@BPP>FOBKLQ>JJBKQMLROAmOFSBOILOAOBABPJLQP

/IRPFBROPMEmKLJlKBPgIFK QBOC>@BBKQOBMELKLILDFBBQJLOMEL PVKQ>UBSFBKAOLKQgI>MMRFAB @BQQB@LK@BMQFLKABI>DO>JJ>FOBBQARQO>GBQAmOFS>QFLKKBINRBIIBPRMMLPB

+B@>O>@QlOBRKFSBOPBIABI >DO>JJ>FOBQBINRBIB @LKkLFQI>&O>JJ> FOB&mKmO>QFSBKBJ>KNRBO>M>PA>MM>O>oQOBA>KPIBPAFCCmOBKQBPMOLMLPFQFLKPNRBGBOmPRJBF@FBKM>OQF@RIFBOA>KPJ>@LKQOF?RQFLKgIEVMLQElPBD>?>OFQFNRB

13 +LTBKPQ>JJ+LTBK PQ>JJIEVMLQElPBD>?>OFQFNRBC>FQMOLDOBPPFSBJBKQPLK@EBJFKA>KPIBP>RQ OBPI>KDRBP >COL>PF>QFNRBPSLFO!BKAG>?>II>E(AOFPPFBQ+>EOLR@EFMLROI>J>WFDEB!>OFIILQ!BKAG> ?>II>E!>OFIILQBQ+>JMFQB IIFMLROIBPLJ>IF1R@>OQMLROI>C>OBQ!BKAG>?>II>E2mDmO>IMLROIBJBEOFBQJnJBBKABELOPABI>C>JFIIB>COL>PF>QFNRB!BKAG>?>II>EBQ!BKAG>?>II>E'>FABKML ROI>IIBJ>KA!O>KAiLAB"> OS>IEL MLROIB/LOQRDR>FP+>JMFQBIIFMLROIFQ>IFBK+LTBKPQ>JJMLROIBCO>Kk>FPBQIBVFAAFPE2@EBBOBQ">E>2@EBBOMLROIBQ@ElNRB

)BJBMB OJBQPAL RSOFOF@FRKBM>OBKQEl PBMLROAFOB?OFlSBJBKQI>@ELPBPRFS>KQBG>FC>FQIB@ELFU>CCB@QFCMIRPNRBIFKDRFPQFNRBARQFIFPBOQLRQ>RILKDAB@BJmJLFOBIBQBOJB>J>WFDEBBKIFBRBQMI>@BAB?BO?lOB

"BPQPLRP@BKLJNRB@BQQBI>KDRBBPQAmPFDKmBLCCF@FBIIBJBKQ>R ,>OL@ABMRFPI>@Om>QF LKBKABI(1" , (KPQFQRQ 1LV>IABI>"RIQROB J>WFDEBJ>FPPROQLRQABMRFPA>QBgI>NRBIIBI>J>WFDEB>mQmOB@LKKRB@LJJBRKBI>KDRBLCCF@FBIIBABIdQ>QJ>OL@>FK

"BPQ>RPPFPLRPI>CLOJBCmJFKFKBAB@BQBOJBQ>J>WFDEQNRBILKAmPFDKBI>S>OFmQmM>OImBA>KPIBPJLKQ>DKBPAR,LVBK QI>P

RPB KP@LJJRKmJBK Q>AJFP>J>WFDE BSBRQAFOBELJJBIF?OBRK KLJAmOFSmI FmMLRO@B OQ>FKPgI>O>@FK BkefefnQOB?O>SBFKQOmMFABBKQLR>OB DD9O9BEF[:?;8;H8ZH;LRkefPBOB?BI IBOPmSFOA>KPIBM>OIBO%FDRFD>R,>OL@LOFBKQ>I

14 +>J>WFDEBBPQRKBKPBJ?IBAB I>KDRBPNR FC>FQM >OQFBABI>C>JFIIB>COL>PF>QFNRB

$IIBBPQEFPQLOFNRB JBKQI>I>KDRBABPMBRMIBP>RQL@EQLKBPABI COFNRBAR-LOAPmQBKA>KQPRORKBPM>@BAB@FKNJFIIFLKPABHJ>II>KQALRBPQBKBPQABIL@m>K QI>KQFNRBGRPNRgI>COLKQFlOBmDVMQLIV?FBKKBBQARKLOA>RPRAABI>OFSBPRAABI>,mAFQmO>KKmBGRPNR>RJ>PPFCAR2QOLJ?LIF>R!ROHFK>%>PL

+>@>OQB@FABPPLRPQFOm BAB"E>HBO,BQQ LR@EF ALKKBRK>MBOkRAR ALJ>FKB>J>WFDEBBQABPAFCCmOBKQBPS>OFmQmPNRFIOBDOLRMB R,>OL@I>J>WFDEBBPQI>I>KDRBJ>QBOKBIIBABABI>MLMRI>QFLKPBILKIBPOmPRIQ>QPAROB@BKPBJBKQABSLFO!LRHLRP

+BMLRO@BKQ>DB>QQBFKQJnJBA>MOlP"E>HBOPLFQ >RQLROAB JFIIFLKPA>J>WFDELMELKBPPRORKBMLMRI>QFLKABJFIIFLKP

3OLFPS>OFmQmPMOFK@FM>IBPPLKQOB@LKKRBPQ>@EBIEFQ>RPRAQ>J>WFDEQ>R @BKQOBBQ Q>OFCFQ>RK LOA

+>@>OQB@FABPPLRP

15 BJMORKQmBg!LRHLRPPFQRBIBPQOLFPS>OFmQmPABI>J>WFDEB>FKPFNRB@BIIBPABI>O>?B

%FDROB1mM>OQFQFLKABPAFCCmOBKQBPS>OFmQmPABI>J>WFDEBBQABI>O>?B>R,>OL@3>@EBIEFQI>MIRPFJMLOQ>KQBAB@BPS>OFmQmPM>OIBKLJ?OBABPBPIL@RQBROPL@@RMBRKBS>PQB>FOBFK@IR>KQIBPJLKQ>DKBPAR'>RQ QI>PBQABI KQF QI>P>FKPFNRBIBPMI>FKBP>RPRA

R@RKA F@QFLKK>FOBBUE>RPFC AB@BQQBS>OFm QmKBUFPQBgIEBROB>@QRBIIBJFPgM>OQIBAF@QFLK K>FOB?FIFKDRB>O>?L>J>WFDEBAB"E>CFHMR?I FmBKMIRPFBROPQLJBPBKQOBBQBQNRBINRBPAF@QFLKK>FOBPQEmJ>QFNRBP@LJJBIB?9J?EDD7?H;:;IL;H8;IJ79>;B>?J

+(1" ,BKQOBMOBKAA>KPIB@>AOBAB PBPJFPPFLKPImI >?LO>QFLKABMI RPFBROP AF@QFLKK>FOBPBQ DILPP>FOBPABI>J>WFDEBPQ>KA>OANRFRKFCFBIBPQOLFPS>OFmQmP>QQBPQmBP>R,>OL@SLFOIBPFQBBKIFDKB

16 /LROIBP?B PLFKPABJBP OB@EBO@EBPGBJB?>PB BPPBKQFBIIB JBKQPRO J>MOLMOB@LJMmQBK@BABIL@RQBROK>QFCABQ>@EBIEFQQBINRFIBPQM>OImA>KPI>OmDFLKA D>AFO

+BAF@QFLKK>FOBA B$I,LRQ>PPF OBQIBJ>KRBIAB!L RJ>IHPRP@FQmP@LJMIlQBKQBQ@LKCFOJBK QI>I FPQBABPC LOJBPNRBGRQFIF PBPROQLRQ @BIIBPNRFPB O>MMLOQBKQ>RUCLOJBPSBO?>IBP

+BQ>NGJFQBPQRKBS>OFmQmMO>QFNRmBBKQ>@EBIEFQM>OABPCBJJBPA(PPLRHQ>KBRKSFII>DBPFQRmMOlPAB3>IFLRFKBgRKB@BKQ>FKBABHFILJlQOBP>RPRABPQA D>AFO

)BIBP> FBKPRFQB@LJMImQmBPBK >RMOlPARKBL @QLDmK>FOB +BPABRUFKCLOJ>QOF@BPPLKQLOFDFK>FOBPA(PPLRHQ>KBBQLKQQLRQBPABRUIBQ>@EBIE FQ@LJJBI>KDRBJ>QBOKBIIB

EQQMTTT

FO@>J

J>FKABU

MEM 17

+>O>@FKB@LKPLK>KQFNRB>ODRJBKQPBQ@LKQOB>ODRJBKQP+RP>DBABI>O>@FKB@LK PLK>KQFNR B@LJJBR KFQmA> K>IVPBIFKDRFPQFNRBOBJLKQBgImMLNRB ABPDO>JJ> FOFBKPJmAFmS>RUQBIP2F?>T>VEBQ (?K)FKKF NRFFKQmOBPPmPM>OI>ABP@OFMQFLKABPOmDRI>OFQmPJLOMELILDFNRBPBQPmJ>KQFNRBPBKQOBABPC>JFIIBPABJLQPBK>O>?BQOLRSBKQA>KP@BQL?GBQRKLRQFIBCCF@>@BMLRO@>MQROBO@BPOmDRI>OFQmP

)RPNRBA>KPIBP>KKmBPNR>QOBSFKDQARPFl@IBABOKFBOI>MBOQFKBK@BABI>O>@FK B@LKPLK>K QFNRBA>KPI>A mOFS>QFLKJLOMELILDFNRB>mQmI>ODBJBKQ OB@LKKRBBQPLRQBKR BM>ORKBJRIQFQRABABC> FQPBJMFOFN RBPARJLFKPA>KPI BPI>KDRBPPmJFQFNRBP

"BK BPQNR>SB@I>SlKBJBKQAB.3NRBILK>PPF PQBgRKBOBJFPBBK@>RPBOmMmQmBABPLKBUFPQBK@B

-LJ?OBRUPLKQIBPQO>S>RUNRFMOLMLPBKQABPBKM> PPBOQLRQPFJMIB JBKQ>RMOLC FQA>RQOBPRKFQm PJLOMELILDFNRBPJLFKP>?PQO>FQBPQBIPIBO>AF@>ILRIBJLQ

/OBK>KQM>OQ>RAm?>Q@I>PPFNRB>RQLROAB@BQQBKLQFLKGBAmCBKAPIFAmBNRBI>J>WFDEBC>FQM>OQFBABPI>KDRBPNRFRQFIFPBKQI>O>@FKB@LKPLK>KQFNRB?FBKNRFI>CCF@EBRK@BOQ>FKKLJ?OBABC>FQPNRFMBRSBKQ I>FPPBOMBKPBONRB@BPQR KBI>KDRBg ?>PBABJLOMELILDFBBPPBKQFBIIBJBKQ@LK@>QmK>QFSBAFCC mOBKQBBK@BI>ABPI>KDRBPPmJFQFNRBPgJLOMELILDFBQVMFNRBJBKQKLK@LK@>QmK>QFSB

#>KP@B@>AOBG>FmQRAFmBK>J>WFDEBABPMEmKLJlKBPS>OFmPFK@IR>KQIBPCLOJ>QFLKPABIFJMBOCB@QFCARMIROFBIBQIBPPQO>QmDFBPABAmDRFPBJBKQABPJLQPA>KPIBPI>KD>D BPPB@OBQP

+BPPB@QFLKPPRFS>KQBPOmPRJBKQJBP>K> IVPBPAB@BPMEmKLJlKBP 18

EDIJHK?JJ>[EH?GK;EKH[7B?J[FIO9>EBE=?GK;+BPOB@EBO@EBP>@QRBIIBPBKJLOMELILDFBBQBKMELKLILDFBOBJBQQBKQ>RDLxQARGLROIBAm?>Q@I>PPFNRB>RQLROABI>KLQFLKABO>@FKBBQABP>MI>@BA>KPI>K>IVPBABI>PQOR@Q ROBABPJLQ P

$IIBPQOLRSBKQ A>KPIBPI>KDRBP>COL>PF> QFNRBPABP>ODRJBKQPMOLMOBPgKLROOFOOBPMB@QFSBJBKQIRKLRI>RQOB>PMB@QARAm?>Q

#BM>OI>K>QROBABPLMmO>QFLKPJLOMELILDFNRBPBQMELKLILDFNRBPNRBIIBPRQFIFPBKQMLROCLOJBOIBPJLQPLRMLROSmEF@RIBOABP@>QmDLOFBPDO>JJ>QF@>IBPIBPI>KDRBP>COL>PF>QFNRBPLCCOBKQA>?LOARKAmCF>RUQEmLOFBPJLOMELILDFNRBPNRBIIBPPLFBKQABQVMB(QBJBQ OO>KDBJBKQLRABQVMB(QBJBQ/OL@BPPRPSLFO'L@HBQQg@BMOLMLPBQ/ORKBQMLRORKBPVKQElPBOm@BKQBPROI>NRBPQFLKABI>O>@FKBBKPmJFQFNRB

/LROIBPRKBPI>O>@FKBB QIBD>?>OFQPLKQgI>?> PBABI >JLOMELIL DFBAB@BPI> KDRBPPmJFQFNRBPBKMOBJFBOIFBRBKKBPBIFJFQ>KQNR>RUQO>S>RUAL?mAFBK@BDmKmO>QFSBSLFOBKQOB>RQOBP,@">OQEV'>VT>OA&RBOPPBI+LTBKPQ>JJ(AOFPPF+LTBKPQ>JJBQ%>RPQ'BSBO

.3OBJBQBK@>RPBI>KLQFLKABO>@FKBQBIIBNRBIIBBPQ@LKkRBA>KPI>K>IVPBABPI>KDRB PPmJFQFNRBP@BPQgAFOB@LJJBRKJLOMElJB >?PQO>FQBKQFlOBJBKQ@LKPQFQRmAB@LKPLKKBP

+BIB@QBROPBOmClOBO>>RQO>S>FIAB/OFK@B2JLIBKPHVMLRORKBAmCFKFQFLKAR@>AOBDmKmO>IAB@BQQBQEmLOFBBQg!>Q$IBQ4PPFPEHFK MLRORKB>MMI F@>QFLK>RPm JFQFNRBP>KP LR?IFBO,@">OQEV/OFK@BBQPR?PmNRB KQPNRFA>KPRKB>MMOL@EBMOLPLAFNRBJFKFJF PBKQmD>IBJBKQIBOsIBABI>O>@FKB@LKPLK>KQFNRBA>KPI>CLOJ>QFLKABPJLQP

#BJnJBIBPQEmLOFB PCLKAmBPPROIBPMOL@BPPRPJBQ QBKQBKOBI>QFLKIBP O>AF@>RUABPIBUlJBPBQ ABPJLQPMI RQsQNRBIBROPO> @FKBP OLKLCC KABOPLK!B>OA2QRJMBQ!IBSFKPBKQOB>RQOBP

+BAm?>Q>mSLIRm>RMLFKQAFKQmOBPPBOIBPMPV@ELIFKDRFPQBPNRFM>OABPBUMmOFBK@BPS>OFmBP 5LFO@BMBKA>KQ*O>JBOBQ3R@HBOMLRORKMLFKQABSRBAFCCmOBKQA>KPIBJnJB@>AOBQEmLOFNRB

19 LKQBU>JFKmIBPPQO>QmDFBPgI|RSOBA>KPI>@NRFPFQFLKAB@BPI>KDRBPBQI>K>QROBABPRKFQmPPQL@HmBPA>KPIBIBUFNRBSLFO%OLPQ%LOPQBO#BRQP@E!LRABI>>,>OPIBK6FIPLK/ORKBQBQ>I

(AOFPPFBQ>I

4PPFPEHFKBQ>I

BKQOB>RQOBP

+BPNRBPQFLKPNRFPBMLPBKQPLKQALK@IBPPRFS>KQBP 0RBPQ@BNRLK@LKPFAlOB@LJJBRKBO>@FKB 0RBIIBMI>@BALFQLKIRF>@@LOABOA>KPIBIBUFNR B/LRON RBIRQFIFP>QFLKJLOMELILDFNRB#>KPIBPI>KD RBPFKALBROLMmBKKBPI>O>@FKBBPQDmKmO>IBJBKQ AmCFKFB @LJJBIRKFQmIBUF@>IBJFKFJ>IBNRRKBKPBJ?IBABJLQPM>OQ>DBKQ@BNRFOBPQBARJLQ>MOlPPLR PQO>@QFLKABQ LRPIBP>CCFUBP

.KAFO>M>OBUBJMIB NRBFKH?CFKHFKH;J[FKH;C;DJFKH?OQ>DBKQI>O>@FKBFKHQ>KAFPNRB9ED9;LE?HH;9;LE?H:[9;LE?H;JF;H9;LE?HM>OQ>DBKQARJLFKPgRK@BOQ>FKKFSB>RABI>K>IVPBI>O>@FKBKLK>RQLKLJB9;L

RPBKP@I>PPFNRB@LJJBLKMBRQIBQOLRSBO@EBW2>RPPROBI>O>@FKBBPQDmKmO>IBJBKQJLKLPVII>?FNRB]>V>KQgImQ>QKLK>CC>F?IFIBJnJB>MLRO@BKQOBK>Q ROBI

$IIBI>FPPBMI>@BMOLDOBPPFSBJBKQA>KPIBPQO>S> RUABIFKDRFPQFNRBPVK@EOLKFNRBgI>KLQFLKMIRPDmKmO>IBABJLOMElJBSLFOBKQOB>RQOBP'>OOFPBQ'L@HBQQ

#BJnJBD7L

NRLKQOLRSBA>KPF;HC[78B;?CF;HC[78B;F;HC[78?B?J[F;HC[78?B?I;HMLROO>FBKQ>RPPFnQOB>K>IV PmP@LJJBABPO>@FKBP KLK>RQLKLJBP>MMBImBP>RPPFJLOMElJBPIFmP?LRKALR@O>K?BOOVJLOMEBJBPBK>KDI>FP

20 $KPmJFQ FNRBBKOBS>K@EBLK>AJBQNR BIBPJLQP >MM>OBKQmPPmJ>KQFNRBJBKQBQJLOMELILDFNRBJBKQM>OQ> DBKQRKB JnJBO>@FKB>MMBImBBK >O>?Bl7IqBLOFDFKBO>@FKBLRk?_HO>@FKB?>PB

$K>O>?BM>OBUBJMIBLKAFO>NRBA7J787FI>m@OFQA?J7p8IFSOBA7pJ?8m@OFS>FKBQC7AJ78?ROB>RM>OQ>DBKQI>O>@FKBXHQ ?Z

#BJnJB BKEm?OB RJLABOKBLK >K>IVPBO>J7IC?HœBUBJMIFBOC[I;HœJBPP>DBC7I7HœQO>KPJBQQOBBQC?CI7HœOBI>FP@LJJBFPPRPABI>O>@FKBXJPOZ

"BQQBKLQFLKABO>@FKB@L KPLK>KQFNRB>MM>O>FQAmGgA>KPIBPQO>S> RUABPDO>JJ>FOFBKPJmAFmS>RUMLOQ>KQPROI>ABP@OFMQFLKABPI>KDRBPPmJFQFNRBPI>O>?BBKM>OQF@RIFBOQBIP7B

%?J78AB2F?>T>VEBQ7B 'KDIq?O>@FKB XCŒIZBKEm?OBRXM‹IZBQPBPAFCC mOBKQB POm>IFP>QFLKPPBOSBKQ>ILOP@LJJBJLAlIBPABAmOFS>QFLK

/IRPBK@LOBPBILK">KQFKB>RA>KPIBSL@>?RI>FOBABPI>KDRBPPmJFQFNRBPI>KLQFLKABO>@FKBQOLRSBRKB>MMIF@>QFLKmSFABKQB@BSL@>?RI>FOBQLRQBKQFBOPBI>FPPBOmM>OQFOBKDOLRMBPABJLQP> MM>OBKQmPM>OPBKPBQ >V>KQRK mImJBKQO> AF@>I@LJJRK

,nJBPFPBILK!LE>PFIKV>M>PSO>FJBKQIFBRAB@LJM>OBOIBPABRU@LK@BMQFLKP@>O@EBW ">KQFKB>R I>O>@FKBP>PPL@FBgRKP@ElJBMLROAmOFSBOAFCCmOBKQBPCLOJBPQ>KAFPNRB@EBWIBPDO>JJ>FOFBKP>O>?BPI>O>@FKBPBOQPBRIBJBKQRKBCLFPA>KPI>AmOFS>QFLKKLQ>JJBKQgI>CLOJ>QFLKARC7Iq:7HBQ>R@RKB>RQOBCLOJBKBPQAFOB@QBJBKQAmOFSmBABI>O>@FKB

SB@I>Sl KBJBKQA>KPIBP>KKmB PPLFU>KQBAFUABI>MELKLILDFB >RQLPBDJBKQ>IBI>O>@FKB BPQCLOJ>IFPm B@LJJBRKJLOMElJBgM>OQBKQFl OBBUMOFJmM>OIBPOBMOmPBKQ>QFLKPJRIQFIFKm>FOBPLvILKAFPQFKDRBIBKFSB>RABI>O>@FKB

21 ABP>RQ OBPKFSB>RUJLOMEmJFN RBP,@">OQEV

+>O>@FKB XHQ?ZM>OBUBJMIB>PPL@FmBgI>JmILAFB? +>JnJBO>@FKB>PPL@FmBgI>JmILAFBFKSBOPB7

HQ?HQ?YYYYYY"5"55""55"5"Y;;YF>>FA?J7p8IFSOBA7pJ?8m@OFS>FK(IBKBPQ ABJnJBABP CLOJBPSBO?>I BPNRFPBILK,@">OQEV PL?QFBKKBKQK>QROBIIBJBKQ@LJJBIBOmPRIQ >QABI>PPL @F>QFLKABI>O>@FKBBQABNRBINRBP>CCFUBPgABPD>?>OFQPMOmPMm@FCFmP

#BPBUBJMIBP>MM>O>FPPBKQBK>

HQ?HQ?YYYYYY"5"5""55"5"YY>>A7J78[9H?H;A7pJ789EHH;IFED:H; KQmOFBROBJBKQ>RJLAlIB>RQLPBDJBKQ>ILKQOLRSBNRBINRBP>MMOL@EBPCLOJBIIBPABPC>FQPARPmJFQFNRBSLFO"ELJPHVgMOLMLPABIEm?OBRBQNRBINRBP>KKmBPMIRQsQ'>OOFP

22 @
A

KHQ?YHQ?YYYYYYY"5""5"""5"5"YY>>A7JJ78<7?H;[9H?H;DA7J78IEKI9H?H;.KSLFQ>F PmJBKQA>KP@BQVMBA >MMOL@E BPIBOsIBNRFOBSFBKQg I>O>@FKB@LKPLK>KQFNRBBQ>RUD>? >OFQPJ>FP>RPPFIB D>FKNRLC COBKQIBPOB MOmPBKQ>QFLKPJRIQFIFKm>FOBPBKQBOJBPA m@LKLJFBBQABPFJMI F@FQmABP LMmO>QFLKP

-LRPOBSFBKAOLKPBKAmQ>FI PRO@BQVMB ABOBMOmPBKQ>Q FLKPBK[ a@BP>ODR JBKQPQEmLOFNRBPP>GLRQBKQABP>ODRJBKQPBJMFOFNRBPBQMPV@ELIFKDRFPQFNRBP RO>KDABP>ODRJBKQPBJMFOFNRBPCFDROBKQIBPI>KD>DBPPB@OBQP

4KBCLOJBSBO?>IB@LJJBA7JJ78FI>C>FQ m@OFOB MBRQnQOBOBKARBFKAFCCmOBJJBKQM>OIRKB ABPCLOJBPPRFS>KQBP87JJ7AA7887JJ7887A87AA7JJ7AA78

"BQQBPQO>QmDFBAB?OLRFII>DBABPJLQPKBPQM>PP>KPO>MMBIBO@BIIBARSBOI>KBKCO>Kk>FPgI>AFCCmOBK@BMOlPNRBI>MBOJRQ>QFLKBKSBOI>KQLR@EBIBPPVII>?BPBQG>J>FPg>R@RKJLJBKQIBP@LKPLKKBPKBPLKQFPLImBPABPSLVBIIBPM>OBUBJMIBMLROB7?II;JEC8;HPBAFO> B7?II;8[JEDBKOm CmOBK@Bg RKB@E>KPLK@mIl?OBAB

23 1BK>RA

.KAFO>>RPPF:WFS>+>ODRJBKQARSBOI>KMBRQnQOB@BMBKA>KQ>QQmKRmM>OIBUFPQ BK@BBKCO>Kk>FP ARKB>RQOBCLOJB ABGBRABI>K D>DB>MMBImB@LKQOBMlQBOFBPIBPNRBIIBPLMlOBKQABPMBOJRQ>QFLKPAB@LKPLKK BPFKAmMBKA>JJBKQABIBROPSLVBIIBP

#>RQOBPBUBJMIBPABI>KD>DBPPB@OBQPNRFJLKQOBKQQLRQ>RPPF?FBK I>MBOQFKBK@BABI>O>@FKB@LKPLK>KQFNRBBK>O>?BPLKQO>MMLOQmPM>O!BOG>LRF

$K>J>WFDEBQ>NGJFQBQQ>DK>TQABR UI>KD>DBPPB@OBQ PCmJFKFKPPLKQ>K>IVPmP@LJJBmQ>KQLOD>KFPmP>RQLROABI>O>@FKB@LKPLK>KQFNRB

-LRP>SLKPJLKQOmA>KPMIRPFBROPmQRABPOm@BKQBP+>EOLR@EF+>EOLR@EF2mDmO>I>?@LJJBKQIBPIL@RQOF@BPAB@BPABRUI>KD>DBPPB@OBQPPLKQ@>M>?IBPAFPLIBOA>KPIBPJLQPABPJLOMEl JBP@LKPLK>KQFNRBPAB KFSB>RBU@IRPFSBJBKQO>AF@>IBQIBPQO>KPCL OJBKQBKPRFQ BM>OAFSBOPBP LMmO>QFLKPABAm DRFPBJBKQSLFO>RPPF#LR@E>pK >gMOLMLPARQ>DK>TQ

$K>MM>O>FPPBKQABPCLOJBPQ>@EBIEFQAmDRFPmBPBKQ>NGJFQ>BQBKQ>DK>TQ? .KMBRQ Km>KJLFKP>S>K @BOIB@>O>@QlOBMBRK>QROBIBQ JLFKPPMLKQ>KmABP@LKQOBMlQ BOFBP@LJM>OmBP>RSBOI>K

+>J>o QOFPBABP@LKQOBMlQOFBPKm@BPPFQ BABPRO @OLoQRKBKQO>oKBJBKQJmQ>IFKDRFPQFNRBPLMEFPQFNRm 24 >

7N87HBQB

bCBABI>OQF@IBAmCFKFEmOFQmABI>O>?B "BPQ>RPPFIB@>PA>KPC

87HABQD

In8HABJBQKOBPMB @QFSBJBKQJLOMElJBM>OQF@FMF>IABI >O>?BBQJ>ONRBABI>lOBMBOPLKKB MIROFBI

.KKLQBO> BKLRQOBNRBA >KPIBPCLOJBPQ>NGJFQJ?CC7fH@KfHBQJ?<<7HN@KHNQKBPQM>PEmOFQmABI>CLOJBQ>@EBIEFQKLKMIRPNRBIBFFKFQF>IA>KPJ?AA7I:n@KI:nJEKJ;IIBPCLOJBPQ>NGJFQ@LJJBK@BKQM>OJ?

PLFPBRIB@BQQBL?PBOS>QFLKPRCCFQgMOLRSBOIBUFPQBK@BABI>O>@FKBBK>J>WFDEBBQI>@>M>@FQmABPIL@RQOF@BPgIFPLIBOP>KPBOOBRO.

25 $K@BN RF@LK@B OKBIBJ>QmOFBISL@>IFNRBABPCL OJBPQ>@EBIEFQFIKBPQ@LKPBOSmKFBKQ>N GJFQKFBK Q>DK>TQ

3LRQBPIBPCLOJBPAmDRF PmBP>CCF@EB KQRKSL@>IFPJBFKS>OF>?IBFKAmMBKA>KQAB@BIRFABPCLOJBPQ>@EBIEFQ?

7

KBKQ>NGJFQBQ7BKQ>DK>TQ

OmARMIF@>QFLKgAOLFQBAB1BQ13LRQBPIBPCLOJBPAmDR FPmBPBKPBO>JlK BKQALK@>RUABRUP@ElJBPPRFS>KQPJ7G@C?JQF11>11GR11J7=D7MJ>G11>11T>11#>KPIBPABRU@>PLKL?PBOSBNRBIBJ>QmOFBI@LKPLK>KQFNRBABI>O>@FKBBPQMOmPBKQABRUCLFP1M>ODmJFK>QFLK1BQ1M>OOmARMIF@>QFLK

%>@Bg@BQVMBAL?PBOS>QFLKLK>FJBO>FQ@LJMOBKAOBMLRONRLF@BPQ1NRFBPQPVPQmJ>QFNRBJBKQDmJFKmBMIRQsQNRRKB>RQOBO>AF@>IBQ>KAFPNRB1BQ1PLKQOmARMIFNRmBP+> .KOBJ> ONRBO>NRBI>SL@>IFP>QFLKABPC LOJBPAmDRF PmBPBKQ >NGJFQF>RPRFQ IB@EBJFK>MLMELKFNRBJFPBKmSFABK@BMLROI>O>?B@I>PPFNRBM>O&RBOPPBI+LTBKPQ>JJMRFPmQBKARgA>RQOBPI>KDRBPPmJFQFNRBP2mDmO>I>R?BO?lOB!BKAG>?>II>EBQgABPI>KDRBPFKALBROLMmBKKBP>IIBJ>KAM>O BUBJMIBSLFO2@EBBO2mDmO>I

.KOBSFBKAO>PRO@BMLFKQBK[

26 OmMLKPBg@BQQBNRBPQFLKPBO>ALKKmBBK[gIL@@>PFLKABImQRABABI>PQOR@QROBABPD>?>OFQPBK>J>WFDEB

1BQBKLKPMLROIBJLJBKQNRBIBPCLOJBPQ>@EBIEFQM>OQ>DBKQ>SB@@BIIBPABQ>NGJFQBQABQ>DK>TQ RKPBRI L?GBQB7H79?D;9E DIED7DJ?GK;

"BPQ @BQQBBKQFQmIBUF@>IBNRB@BPABRUI>K D>DBPPB@OBQPJ>K FMRIBKQA>KPPLKFKQm DO>IFQmBQ gIBU@IRPFLKABQLRQ>RQOBmImJBKQMOmPBKQA>KPIBPCLOJBPQ>@EBIEFQ

+BPmQRABP PROIBPM>QELI LDFBPARI>KD>DBCLROKFPPBKQRKB>RQOBPmOFBA>ODRJBKQPMLROI>O>@FKB@LKPLK>KQFNRB

#B MIRPIBPJmQ>QE lPBPMOLARFQBPBK>O>? BKFK@IRBKQNRBIBP@LKPLKKBPO>AF@>IBPBQKLK>CCFU>IBPPRDDmO>KQ>FKPFRK>@@lPAFOB@QgI>O>@FKB@LKPLK>KQFNRBM>OBUBJMIBl?b

J ?C7pBMOL?>?FIFQmBPQOBKARM>Ol?b J ?B7pC7plM>RSOBPM>O

7plBQMFP@FKBC7

I87bM>OC7

+B@LKQO>PQBNRBMLPBI>KLQFLKABO>@FKBBKQOBIBPI>KDRBPFKALBROLMmBKKBPARKBM>OQBQI BPI>KDRBPPmJFQFNRBPA>RQOBM>OQOBCIl QB?DPPFNRBBKQOBIBPI>KD RBPgJLOMELILDFB @LK@>QmK>Q FSBBQ@BIIBPgJLOMELILD FBKLK@LK@>QmK>QFSB

$K>J>WFDEBBKOB S>K@EBIB Am?>QBPQJLFKPQO>K@Em

!LKKLJ?OBABIFKDRF PQBPSLFOBKQOB>RQOBP">KQFKB>RBQ&>II>K A>@@LOABgI>O>@FKBRKPQ>QRQ@LJM>O>?IBg@BIRFNRBIIBQFBKQBKPmJFQFNRB

27 +BAm?>Q BPQMOL?>?IBJBKQIF mg@BNRB I>J>WFDEBMLPPlABRKPVPQlJBJLOMELILDFNRBEV?OFABPFQRmgI>COLKQFlOBABI>JLOMELILDFBKLK@LK@>QmK>QFSBABQVMBPmJFQFNRBBQABI>JLOMELILDFB@LK@>QmK>QFSBABQVMBFKALBROLMmBK

#RK@sQmLKP>@@LOAB g>K>IVPBOM>OBUBJMIB :B@LRSOB?:B7FI>@LRSB OQ7C:BKKR>DBPBQ?C:B@LRSBO@IB@LJJBmQ>K Q@LKPQFQRmPARKBO> @FKB:BgI>NRBIIBP>GLRQBKQABPJLOMElJBP@LKPLK>KQFNRBPBQSL@>IFNRBP

AMD7PBMBK@EBO7CP@

KCP>QQO>MBO

DELJJB7@D?M7@D?M

DM>IJFBO?IBC?IBC

7DMLFPPLK

(IC>RQAFOB@BMBKA>KQNRB@BQVMBA>ODRJBKQPS>RQ>RPPFMLROI>O>?BQ>KQFISO>FNRBI> JLOMELILDFB KVBPQM> PNRFKQBOKB

+BPMIROFBIPBUQBOKB PPLKQ>RPPF OmM>KARPBK>O>?BNRBK>J>WFDEBBQIBPCLOJBPSBO?>IBPVOBkLFSBKQABPMOmCFUBPABPPRCCFUBP>RPPF?FBKNRBABPFKCFUBP

EDJH;

28 @>O>@QlOB>?PQO>FQBQPLKFK@>M>@FQmgOBKAOB@LJMQBIB@>Pm@Em>KQARQO>KPCBOQABMOLMOFmQmPMOLPLAFNRBPBKQOBI BP?>PBPBQIBPCLOJBPAmOFSmBP

+>ODB JBKQOBMOFPA>KPIBPQO>S>RU>ALPPmPg.3SLFOM>OBUBJMIB!>Q$I4PPFPEHFK@BQ>ODRJBKQPBGRPQF CFB>RSRABI>K>Q ROBJnJBABI>QEmLOFBNRFI>S>K@BBQNRFBPQRKBQEmLOFBAFQBPROC>@FPQBLvIBPAmOFS>QFLKPLRQMRQLRQMRQMOL@lABKQBKQOBCLOJBPMELKmQFNRBPBKQFlOBJBKQPMm@FCFmBP

.3PBPQ>QQBImB BKLRQOBgCLROKFOABPAFPMLPFQ FCPNRFMBOJBQQBKQ ABOmFKQBOMOmQBOIBP@E>KDBJBKQPJLOMELILDFNRBPFKQBOKBP>RJLQBKQBOJBPALMmO>QFLKP@LK@>QmK>QFSBPDmOmBPM>OABP@LKQO>FKQBPAB?LKKBCLOJ>QFLK

/>OJF@BIIBP@FIBP@LKQO>FKQBPAFQBPA>IFDKBJBKQ&BKBO>IFWBA IFDKJBKQSLFO,@">OQEV/OFK@BNRFAmQBOJFKBKQM>OBUBJMIBI>AFPQOF?RQFLKABI>CCFUBKCBKQ>D>ILDRKBI>KDRBABP/EFIFMMFKBP

MM>O>FPP>KQQ>KQsQgI>J>ODBD>R@EBARJLQ@LJJBA>KPKC7H7BBKPBFDKBOQ>KQsQgIFKQmOFBRO@LJJBA>KPIKCKB7Jm@OFOB@BQ>CCFUBMBRQSLFOP>AFPQOF?RQFLKBUMIFNRmBM>OOmCmOBK@BKLKM>PgNRBINRBOBMOmPBKQ>QFLKJLOMELILDFNRBM>OQF@RIFlOBJ>FPPFJMIBJBKQgRKB@LKQO>FKQBNRFPBILK,@">OQEVBQ/OFK@B>IFDKBI>J>ODBD>R@EBABI>CCFUBPROI>J>ODBD>R@EBARO>AF@>IPQBJ

/ELKLILDFNRBJBKQM>OI>KQ.3OBSFBKQ>SB@@BQVM BAB AmOFS>QFLKPgIRKFIFKm>OFP>QFLKABI>@E>oKBQBIIBNRBIIBBPQ@LKkRBA>KP2/$BK@LKPFAmO>KQ

29 NRBQLRQBLMmO>QFLKJLOMELILDFNRB@LKPFPQBPFJMIBJBKQg>IFDKBOABPCOLKQFlOBP

'>JJLKABQ,@">OQEV/OFK@B

#>KPIBJnJBB PMOFQ#BII $IJBIA>L RFPL RQFBKKBK QNRBK>J>WFDEBABOFSBACLOJPMOBPBOSB>PJR @E>PMLPPF?I BQEBIBKDQEL CQEB @LKPLK>KQPFKQEBPLRO@BCLOJP

+BIB@QBRO >RO>KLQmNRBI>O>@FKB@L KPLK>KQFNRBAm MLROSRBABQLRQBPMm@FCF@FQmMOLPLAFNRBKBMBRQM>POBKAOB@LJMQBAB@BQVMBABMEmKLJlKBP

"BP>ODRJBKQP>S>K@mP@LKQOBI>O>@FKB@LKPLK>KQFNRBPLKQFIPMLRO>RQ>KQPRCCFP>KQPMLROBKOBGBQBOIBUFPQBK@BJnJB$PQFIPLRE>FQ>?IBABKMOLP@OFOBQLRQBOmCmOBK@BA>KPI>K>IVPB"BPQIBPLOQFIBPQSO>FABQLRQBMOLMLPFQFLKQEmLOFNRB 4KBQBKA>K@BBK@LOBOBKCLO@mBM>OABPOB@EBO@EBPOm@BKQBPAFQBP?FLIFKDRFPQFNRBPNRFMOsKBKQRKBMELKLILDFBMI>QBCI>QMELKLILDV

30 AnQOBOBJMI>@mBgQLRQJLJBKQM>ORKB> RQOBMOLMLPFQF LK>RMLRSLFOBUMI F@>QFCPRMmOFBRO

$K@LOBC>RQFIAmJLKQOBONRBA>KPIBPI>KDRBPBKNRBPQFLKI>?>KALKABI>O>@FKB@L KPLK>KQFNRBOlDIBMIRPAB MOL?IlJBP NRFIKBK@OmBBQNRBI> DmKmO>IFP>QFLKABPAmOFS>QFLKPg?>PBABJLQP OBKA@LJMQB >RPPF?FBKABP@>PMOL?ImJ>QFNRBPNRBKLRPSBKLKPAmSLNRBONRBABQLRPIBP>RQOBP@>PLvI>O>@FKB@LKPLK>KQFNRBOBPQBMBOQFKBKQB

.KMBRQ M>OBUBJMIBPBABJ>K ABONRBIIBM>OQL@@RMBKQIBPSBO?BPAmKLJFK>RUALKQOBKABKQ@LJMQBIBPQO>S>RUAB!>Q$IBQAB4PPFPEHFKA>KPIBKPBJ?IBABPAmOFS>QFLKPBKEm?OBR$PQFIKm@BPP>FOBABDmKmO>IFPBOI>AmOFS>QFLKg?>PBABJLQPgQLRQIBPVPQlJBMLROI>PFJMIBO>FPLKNRRKB@I>PPBABSBO?BPOmPFPQBKQgI>K>IVPBBKQBOJBPABO>@FKBBQABD>?>OFQPPFABPRO@OLoQ@BQQB@I>PPBBPQ@LKPQFQRmBBKDO>KABM>OQFBABJMORKQPgABPI>KDRBP@LK@>QmK>QFSBP#>KPIBJnJBBPMOFQNRBC>FOBBK>O>?BABPMIROFBIPNRFKEmOFQBKQM>PABI>JnJBNR>KQF QmSL@>IFNRBNRBIBROP@LOOBPMLKA> KQPPFKDRIFBOP>ILOPJnJBNRFIPOBPPBJ?IBKQM>OC>FQBJBKQ>RU@> PAFP@RQmPM>O'>JJLKABQ ,@">OQEV/OFK@BPRPJBKQFLKKmP RQOBJBKQAFQ@LJJBKQIBP>K>IVPBPABPROC>@BBUMIFNRBO>FBKQNRBI>SLVBIIBBKQOBIBPABRUABOKFlOBP@LKPLKKBPBPQILKDRBA>KPIBPMIROFBIPAK<<7pHJm@Om>KQPBQHKAA7p8M>PP>DBOPJ>FP?OlSBA>KPIBPPFKDRIFBOP@LOOBPMLKA>KQPA7pOD RJBKQmSLNRm A>KP/ORKBQPBILKIBNRBII>K>IVPBg?>PBABJLQPALFQ@LKPQ>JJBKQAm@FABOPFRKJLQ7BPQAmOFSmARKJLQ8LRIFKSBOPBLKMBRQPBABJ>KABOBK>O>?BIBNRBIABA7J78?B7[9H?JBQO7AJK8FIm@OFQBPQIBJLQAB?>PBBQIBNRBIBPQIBAmOFSm

2FIP>SlOBNRBIBP@>POm@> I@FQO>KQPPROIBPN RBIPI>K>IVPBPROC>@FPQBA BPQEmLOFBPg@LKQO>FKQBPPLKQNR>KQFQ>QFSBJBKQ?FBKFKCmOFBROP>RU@>PNRFQLJ?BKQPLRPI>K>IVPBg?>PBABO>@FKB@LKPLK>KQFNRB>ILOPFIPALFSBKQnQOBQO>FQmPMLRO@BNRFIPPLKQ@BPQgAFOBABP@>POm@>I@F QO>KQP

#>KPIB@>PAB IEm?OBR ,LLOB">KQTBII

31 K>MR@LIIB@QmNRBSBO?BPAmKLJFK>RUJLKLPVII>?FNRBP

+BPQEmLOF BPPROC>@FPQBP.3BKQnQBMLROPRFSBKQIBJVQEBA RKB>MMOL@EB ELIFPQFNRBNRF@LKPFAlOBIBPC>FQPABI>KDRB@LJJBRKBPLJJBFKAFSFPF?IBLRARJLFKPBPP>VBKQABJLAmIFPBOARKBJ>KFlOBRKFNRBBQRKFSBOPBIIBI>JLOMELILDFBABQLRQBPIBPI>KDRBP V@LJMOFPIBPm JFQFNRB

$KC>FP> KQ>FKPFBIIBPAm@OFSBKQMIRPNRBIIBPKBUMIFNRBKQ

$IIBPM>PPBKQg @sQmABDmKmO>IFP>Q FLKPNRFCLKABKQABPQEmLOFBPOmCRQ>?IBPBQC>IPFCF>?IBP@LJJB>RQ>KQA>RQOBPQEmLOFBPA>KPBQBKABELOPABI>IFKDRFPQFNRB

#FCCmOBKQBPSBOPFLKPAB.3BUFPQBKQ

$IIBPRQFIFPBKQABPLRQFIP CLOJBIP>A>MQ>?IBPgSLILKQmMLRO>K>I VPBONRBINRBPC>FQPFIPRCCFO>FQGRPQBABC>FOBPL KJ>O@EmM>OJFIBP@LKQO>FKQBPBUFPQ>KQBPLRJnJBABK@OmBOABKLRSBIIBPMLROMBRNRBIIBPOBKQOBKQA>KPIBP@E mJ>DIL?>IABI>QEmL OFB

.KMBRQPBABJ>KABOA>FIIBROP@BNRF KBPQM>PBUMI F@>?IBA>KPRKQBI@>AOBBQBKNRLF .3BPQCLK@FlOBJBKQAFCCmOBKQBARJLAlIBDmKmO>QFC@I> PPFNRB2/$

+BOFPNRBABPRODmKmO>QFLKNRBMOmPBKQBKQIBPOlDIB PIFKm>FOBP@I>PPFNRBPDRBQQB>RPPFI>@LJMRQ>QFLKg?>PBABP@LKQO>FKQBPSFLI>?IBPBQEFmO>O@EFP>?IBP

+BKLJ?OBA B@>KAFA>QPDmKmOmPBQIBKLJ?OB AB@LKQO>FKQBPML PPF?IBPBQF J>DFK>?IBPOBPQBKQAFCCF@FIBJBKQNR>KQFCF>?IBP>RMLFKQNRBILK MBRQPBABJ>K ABONRBIBPQIB@LxQ@LDKFQFCKm@BPP>FOB>RQO>FQBJBKQ@LJMRQ>QFLKAB@BQQBPLJJBAFKCLOJ>QFLKP

4KQO>S>FIOm@BKQ PEIBVBQ>I

IFSOBRKFKSBKQ>FOB

32 ABP@LKQO>FKQBPMOLMLPmBPGRPNRBKA>KPIB@>AOB.3

#>KPPLK>K>I VPBABPSBO?BPAm KLJFK>RUBKE m?OBRSLRIRB@LJJBRKB>IQBOK>QFSB>RU>MMOL@EBPg?>PBABO>@FKBBQABD>?>OFQ4PPFPEHFKJBQBK|RSOBAFU@LKQO>FKQBP

+BAmOFSmBPQmS>IRmM>OJFERFQ@>KAFA>QPgI>FABABKBRC@LKQO>FKQBPSFLI>?IBPBQEFmO>O@EFPmBPSLFO4PFPEHFKMLROI>IFPQBABP@LKQO>FKQBPBQIBROEFmO>O@EFB

.K MBRQPBAB J>KABO>RM>PP>DB MLRON RLFPBRIBJBKQERFQ@>KAFA>QPPLKQmS>IRmP

,LVBKK>KQNRBINRBPMOFK@FMBPAB?LKKBCLOJ>QFLKKLQ>JJBKQI>PPL@F>QFLKRKgRKABD>R@EBgAOLFQBI>O>@FKBPBIFBA>KPRK@>PgI>SLVBIIB7BQ>RD>?>OFQ"5"BQA>KPI>RQOB@>P>RUSLVBIIBPFBBQ>RD>?>OFQ"5"5"SLFO&LIAPJFQEPROIBJLAlIB>RQLPBDJBKQ>IBQ,@">OQEVMLRORKB>MMI F@>QFLKgI> JLOMELILDFBAmOFS>QFLKKBIIBBKPmJFQ FNRB

+>PPL@F>QFLKABPPBDJBKQP ABD>R@EBgAOLFQB BUMIFNRB KLQ>JJBKQI>MOLM> D>QFLK ABI>@LKPLKKBO>AF@>IBCPROI>MLPFQFLK"IF?OBgP>AOLFQB

33 >

AJAJYYY"5""5"5"YYY>FB(I>MM>OQF BKQ>RIB@QBRO ABGRDBOI>NRBIIBABPABRU>MMOL@EBPBPQ I>MIRPm@LKLJFNRBBQI>JLFKP@LJMIBUB

+B@>O>@QlOBMOmQBKAR>?PQO>FQABI>O>@FKB@LKPLK>KQFNRBKBABSO>FQ BKMOFK@FMBMLPBO>R@RKMOL?IlJBgI>AmJLKPQO>QFLKBQ>RO>FPLKKBJBKQP@FBKQFCFNRB

+>O>@FKB@LKPLK>KQFN RBKBPQA>FIIBROPM>PIBPBRI L?GBQIFKDRFPQFNRBNR>IFCF>?IBA>?PQO>FQSLFO>RPPFI BP@>QmDLOFBPSF ABPIBP >O?OBPPVKQ>UFN RBPBQ@

/LPBOIBUFPQBK@BAL?GBQP>?PQO>FQPNRFKBPLKQM> PL?PBOS>?IBPAFOB@QBJBKQJ>FPPBRIBJBKQgQO>SBOPIBROPJ>KFCB PQ>QFLK PC>FQM>OQFBFKQmDO>KQBARO>FPLKKBJBKQP@FBKQFCFNRB

0RFAABPMOLQLKPBQABPKBRQOLKP QLK?BPLFKABIBPSLFOMLROBK>@@BMQBOIBUFPQBK@BLRGRPQBAmQB@QBOIBROPPFDK>QROBP+>O>@FKB@LKPLK>KQFNRBJ>IDOmPLK@>O>@QlOB>?PQO>FQBQPLKFK@>M>@FQmgBUMIFNRBOQLRPIBPC>FQPNR LKPLRE>FQBO> FQNRBIIBBUMIFNRBOBPQBRQFIBMLROOBKAOB@LJMQBARKDO>KAKLJ?OBABMEmKLJlKBPALKQ@BRUNRFPLKQOBI>QFCP>RUI>KD>DBPPB@OBQPBK>J>WFDEB

34 +BPABRUPB@QFLKPPRFS>KQBPPBOLKQ@LKP>@OmBPgRK>RQOBQVMBABMEmKLJlKBNRF@LK@BOKBI BPO>@FKBP@LKPLK>KQFNR BP

"BIRF ABP@LKQO>FKQBPNRL?PBOSBKQ@BPO>@FKBPBKPmJFQFNRBBQBK>J>WFDEB

.KBU>JFKBO>I>@LJMLPFQFLKPBDJBKQ>IBABPO>@FKBPBK>J>WFDEBBQIBP@LKQ O>FKQBPAFPQOF?RQFLKKBIIBP>RUNRBIIBPBIIBPPLKQPLRJFPBP

,;9>;H9>;I&?D=K?IJ?GK;I:;0?D9;DD;I +>EOLR@EF,LE>JBA%ILOBK@B5FII LFKD (KQOLA R@Q FLK ,;9>;H9>;I&?D=K?IJ?GK;I:;0?D9;DD;I +>EOLR@EF,LE>JBA%ILOBK@B5FII LFKD

1>@FKBBQ1> AF@>I

$AFQFLK,;9>;H9>;I&?D=K?IJ?GK;I: ;0?D9;DD;I/OBPPBP 4KFSBOPFQ>FOB PAB5FK@BKKBP +>EOLR@EF,LE>JBA .KQ EBFKQBOK>IPQOR@QROBLC 3>PEIEFVQ!BO?BOQOF@LKPLK>KQ>IOLLQP &?D=K?IJ?9#DGK?HO +>EOLR@EF,LE>JBA # >KPJK:;I:;F>ED[J ?GK;;J:;B?D=K? IJ?GK;8;H8ZH;I"ECC7=;W(7^C7&EK7 B?

2>IBJ "E>HBO JFK>,B QQLR@EF&mO>OA/EFIFMMPLKBAP

,24PPRK>J>WFDE2$+ %$AFQFLKP/BBQBOP/>OFP+LRS>FK

35 +>EOLR@EF,LE>JBA/EFIFMMB2m DmO>I

,LOMELI LDF BD>?>OFQFNRBBQ>MLMELKFBA>KPRKI>KD>DBPB@OBQ CmJFKFKBK? BO?lOBQ>@EB IEFQ ,;LK;7D7:?;DD;:;&?D=K?IJ?GK;

ECCKD?97J?EDI+>EOLR@EF,LE>JBA/EFIFMMB2mD mO>I

1LLQ>KA3BJMI>QBJLOMELILDV$SFABK@BCOLJPB@OBQI>KD R>DBPFK !BO?BO>KA,LOL@@>K O>?F@

+>EOLR@EF,LE>JBA/EFIFMMB2mDmO>I !&)1->KQBP +>EOLR@EF,LE>JBA

3>PEI EFVQ!BO?BOQOF@LKPLK>KQ>IOLLQP ?FK>OV?O>K@EFKDEB>A@LJMIBJBKQPQOR@QROB

!&)1

3LJPu-LOSlDB

+>EOLR@EF,LE>JBA "LKQ O>FKQBPAB@LL@@ROOBK@BA>KP IBPO>@FKBPQOF@LKPLK>KQFNRBPAR?BO?lOBQ>@EBIEFQ $EKHD[;:v[JK:;IEH= 7D?I[;F7HB;B78EH7JE?H;OD7C?GK;:K&7D=7= ;;D>ECC7=;W(7^C7&EK7 B?J> OP+VLK 36
#BI>K>QROBABP@LKPLKKBPO>AF@>IBP

#BP@>P@I>PPFNRBPKLQmPM>O&OBBK?BODBQ?FBK>S>KQM>OIB PDO>JJ>FOFBKP JmAFmS>RUOBMOFPBKPRFQBM>O,@">OQEV ?JLKQOBKQNRBIBPO>@FKBPPmJFQFNRBPJ>GLOFQ>FOBJBKQQOF@LKPLK>KQFNRBPKB@LKQFBKKBKQG>J>FPABRUME>OVKD>I BPŒBQzKF ABRU@LKPLK KBP>AG>@BK QBPFABKQFNRBPLRELJLOD>KFNRBPFPPRBPA RKBABP @I>PPBPPRFS>KQBPI>?F >IBPL@@IRPFSBP@LOLK>IBPCOF@>QFSBP@LOLK>IBPPLK>KQBP@LOLK>IBPSmI>FOBPBQDRQQRO>IBP

/>OBUBJMIBLKKBQOLRSBM>PABPCLOJBPABQVMB:?:;CJ>FPPBRIBJBKQABQVMB:?C;CIBPNRBIIBPPFKQBOMOlQBKQA>KPIB@>AOBABI>MELKLILDFB>RQLPBDJBKQ>IB@LJJBFPPRBPABO>@FKBP?FIFQlOBPALKQI>ABRUFlJB @LKPLKKBL @@RMBABRUMLPFQFLKPPNRBI BQQ>IBP,@">OQEV

)BO>MMBIIB@FABPPLRPI>OBMOmPBKQ>QFLKAB:?C;CFKFQF>IBJBKQALKKmBBK?AJY"5"5"YYFB+BQVMBAB@LKQO>FK QBPNRBKLRPSBKLK PAmSLNRBOPBUMIFNRBC>@FIBJBKQgI>FABABOBMOmPBKQ>QFLKPJRIQFIFKm>FOBPLvI>O>@FKB >MM>O>oQPRORKBIFDKBJLOMEmJFNRB>RQLKLJB

#>KPIBJnJBLOA OBAFAmB PLKMBRQ @FQBOABP@>PA >PPFJFI>QFLKBQABAFPPFJFI>QFLKABP>CCFUBPBKCLK@QFLKABI>K>QROBABP@LKPLKKBPNRF@LJMLPBKQI>O>@FKB

37 :K>O>@FKBNRFI>@@RBFIIB@LKQFBKQRKB@LKPLKKBI>?F>IBM>OBUBJMIB@E>OFLQPBAFQD7HA78JBQKLKM>PC7HA78J

C7PKpAJJLOQFBOMOBRSBNRBIBP@LKPLKKBPO>AF@>IBPBQIBPSLVBIIBP> MM>OQFBKK BKQgABR UKFSB>RUJLOMEmJFNRBPA FPQFK@QP

=?8?BPLFPBKC> @BNRF PBOm>IFPB:D=?8?B<

4K? OBC>MBOkRAB@BJLAlI BAB PVII>?>QFLKPBO>ALKKm BK[

+BIB@QB ROMLROO>PB OmCmOBO>RQO>S>FILOF DFK>I+LTBKPQ>JJBQg2@EBBOMLROMIRPABAmQ>FIP

C=?8?BD=?8?BJKD?IYYYY"5

DK@RFPJ>FPPP

DPSBKAPj

bjjCC>FPELKQBBQkk

DkCP>RSB+>EOLR@EF

4KBUBJMIBBPQOBMOmPBKQmBKI

bjjCjbjjCPˆzˆJYY;Y"5 (IBKBPQABJnJBABPBJMOR KQP>RCO> Kk>FP9>;C?I;BQI79E9>;PLKQOBKARBPM >OjKC?kKRFPBQQBBQj7AKj

38 "BQVMBAB@LKQO>FKQBPQO>AFQFLKKBIIBJBKQ>QQOF?RmgIBCCBQAR]/OFK@FMBAR"LKQLRO.?IFD>QLFOB`SLFO&LIAPJFQEJ>FP>RPPF+B?BKMLROIBPQLKPBQ,@">OQEVMLROIBPO>@FKBPPmJFQFNRBPKBPBIFJFQBM>P>RU@LKPLKKBPJ>FPPmQBKA>RPPF>RUSLVBIIBP

&OBBK?BODBQ*ROV...LTF@WO>MMLOQBKQIFK@LJM>QF?FIFQmABPSLVBIIBPE>RQBPFBQRA> KPRKB JnJBCLOJBPm JFQFNRB

#BJnJB,@">OQEV PLRQFBKQNRBQEBEFDEDIF ABPM>KAOJ>V>IPL ?BPR?GB@QQL@LL@@ROOBK@BOBPQOF@QFLKP $KOm>IFQmRKBPRFQBFRLRRFBPQMOLEF?mBKLKM>PA>KP RKBJnJBCL OJBJ>FPA>KPRK JnJBJLOMElJBSL@> IFNRB

$Q PFA>SBKQROB@BPABRU SLVBIIBPPBOBQOLRSBKQ@sQBg@sQBI>PPF JFI>QFLKLMlOBM>OBUBJMIBCK:K?HKDABSFBKQCK:?pHKDAFOB@QBROGK?B7ALKKBG?pB7žFI>mQmAFQŸBQ7@M7pCI>FPPBMI>@Bg7@@7pCžGLROPŸSLFO!O>JB

-LRPOBSFBKAOLKPPRO@BP@LKQO>FKQBPSL@>IFNRBPBK[KLRPMOLCFQBOLKPAB@BQQBL@@>PFLKMLROM>OIBOABP>IQBOK>K@BPSL@>IFNRBPA>KPIBPMIROFBIP>COL>PF>QFNRBPBQIFSOBONRBINRBPOmCIBUFLKPPROIEVMLQElPBAR@EBJFK>MLMELKFNR BMOLMLPmBM>O&RBOPPBI+LTBKPQ>JJ

/>O>FIIBROPI>J>WFDEBPBAFPQFKDRBARPmJFQFNRBBQABI>O>?BBKM>OQF@RIFBOM>OABP@LKQ O>FKQBPAF PQOF?RQFLKKBIIBPARK>RQOBL OAOB

$IIBPMLOQBKQPROI>K >QROBJnJBABP@LK PLKKBPNRF @LJMLPBKQI>O>@FKB +> PB@QFLKPRFS>KQB IBROBPQ@LKP>@OmB

AjK@>IAI@FKB?FB KCLOJmBBK>J>WFDEB@LKQFBKQ>RJLFKPRKBPLK> KQBPLRSBK QMOm@mAmBARKBL?PQOR>KQB

-LRPOBMOBKLKPMLROIBP?BPLFKPABI>K>IVPBI>IFPQBABPO>@FKBPAOBPPmBBK>KKBUBA>KP+>EOLR@EFBQIBP L?PBOS>QFLK PNRFPVO>M MLOQBKQ

ABPO>@FKBP

39 BU>JFKmBP@LKQFBKKBKQ>RJLFKPRKBPLK>KQBI>NRBIIBBPQMOm@mAmBA>KPABP@>PARKBL?PQOR>KQB

+BPBUBJMIBPBKFIIRPQOBKQIBPQVMBPABSBO?BPOBQBKRP@I>PPmPBKNR>QOBDOLRMBPPBILKI>K>QROBL?PQOR>KQBLRPLK>KQBABIBRO@LKPLKKBP.MLROL?PQOR>KQB2MLROPLK>KQB))-?POmQ>IBOWDOQO>SBOPBODWJ@LRMBOHˆJBKQOBO)-)HOC>QQ>@EBOHOWI>?LROBOzOD?OxIBOCOAAmJ>KDBO-)-JDOJLFPPLKKBOIHJ>OOFSBOJA•IBKQBOOBOKHOPBIBSBO)--HKRPBMBK@EBO?OFmDO>QFDKBOUJOCBOJBKQBOŠIRMBOAOB+BPO>@FKBPBKQFlOBJBKQ@LKPQFQRmBPABPLK>KQBP@LJJBHC?nQOBC>QFDRmBQCBKnQOBJLRKBOB MOmPBKQBKQ M>PMIRPA BABPALKKmBP

40 $QPFR KBPLK>KQB>MM>O>oQBK MLPFQFLKFKFQF>IBRKB> RQOBSFBKQ BKMLPFQFLKCFK>IB@LJJBA>KPC=HBQBACPBRIBJBKQO>@FKBP@LKQOBSFBK KBKQg@B QQBDmKmO>IFP>QFLK

$KPLJJBI> PLK>KQB MBRQ>MM>O> oQOBA>KP KFJMLOQBNRBIIBMLPFQFLKABI>O>@FKBBQA>KPIm@O>P>KQBJ>GLOFQmABP@>PBIIBBPQMOm@mAmBARKBL?PQOR>KQB

+BQ>?IB>R@FABPPLRPOmPRJBIBPL? PBOS>QFLKPNRBKLRPSBKL KPAmKRJmOBO3>?IB>RKLJ?OBABO>@FKBPABPBU@BMQFLKP RJLFKPRKB2

RMIRP2 RJLFKPRKB2BPQMOm@mAmBM>ORKB. &v>OFEJ>ZI;J\J;

9ECFB[C;DJ/>OQ>KQAB@BPL?PBOS> QFLKP G>F MOLMLPm+>EOLR@EFNRBIBPO>@FKBPQOFIFQlOBPMLPPlABKQRKBPQOR@QROBEFmO>O@EFNRB?FK>FOBALQmBARKBQnQBBQARK@LJMImJBKQ

$IIBPM>OQ>DBKQIBJnJBK|RAA>KPI>O?OB +BQOLFPF lJBPBDJBKQ NRF@LJMLPBI>O>@FKBBPQ RKPBDJBKQI7J;BB?J;>QQ>@Em>RK|RAPRMmOFB RO

/>OPBDJB KQP>QBIIFQBG BKQBKAPNRFIMBRQ 2ROIBPKLQFLKPAB]QnQB`BQAB]@LJMImJBKQ`BQIBRORP>DBBKMELKLILDFBSLFOBKQOB>RQOBP KABOPLKBQ KABOPLK$TBKA>KPIB@>AOBABMELKLILDFBABAmMBKA>K@B*>VB+LTBKPQ>JJ5BODK>RAA>KPIB@>AOBABI>MELKLILDFBAR&LRSBOKBJBKQBQ'>JJLKABQ/OFK@BA>KPIB@>AOBABI>MELKLILDFBJmQOFNRBBQ>@@BKQRBIIB

41 >MM>O>oQOB>RPPF?FBKgD>R@EBNRgAOLFQBAR@LRMIBQnQB@LJMImJBKQ

/LROFIIRPQOBOIBJLAlIBNRBINRBPRKBPABPO>@FKBPBKPLKQOBMOmPBKQmBPBK+>CLK@QFL KABQnQBABI>O>@FKBB PQ>QQOF?Rm BgIL?PQOR>KQB BKQLROmB FJJmAF>QBJBKQgD>R@EBABI>PLK>KQB

$K>M M>O>FPPBKQIBPO>@FKBPAmMLROSRBPAL?PQOR>KQBP@LJJBHC?nQOBC>QFDRm BQCBKnQOBJLRNRFMLROO>MMBIOBMOmPBKQBKQPBRIBJBKQABPO>@FKBPBU>JFKmBPSLFO>KKBUB+>EOLR@EF

2FIEVM LQElPBBPQGRPQBLKP>QQBK Ag@BNRBIBPO>@FKBP?FIF QlOBPPLF BKQ@LJMLPmBPPBRIBJBKQARKBL?PQOR>KQBPRFSFBARKBPLK>KQB

RQOBJBKQAFQARKBQnQBPRFSFBABPL K@LJMImJBKQ

2ROI BPO>@FKB P?FIFQlOB PBU>JFKmBPSLFO>KKBUB+>EOLR@EF L KQI>CLOJB .2BU

BIPE>?FIIBODIM>PPBOI>KRFQHPq@>PPBO

CBJLKQOBODKnQOB@RFQ

42 LRAL?PQOR>KQBPBU

Ii>@EBQBOiP@OBRPBO

#>?LOA FIPDmJFKBKQQLRPI>PB@L KAB@LKPLKK BO>AF@>IBgIFK>@@LJMIF $KPRFQBFIP>CCF@E BKQI>SLVBIIB >BKM LPFQFLKCF K>IBgI>@@LJMIF@LJJBgIFK>@@LJMIF

0R>KQ>RUO>@FKBPJLKL IFQlOBPLK P>QQBKAg@BN RBIIBPPLFBKQCLOJmBPPBRIBJBKQAL?PQOR>KQBP@BPQgAFOBABI>@LKPLKKBQnQB

+BPNRBINRBPO>@FKBPAB@BQVMB >QQBPQmBPBK >J>WFDEBQ>@EBIEFQPLKQBCCB@QFSBJBKQQL RQBPCLOJmBPAL?PQOR>KQBPM>OBUBJMIB=nQOBAAM>PPBOM>OjjJ>KDBOBQ

+L?PQOR>KQBBPQBKNRBINRBPLOQBgI>O>@FKB@BNRRKBSLVBIIBBPQgI>PVII>?BLRBK@LOB@BNRRKSBO? BBPQ >R5/ABI>JnJB C>kLKNR RKBPVII>?BMB RQKnQOB@LKPQFQRmBNRBARKBSLVBIIBBQNRRK5/MBRQKnQOB@LJMLPmNRBARKSBO?BRKBO>@FKBMBRQKnQOB@LKPQFQRmBNRBARKB@LKPLKKBL?PQOR>KQB

$KABELOPARALJ>FKB>J>WFDEBIB?BII>@LLI>I>KDRB>JmOFKAFBKKBM>OImBBK"LILJ?F B!OFQ>KKFNRB@LKKRBmD>IBJBKQMLROQLImOBOA BPDOLRMBP@LKPLK>KQFNRBP@LJMIBUBP>MMLOQBRK>ODRJBK QPRMMImJBKQ>FOBBKC>SB ROABIEVMLQElPBPLK>KQBL?PQOR>KQB

!>DBJFEIO>MMLOQBBKBCCBQNRBA>KP@BQQBI>KDRBI>PRFQBL?PQOR> KQBPLK>KQBGLRBRKOsIBB PPBKQFBIA>KPIL OD>KFP>QFLK

43 PVII>?FNRBABPPBDJBKQP

3LRQB PRFQBAB PBDJBKQPNRFKBOmMLKAM>P>RM>QOLK PVII>?FNRBL?PQOR>KQBPLK>KQBSLVBIIB@LKPLKKBOBPQBKLKPVII>?mB

/IRPFBROPmQRABPM>OJFIBPNRBIIBP!BKPLRH>P!LRHLRP">AF"E>HBO"E>JF#BII$IJBAI>LRF'>JJ>KB)B??LRO+>EOLR@EF+LR>IF/EFIFMPLKPBPLKQFKQmOBPPmBPg@BPRGBQBPPBKQFBIIBJBK QBKQ>@EBIEFQ

">OgI>AFCCmOBK@BABP>R QOBPS>OFmQmP ABI>J>WFDEBLvI>DmJFK>QFLKg IFK>@@LJM IFQLR@EB FKS>OF>?IBJBKQI>@LKPLKKBJmAF>KBABI>O>@FKBB KQ>@EBIEF Q@BPQQ> KQsQI>@LKPLKKBJmA F>KBNRF DmJFKBQ>KQsQIFKFQF>IB

quotesdbs_dbs22.pdfusesText_28