MOROCCO
Rabat-Salé-Kénitra (2,258), Marrakech-Safi (1,206) and Fès-Meknès (1,115) In terms of infrastructure, the data shows 2101 primary health care establish-ments in the public, 831 urban health centres and 1,270 rural health centres Regarding hospitals, there are 148 across the country with a capacity of 21,692 beds Morocco has 10 psychia -
ETUDE ET MISE EN ŒUVRE DU PLAN DE DEPLACEMENTS URBAINS DE LA
Wilaya de la Région Marrakech Safi Ville de Marrakech ***** FEVRIER 2017 I ETUDE PDU DE LA VILLE DE MARRAKECH II PROGRAMME D’INVESTISSEMENT PRIORITAIRE PIP 2011-2017:
IMPLEMENTATION COMPLETION MEMORANDUM (ICM) A BASIC TRUST
partners (the MSFFDS as the central Implementing Agency, the Wilaya of Marrakesh-Safi and the Municipality of Marrakesh) As for the other project components, coordination progressively developed among the ministries and agencies in charge of urban planning, housing, transport, and
WOMEN’S POLITICAL PARTICIPATION IN A LEBANON: PERSPECTIVES
(Lebanon), Marrakech - Safi (Morocco), West Bank (Palestine), Monastir and Sousse (Tunisia) These local clusters focus on two main issues: women’s participation in political life and combating violence against women This document presents the diagnosis with regard to Mount Lebanon G MountA Lebanon Governorate (Lebanon) R eg i on f Ma rk ch
Les 2S, 26, 27 et 28 mai 2004 - ResearchGate
Wilaya de Marrakech Contribution à l'étude pharmacologique de quelques atlantique Larache-Safi est d'une importance capitale sur le plan socio-économique au Maroc:
MADAME LA DIRECTRICE DES OPERATIONS DEPARTEMENT MAGHREB
Casablanca-Settat, Marrakech-Safi, Draâ-Tafilalet et Souss-Massa Par ailleurs, certaines des activités du programme seront focalisées sur des régions spécifiques, notamment les régions de Rabat-Salé-Kenitra (marché de gros) et de Souss-Massa (centre de production de mâles stériles de cératite)
Communiqué de presse
au siège de la Wilaya de Marrakech – Safi, sous la présidence de Madame la Ministre Déléguée auprès du Ministre de l'Energie, des Mines, de l'Eau et de l'Environnement, Chargée de l'Eau L'ordre du jour de cette session comporte les points suivants : Mot d'ouverture de Madame la Ministre ;
1 6 9 - Millereponsescom
-Beni-Mellal, Azilal, Fkih Ben Salah, Safi Marrakech -_ 3 4 5 -Les Préfectures et les Provinces de la Wilaya de la Région du Grand Institut de Formation aux
[PDF] monographie de la province de safi
[PDF] conseil régional marrakech safi
[PDF] 2degt3 c'est quoi
[PDF] données démographique définition
[PDF] libellé court enseignement d'exploration
[PDF] dissertation sur l'engagement littéraire
[PDF] production agricole mondiale chiffres
[PDF] comment nourrir 9 milliards d'hommes en 2050 pdf
[PDF] évolution production agricole mondiale
[PDF] population française en 1950
[PDF] production agricole mondiale 2016
[PDF] production agricole mondiale statistiques
[PDF] population mondiale 1940
[PDF] population mondiale en 2016
1
IMPLEMENTATION COMPLETION MEMORANDUM (ICM)
A. BASIC TRUST FUND INFORMATION
Name: Promoting the Physical Accessibility of People withLimited Mobility (P128555)
Recipient Country Name: Morocco
Implementing Agency Name: Ministry of Solidarity, Women and Family Affairs, andSocial Development (MSFFDS)
TF Name: Improving the Physical Accessibility of People withLimited Mobility (PLMs)
TF Number: TF010735
Task Team Leader Name: Vincent Vesin (at the time of this ICM)TF Managing Unit: 9380 GTI05
TF Amount: US$2,850,000.00
TF Disbursement Amount: US$2,377,866.75
TF Activation Date: 16 April 2012
TF Closing Date(s): 31 January 2017
Table 1: Cost and Financing table (current financial status)Eligible
Expenditure
Category
Amount of the
Grant Allocated
(in USD)Amount
Disbursed
(in USD)Unallocated
Funds Balance
(in USD)Percentage
Disbursed
of Total1. Goods, works,
non-consulting services, services including audits, and Training.2,830,000.00
2. Operating
Costs20,000.00
TOTALAMOUNT
2,850,000.00 2,377,866.75 472,133.25 83.4%
Public Disclosure AuthorizedPublic Disclosure AuthorizedPublic Disclosure AuthorizedPublic Disclosure Authorized
2B. TRUST FUND DEVELOPMENT OBJECTIVES AND DESIGN
1. Original (and Revised) Trust Fund Development Objectives
1. The project was financed by a US$2,850,000 grant provided by Japan Policy and Human
Resources Development (PHRD) Fund to the Kingdom of Morocco (the Recipient). The project development objective was to promote the physical accessibility for persons with limited mobility (PLMs) by demonstrating its feasibility through a pilot project in Marrakesh. This objective was not revised during project implementation.2. Original (and Revised) Trust Fund Activities/Components
2. The grant agreement signed on March, 2nd, 2012 stipulated that the project consisted of the
following parts: Part A - Capacity building regarding physical accessibility of people with limited mobilityProvision of services for:
(a) Conducting an inventory of upgrade needs of urban infrastructure to improve the accessibility of people with limited mobility in Rabat, Casablanca, Oujda and Tangier; (b) Carrying out a review of the construction code to include accessibility features; (c) Carrying out a review of the existing standard designs, technical specifications and standard procurement documents used by the municipalities in Morocco to perform selected urban infrastructure works; (d) Carrying out a review of the draft guidelines on accessibility; (e) Preparing a study to recommend the normalization of public transport vehicles to include accessibility requirement; and (f) Development of training modules for local and municipal engineers regarding accessibility of people with limited mobility; Provision of consultant services for producing a national strategy on the inclusive development of persons with disability in Morocco. Part B - Pilot project to upgrade urban infrastructure in Marrakesh to facilitate the accessibility of people with limited mobility Provision of consultants' services and carrying out civil works to: (a) upgrade pedestrian space on major boulevards; and (b) upgrade to the municipality building and the Wilaya1 building to improve accessibility to people with limited mobility. Part C - Knowledge dissemination and awareness campaign Provision of consultants' services for producing a training module for non-governmental organizations (NGOs) to strengthen their advocacy on accessibility matters; Provision of training to: (a) municipal engineers, Wilaya engineers and architects on technical aspects of accessibility and on how to integrate it in transport/urban infrastructures projects; (b) NGOs to strengthen their advocacy on accessibility matters; Dissemination of accessibility knowledge to technical ministries and municipal and local engineers.1 Administrative division corresponding to a region in Morocco.
3Part D - Monitoring and evaluation
Provision of consultants' services for: (a) producing monitoring and evaluation reports on the progress of the project implementation; (b) providing fiduciary support to the implementation unit; and (c) undertaking an assessment of and preparing a report on the project success and shortfalls.Part E - Project management and administration
Provision of goods and consultants' services to strengthen the project implementation unit management, monitoring and coordination capacity (including project audit and financing of operating costs).3. The above parts were not revised during project implementation.
3. Outcome Indicators
4. The grant agreement also stipulated that the project outcome indicators consisted of the
following: i. By the end of the project, at least three cities in Morocco have included accessibility for people with limited mobility in their urban transport infrastructure projects; ii. By the end of the project, the implementation decree of the Law n°10-03 of the Recipient has been published in the National Gazette; the draft Construction Code has been prepared by the Ministry of Housing and Urban Planning; the draft strategy for people with limited mobility has been prepared by the MSFFDS; and the draft study on appropriate public transport norms for people with limited mobility has been prepared by the Ministry of Transport and Equipment; iii. By the end of the project, the inventories of accessibility improvements have been finalized in at least 4 major cities; iv. By the end of the project, at least 5 km of boulevards have been built or upgraded in Marrakesh to become accessible to people with limited mobility; v. By the end of the project, at least 5 public spaces have been upgraded in Marrakesh to become accessible to people with limited mobility;5. The above indicators were not revised during project implementation.
4. Other Significant Changes in Trust Fund Design
6. There were no significant changes during project implementation.
5. Restructuring (if any)
47. There was one restructuring to extend the closing date. Following a request from the
Kingdom of Morocco dated November 10, 2015, the World Bank, in agreement with the PHRD Fund, extended the closing date from January 31, 2016, to January 31, 2017, to allow for the delivery of the remaining activities.6. Key Factors Affecting Implementation and Outcomes
8. Project Preparation, Design and Quality at Entry. Project preparation was positively
influenced by the Government of Morocco (GoM) recent interventions and commitment. The GoM had indeed adopted an inter-ministerial action plan to promote the accessibility of people with limited mobility and had committed to improve human development indicators, in particular those pertaining to the vulnerable groups of the population. The GoM had also developed an ambitious program to improve urban transport in several major cities, a program supported by the World Bank in 2011 through the Urban Transport Development Policy Loan (DPL P115659). This anchored the project within the GoM broader dialogue with the World Bank on urban mobility and transport, including for people with limited mobility, which increased its relevance and visibility for public stakeholders. The project was therefore designed to execute the above inter-ministerial action plan through technical assistance, capacity building, knowledge dissemination, and awareness activities at national and local levels, and through pilot civil works to upgrade urban infrastructure in Marrakesh. The quality at entry is therefore rated as satisfactory.9. Implementation. The project progressed slowly in the first years of implementation, mostly
because the Implementing Agency (MSFFDS) had no previous experience with the World Bank and with this type of project. Following a World Bank advice, the Implementing Agency hired a few consultants who helped speed up implementation; among them, a seasoned procurement consultant had a major positive impact on the preparation of contracts. The Implementing Agency also benefited from extensive support from the World Bank team on operational and fiduciary matters.10. Ownership. The Implementing Agency endeavored to promote the political, social, economic
and cultural rights of people with limited mobility in general and through the project especially. The GoM was fully committed to the disability agenda at the national and international level by taking drastic measures such as the ratification of the International Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities and its Optional Protocol, of the Law n °97-13 on the protection and promotion of the rights of People with Limited Mobility, and of a new Constitution in 2011 where the notion of disability is clearly highlighted, which helped creating an enabling framework for project implementation.11. Stakeholders coordination. Pilot civil works in Marrakesh were successfully completed
thanks to the high level of cooperation already established before the project among the involved partners (the MSFFDS as the central Implementing Agency, the Wilaya of Marrakesh-Safi and the Municipality of Marrakesh). As for the other project components, coordination progressively developed among the ministries and agencies in charge of urban planning, housing, transport, and local government affairs, and the civil society and other NGOs representing people withdisabilities. These are all positive factors that had a major influence on the success of the project.
5C. OUTCOME
1. Relevance of TF Objectives, Design and Implementation
12. Relevance of objective. The project development objective was highly relevant to
needs and was consistent with the human development strategy and commitment to the relevant international convention and local laws recently adopted. Moreover, the project development objective was consistent with the World Country Partnership Strategy (CPS) with Morocco covering the 2010-2013 period, notably the section on ulnerability and social exclusion under the second pillar service delivery to .13. Relevance of design and implementation. The design of the project also proved to be highly
relevant. The project rightly combined technical assistance and pilot civil works to improve the physical accessibility of public buildings, gardens, and sidewalks for people with limited mobility, including the disabled, the elderly, and pregnant women. As intended, pilot civil works in Marrakesh had a significant demonstration effect at the national and regional levels by showcasing in a concrete way how the accessibility of urban public spaces can be improved for people with limited mobility and by raising awareness of decision-makers and citizens aboutaccessibility issues to enable the development of similar local projects (in Tétouan for instance).
Choosing the MSFFDS to implement the project proved highly relevant given that the ministry showed continuous commitment and ownership and managed to fill the moderate capacity gaps observed in the first years of implementation.2. Achievement of TF Development Objective2
14. As originally envisaged, the project conducted a number of monitoring activities: A baseline,
mid-term and project end evaluation were carried out with end results. The details are given below: The project development objective has been satisfactorily met, as shown by the achievement of the outcome indicators detailed below. Component 1: Capacity building regarding physical accessibility of PLMs:15. Inventories of accessibility improvements. This objective was to be measured by number of
cities that will include accessibility for PLMs in their urban transport infrastructure projects. By the end of the Project, the end target has been reached. Inventories have been done for four cities: Rabat, Casablanca, Oujda, and Tangier. Meanwhile, two cities have also included accessibility in their infrastructures program namely (i) Tetouan, which was able to develop a program in partnership with Handicap International and NGO Colombe Blanche and with the financial support of the European Union. (ii) Settat, was able to provide access to certain buildings open to the public and in some urban traffic corridors, as part of its Community-based Rehabilitation Program. In addition to the city of Marrakech which was selected as a pilot project for this grant. Other cities are being involved in this process. (Casablanca and Kenitra). Also, MSFFDS entered in a collaboration with the Wilayas of Tangiers, Rabat and Oujda, based on the results achieved from the urban development assessment obtained under this program.16. Draft Construction code to include accessibility measures. The end target has been
reached. Implementation decree of the Law n°10- 03 has been published in the National Gazette of the GoM. The draft Construction Code has been prepared by the Ministry of Housing and Urban Planning. The draft strategy for people with limited mobility has been prepared by the2 Annex 1 summaries Outcome Indicators and the Intermediate Indicators showing baseline and end target
6 MSFFDS. The draft study on appropriate public transport norms for people with limited mobility has been prepared by committee that included the Ministry of Transport and Equipment.17. Cities in Morocco that consider including accessibility in their urban transport
infrastructure projects. By the end of the Project, the end target was reached and 4 cities (Rabat, Tangier, Oujda and Casablanca) have included accessibility for PLMs in their urban transport infrastructure projects. These cities looked at their planning needs and worked to improve the accessibility of space and transport management. They have also included accessibility component in urban planning and improved their technical bidding requirement in all project related to urban development;18. Draft disability strategy produced. The end target has been reached. The Recipient has
produced a strategy and finalized an action plan.19. Technical Staff formed on PLM. 30 staff from the central department of the Ministry and
300 engineers and technical staff from different local municipalities (Casablanca, Agadir,
Marrakech, Fez, Oujda, Tangier and Rabat) were trained. Some of these trainings were specifically tailored and devoted to the two most concerned departments (Ministry of the Interior and Ministry of Housing and Development Planning); the training included also the Associations working on disability. These trainings were intended to help them strengthen their institutional skills.12 training modules and workshops were carried just for this purpose. These trainings were extended to cover Staff from NGO and Associations. The total at the end of the project, however, reached 400 staff trained between architects and technical staff from urban agencies, central Departments, local authorities, NGOs and Associations. Component 2: Pilot project to upgrade urban infrastructure in Marrakesh to facilitate the accessibility of PLMs:20. Accessible boulevards. By the end the project was able to go beyond the original target of
5 km and was able to upgrade 17.5 km of main streets in Marrakesh (Avenue Mohamed VI,
Avenue Hassan I, and Avenue Moulay Rachid).
21. Accessible public buildings. By the end of the Project, works were completed in two public
buildings, the headquarters of the Wilaya of Marrakesh-Safi and headquarters of the Commune ofMarrakesh.
37. Accessible public spaces. Works completed in 5 public spaces in Marrakesh: (i)
Boulvevards, (ii) headquarters of the Wilaya of Marrakesh-Safi. (iii) Headquarters of the Commune of Marrakesh, (iv) public garden of El Harti, and (v) public park of Arsat MoulayAbdesslam
Component 3: Knowledge dissemination and awareness campaigns22. Increased awareness among authorities about the inclusion of accessibility in urban
transport infrastructure through the development and dissemination of relevant regulatory and technical knowledge. By the end of the Project, the end target has been reached. The legaland regulatory texts governing the law on accessibility, law n ° 10.03 and 5 joint decrees securing
its implementation, decree n ° 2.11.246 of the said law related to the accessibility in urbanism, architecture, transport and communication were established and they are as follow: (i) Law of2003 on accessibility, (ii) Implementing decree for the 2003 law, (iii) Urban planning framework,
(iv) Architectural framework, and (v) Standards for physical accessibility. 723. In term of strengthening institutional skills to help PLMs, 12 trainings and workshops were
conducted on the subject. Approximately 400 architects and technical staff from urban agencies, local authorities, NGOs and associations have been trained. It should be noted that through these types of trainings and workshops, a number of beneficiaries throughout the Moroccan territory are able to acquire the methodological and conceptual tools to work with PLMs. These trainingcourses also targeted capacities building for associations in this field and help promote their legal
knowledge and develop their skills and support their advocacy. The trained staff can subsequently carry out diagnosis and analysis in this area of expertise and can work with and receive PLMs in their constituency or locality.24. ONG Staff formed on PLM. 100 staff were trained. The project, however, went beyond the
target of 100 Staff trained25. Distribution of guides and pamphlets. 5,000 copies were distributed. The number of guides
and pamphlet raising awareness for Handicaps and PLMs has also achieved its objective26. Awareness Workshops on PLM. 12 workshop and meetings were organized
Component 4: Monitoring and Evaluation:
27. The project conducted a number of monitoring activities: A baseline, mid-term and project
end evaluation were carried out with end results. The evaluation presented particular ways to replicate the model in other institutions such as the Ministry of Tourism and the Railway office (ONCF). Contracts for the procurement of IT equipment for project monitoring and procurement support and financial management were signed in November 2014, April 2014 and April 2013. Following the signature of these contracts, the computerized tools acquired and the consultants contracted contributed significantly to the significant acceleration of the execution rate of the procurement materials (20 contracts awarded as part of the grant) and to the preparation the financial monitoring reports of the project. They also contributed in improving knowledge of the World Bank's rules. As a result of this capacity building and support to the PMU, as well as the continued efforts of the MSFFDS and its partners, have also contributed in achieving the objectives set by the PDO of this project. Component 5: Project Management and Administration:28. MSFFDS worked in a close collaboration with the World Bank. MSFFDS as the
implementing agency in charge of day-to-day project management and worked closely with other stakeholders as well as other relevant government and local institutions such as the Wilaya of Marrakech and was the main interlocutor with all contractors. MSFFDS had established and maintained a Project Management Unit (PMU) with qualified staff to implement the project and ensure that funds, services and other resources needed are provided or facilitated in accordance with the Grant Agreement. Nevertheless, MSFFDS experienced delays in meeting the deadline in many activities and civil works in the beginning, which led to downgrading of the PDO rating. However, by March 2012, the rating was upgraded again to satisfactory following the completion of several deliverables that were produced and of the progress of civil works inMarrakech thereafter.
3. Efficiency
29. The project has been implemented efficiently and in compliance with the World
standard rules and procedures. The efficiency rating is Substantial. The resources were spent in strict observation of MNSFFDS and all procurement processes involved in project implementation were conducted in accordance to the rules. Cost overrun was prevented 8 by close follow-up from both the World Bank and the Implementing Agency, and by a large variation of the US$/MAD exchange rate between the start and the end of the project (US$ 1 ~ MAD 8.5 in 2012 against US$ 1 ~ MAD 9.9 in 2016, which represents a variation of 16 percent). This variation explains why the actual cost of the project is significantly lower than the estimatedcost. By the end of the project, almost the totality of the funds was used. Despite a slow start that
imposed extending the closing date, all planned activities were ultimately carried out with satisfactory outcomes. The Implementing Agency has provided adequate office facilities and adequate administrative support to all consultants, NGOs associations and stakeholders involved in this project. The NGOs dedicated to inclusion of vulnerable citizens have acknowledged the positive socio-economic returns of the project in that regard (albeit these returns are difficult to quantify).