managers construe and experience flexible working arrangements while successfully fulfilling their arriving at a definition which will be used in this thesis
Previous PDF | Next PDF |
[PDF] Flexible Working Practices - RePub, Erasmus University Repository
Hamburg, Germany, represent recent examples of such innovative offices In the current dissertation, I therefore extend the definition of spatial flexibility to also
[PDF] Flexible working as an effective tool of organisational commitment
12 jui 2017 · investigate the relationship between flexible working and employee (c) My thesis will be included in electronic format in the College
[PDF] Flexible working as an effective tool of organizational - DiVA
The thesis suggests the hypothesis, according to the literature review and flexible working definition followed by the history of office design, types of flexibility,
[PDF] FLEXIBLE WORK ARRANGEMENTS: - CORE
culture and structure By using this perspective, this thesis conceptualises flexible work ar- rangements as to which degree the employees are able to choose the
[PDF] Cranfield University - CORE
managers construe and experience flexible working arrangements while successfully fulfilling their arriving at a definition which will be used in this thesis
[PDF] Flexible work arrangements,job satisfaction and performance
A Dissertation submitted in Partial fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of Flexible work arrangements allow employees to balance their sample size of 92 employees were requested to participate in the survey, 62 of these
pdf Flexible Working Individual Performance and Employee
flexible working policy rather than actual flexible working (e g Budd & Mumford 2006; Wood de Menezes & Lasaosa 2003) and few studies have considered actual individual performance This paper in contrast analyses the association between having a flexible working arrangement
Flexible working qualitative analysis - GOVUK
What is flexible working? 15 2 Individual 17 Employees value flexible working 17 Flexible working helps attract and retain employees 18 Demand for flexible working varies by gender
Searches related to flexible working dissertation example
flexible working practices on employees’ engagement and satisfaction analysing the differences within employee’s age and gender on a household appliance business in Brazil The themes assessed in this research were flexible working hours flexibility on uniform wear and remote working
[PDF] flexible working hours literature review
[PDF] flexible working hours policy pdf
[PDF] flexible working model atkinson
[PDF] flexible working request considerations
[PDF] flexible working research uk
[PDF] flexible working standard chartered
[PDF] flexion composée béton armé
[PDF] flexion rdm exercice
[PDF] flight operators in india
[PDF] flight tracker map
[PDF] flights coronavirus international
[PDF] flights to mauritius during covid 19
[PDF] flipster login
[PDF] flixbus paris bercy la rochelle
Cranfield University
Deirdre Anderson
An investigation into the experiences of managers who work flexiblySchool of Management
PhDCranfield University
School of Management
PhD Thesis
2007-2008
Deirdre Anderson
An investigation into the experiences of managers who work flexiblySupervisor:Dr Val Singh
September 2008
© Cranfield University, 2008. All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced without the written permission of the copyright holder. iABSTRACT
This thesis explores the experiences of managers who work flexibly. Flexible working policies are prevalent in all organizations in the UK because of the legislation giving specific groups of parents and carers the right to request flexible working. Many organizations extend the policies to all employees, yet the take-up is not as high as expected, particularly among staff at managerial levels. This thesis explores how managers construe and experience flexible working arrangements while successfully fulfilling their roles as managers of people. The exploratory study consisted of interviews with eight managers with unique flexible working patterns. Analysis of the interview transcripts identified concepts of consistency and adaptability. Consistency refers to meeting fixed needs from the work and non-work domains, and adaptability refers to the adjustment of schedules to meet the changing demands from those domains. The concepts of consistency and adaptability were further explored in the main study which is based on interviews with24 women and 10 men who held managerial positions and had a flexible working
arrangement which reduced their face time in the workplace. The research offers three main contributions to the literature. At a theoretical level, I propose a model which demonstrates how individuals use consistency and adaptability to meet the fixed and changing demands from the work and non-work domains. This model extends understanding of the complexity of the segmentation/integration continuum of boundary theory, explaining how and why managers use flexible working arrangements as a means of managing boundaries and achieving desired goals in both domains. Four distinct clusters emerged among the managerial participants in terms of the type and direction of adaptability, indicating the range of strategies used by managers to ensure the success of their flexible working arrangements. A detailed description of managers' flexible working experiences is provided, adding to what is known about the role of manager through the exploration of the enactment of that role when working flexibly. ii Keywords: Consistency and adaptability; segmentation; integration; boundary management; promotion; work life balance iiiACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
My doctoral journey has been a "long and winding road" and the completion of this thesis has only been possible with the help and support of the many colleagues, friends and family members who have offered encouragement and patience over the years.I would like to give special thanks to:
Val Singh, my supervisor, and Sue Vinnicombe for giving me this opportunity and encouraging me every step of the way, especially when I doubted myself. The members of my review panel, Clare Kelliher and David Partington, for ideas and challenges and steering me in the right direction. Judy Greevy and Claire Green who helped to arrange the data gathering phases of the study, the participants who gave up their time in their flexible but busy schedules, and the HR staff in the various organizations who helped coordinate the interviews. My colleagues and friends, both past and present, in the International Centre for Women Leaders, especially Ruth Sealy, Elena Doldor and James Collins, for the many conversations, questions and ideas, as well as shared laughter, and a touch of insanity! My friends, Peter Craig and Judith Meighan, whose quiet comments gave me the push I needed, and colleagues Clare Bradshaw, Mary Cover and Sheila McAlpine for their support and continued friendship.And most of all I would like to thank my family.
My mother and my late father (Pat and Kevin Fitzgerald) both left school as young teenagers without any formal qualifications, but with a love of learning and a belief in the value of education. They worked hard to ensure that my siblings and I had the opportunities they would have loved, and have always been so proud of our educational (and other) achievements. I think this one surpasses their dreams. My sister Eithne Fitzgerald began her MA as I began my PhD and we have had many long phone conversations about the intricacies of grounded theory, literature reviews and coding structures, when nobody else would have been interested. She has also iv helped with proof reading and still remained interested (and successfully completed herMA long ago!).
My three children were 14, 12 and 10 when I began this undertaking, and have grown into wonderful young adults. Clare, Declan and Paul have had their own learning while I have been busy pursuing my doctoral studies. Aside from school and the assortment of A levels, AS levels and GCSEs they have passed between them in recent years, they have also had some "life lessons" in cooking their own tea, becoming adept with the washing machine and the iron, and generally becoming more self-sufficient as I spent more time on my PhD and less with them. They all have demanding academic challenges in the immediate future and I hope to give them the love, patience and support they have given me. My husband Rob has been my greatest supporter throughout my studies and I simply couldn't have done it without his love and enduring encouragement. This thesis is dedicated to my family, with love and thanks. vTABLE OF CONTENTS
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS ............................................................................................iii
TABLE OF FIGURES ....................................................................................................ix
TABLE OF TABLES....................................................................................................... x
1 Introduction .............................................................................................................. 1
1.1 Aim of the research........................................................................................... 1
1.1.1 Personal interest........................................................................................ 1
1.1.2 Background to the research...................................................................... 2
1.1.3 Research gap............................................................................................. 3
1.1.4 The research questions.............................................................................. 5
1.2 Outline of thesis................................................................................................ 5
1.3 Conclusion........................................................................................................ 7
2 Literature Review................................................................................................... 11
2.1 Flexible working............................................................................................. 11
2.1.1 Formal and informal flexible working.................................................... 14
2.1.2 Case relevant definition.......................................................................... 15
2.2 Organizational reasons for the introduction of flexible working ................... 16
2.2.1 A business case for flexible working...................................................... 17
2.2.2 Implementation of Flexible Working Policies........................................ 18
2.3 The role of manager........................................................................................ 21
2.4 Managers who work flexibly.......................................................................... 26
2.4.1 Reduced load or reduced hours .............................................................. 28
2.4.2 Gender differences in managers working flexibly ................................. 32
2.4.3 Summary of knowledge of managers working flexibly......................... 34
2.5 Flexible working and work life integration.................................................... 34
2.6 Management of the boundary between home and work................................. 37
2.6.1 Boundary theory............................................................................................ 39
2.7 Conclusion...................................................................................................... 41
3 Methodology........................................................................................................... 47
3.1 Introduction .................................................................................................... 47
3.2 Theory and research........................................................................................ 47
3.3 Philosophical approach................................................................................... 48
3.4 Positivism versus interpretivism..................................................................... 51
3.4.1 Positivism............................................................................................... 51
3.4.2 Epistemological stances for qualitative enquiry..................................... 52
3.4.3 Social constructionism............................................................................ 54
vi3.5 Research strategy and design.......................................................................... 56
3.5.1 Reflexivity.............................................................................................. 58
3.5.2 Validity and reliability............................................................................ 59
3.5.3 Choice of semi-structured interviews..................................................... 60
3.6 Fieldwork........................................................................................................ 62
3.6.1 Rationale for including women and men................................................ 62
3.6.2 Phase one - the pilot study..................................................................... 63
3.6.3 Phase one: Selection of participants....................................................... 64
3.6.4 Phase one: Data collection...................................................................... 65
3.7 Fieldwork - phase two.................................................................................... 66
3.7.1 Phase two: Selection of participants....................................................... 66
3.7.2 Phase two: Data collection ..................................................................... 67
3.8 Data analysis................................................................................................... 68
3.8.1 Transcription, coding and analysis......................................................... 68
3.8.2 Template analysis................................................................................... 68
3.8.3 Use of NVivo software........................................................................... 71
3.8.4 Presentation of the findings.................................................................... 71
4 An exploration of managers' flexible working arrangements (FWAs).................. 75
4.1 Demographic details....................................................................................... 76
4.1.1 Consistency and adaptability.................................................................. 78
4.2 Work life balance (WLB)............................................................................... 82
4.2.1 Boundary management........................................................................... 85
4.2.2 Reciprocal exchange............................................................................... 89
4.3 Career.............................................................................................................. 91
4.3.1 Desire for further progression ................................................................ 92
4.3.2 Performance measurement ..................................................................... 93
4.3.3 Visibility/invisibility............................................................................... 94
4.4 Supervisory responsibilities............................................................................ 96
4.5 Discussion....................................................................................................... 99
4.6 Directions for research in main study........................................................... 103
5 Findings (part 1)................................................................................................... 107
5.1 Demographics............................................................................................... 108
5.1.1 Unique flexible working patterns......................................................... 112
5.2 Strategies for maintaining flexible working arrangements........................... 116
5.2.1 Consistency and adaptability in FWAs ................................................ 116
5.2.2 Coordination and support..................................................................... 120
5.2.3 Changes to FWAs over time................................................................. 123
5.3 Flexible working and the integration of work and life................................. 126
5.3.1 Time with family.................................................................................. 127
5.3.2 Work life balance.................................................................................. 130
5.3.3 Boundary management......................................................................... 133
5.4 Discussion..................................................................................................... 135
vii5.5 Summary of findings (part 1)....................................................................... 139
6 Findings (part 2)................................................................................................... 143
6.1 Summary of roles of managers..................................................................... 144
6.2 Supervisory relationship............................................................................... 145
6.2.1 Availability........................................................................................... 146
6.2.2 Delegation............................................................................................. 150
6.2.3 Managing flexible workers................................................................... 153
6.3 FWAs and promotion................................................................................... 159
6.3.1 Access to promotion opportunities....................................................... 160
6.3.2 Suitability of role.................................................................................. 163
6.4 Personal organization of work...................................................................... 168
6.4.1 Managing time in a different way when working flexibly................... 169
6.4.2 Focus and concentration....................................................................... 174
6.5 Discussion..................................................................................................... 175
6.6 Summary of findings (part 2)....................................................................... 178
7 Discussion and contributions................................................................................ 183
7.1 Summary of the research findings................................................................ 184
7.2 Managers' experiences of flexible working................................................. 185
7.3 Consistency and adaptability of flexible working arrangements.................. 188
7.3.1 Consistency and adaptability in making FWAs work.......................... 188
7.3.2 Adapting towards work domain ........................................................... 192
7.3.3 Adapting towards both work and non-work domains .......................... 197
7.3.4 An integrated approach......................................................................... 202
7.3.5 Consistent FWA ................................................................................... 207
7.4 Summary....................................................................................................... 210
8 Conclusions .......................................................................................................... 213
8.1 Summary of findings from the literature review.......................................... 213
8.1.1 Definition.............................................................................................. 213
8.1.2 Role of manager.................................................................................... 213
8.1.3 Career, gender differences and work life balance ................................ 215
8.2 Pilot study..................................................................................................... 215
8.3 Research gap................................................................................................. 217
8.4 Contributions................................................................................................ 217
8.4.1 Map of managers' experience of flexible working............................... 218
8.4.2 Model of consistency and adaptability................................................. 220
8.4.3 Consistency/adaptability clusters ......................................................... 224
8.5 Implications for practice............................................................................... 225
8.5.1 Work aspects of flexible working......................................................... 225
8.5.2 Flexible working in the greater context of managers' whole lives....... 227
8.6 Limitations of this research.......................................................................... 228
8.7 Directions for future research....................................................................... 229
viiiREFERENCES............................................................................................................. 233
APPENDICES.............................................................................................................. 251
Appendix 1: Interview schedule for pilot study....................................................... 251
Appendix 2: Interview schedule for main study....................................................... 252
Appendix 3: Coding structure................................................................................... 253
Appendix 4: Respondents' descriptions of their roles.............................................. 256
Appendix 5: Journal article....................................................................................... 263
ixTABLE OF FIGURES
Figure 5-1 Map of managers' experiences of flexible working................................... 107 Figure 5-2 Strategies for maintaining flexible working arrangements......................... 116 Figure 5-3 Consistency and adaptability of flexible working arrangements................ 118 Figure 5-4 Flexible working and the integration of work and life............................... 126 Figure 6-1 Map highlighting work aspects of flexible working................................... 143Figure 6-2 Supervisory relationship............................................................................. 145
Figure 6-3 Promotion ................................................................................................... 159
Figure 6-4 Personal organization of work.................................................................... 168
Figure 7-1 Map of managers' experiences of flexible working................................... 185 Figure 7-2 Consistency and adaptability of flexible working arrangements................ 188Figure 7-3 Adapting towards work domain.................................................................. 192
Figure 7-4 Adapting towards both work and non-work domains................................. 197Figure 7-5 An integrated approach to work and life .................................................... 202
Figure 7-6 Consistent approach to flexible working.................................................... 207
Figure 8-1 Map of managers' experiences of flexible working................................... 218 Figure 8-2 Consistency and adaptability of flexible working arrangements................ 220 Figure 8-3 Role segmentation-role integration continuum (Ashforth et al, 2000)....... 222 xTABLE OF TABLES
Table 3-1 Network of Basic Assumptions Characterizing The Subjective - ObjectiveDebate within Social Science................................................................................. 50
Table 3-2 Contrasting implications of positivism and social constructionism............... 56 Table 3-3 Fundamental differences between quantitative and qualitative researchstrategies................................................................................................................. 57
Table 4-1 Demographic details....................................................................................... 77
Table 5-1 Individual working patterns ........................................................................ 110
Table 5-2 Summary of demographic details................................................................. 112
Table 6-1 Job titles of sample....................................................................................... 144