Nov 6, 2019Although by definition all PWPs lack capacity to make medical decisions, their mental status can range from coma to completely awake and alert.AbstractBackgroundDecision-Making ProcessDiscussion
When decisions must be made for an incapacitated patient, priority is given to the patient's previously stated preferences. An advance directive--living will or durable power of attorney--simplifies the process.
Approaches to Making Decisions
Generally, there is agreement that “a substituted judgement or a best interest standard” is best to help guide decision making for unrepresented patients,9 although laws and policies vary in how best to uphold a best interest standard.4, 9 As the Hastings Center notes, “[t]here is as yet no consensus on the proper solution.”10 However, state laws a.
,
Can a surrogate make medical decisions if a patient is incapacitated?
In almost all states, there is a default surrogate statute that allows a physician to rely on the input of someone other than the patient to make the patient’s medical decisions.
These statutes prioritize a ranking of qualified surrogates who may be authorized to make decisions for an incapacitated patient.
,
Discussion
There is a significant debate in the literature about which decision-maker approach is best for unrepresented patients (both in the general sense and in more specific situations such as end-of-life care), with commentators falling into 2 basic camps: one that supports physicians and one that supports ethics committees.
While there is support for gu.
,
Should physicians engage patients whose capacity is impaired in decision-making?
Physicians should engage patients whose capacity is impaired in decisions involving their own care to the greatest extent possible” .
The higher the risk of a particular decision, the more important it is that the patient has appropriate decision-making capacity.
,
Single Greatest Category of Problems
Unrepresented patients are incapacitated individuals whom Pope describes as having “no available friends or family to make medical decisions as ‘default’ surrogates.”1 These patients typically fall into 3 groups: those who are homeless or mentally ill, those who by “choice or life history” do not have family or friends who could act as a surrogate,.
,
What are appropriate health care decisions for unrepresented incapacitated patients?
To establish uniform procedures to implement appropriate health care decisions for unrepresented incapacitated patients.
Appropriate health care decisions include:
- both the provision of needed and wanted medical intervention and the avoidance of medically ineffective interventions or interventions that are excessively burdensome
,
What happens if a person is incapacitated?
If you become incapacitated, either by a sudden accident or by the onset of a mental disability, someone will have to make your medical decisions that affect your well-being and perhaps even your life.
There are only two ways someone who is incapacitated can have input on their own medical decisions:
- Having an advance directive
New York law
The Family Health Care Decisions Act is a statute adopted in New York state in 2010 that had been pending before the legislature since 1994.
The statute was approved by the New York State Senate in July, 2009.
The legislation was introduced by state senator Thomas Duane of Manhattan.
It was signed into law by Gov.
David Paterson on March 16, 2010.
